4 ms·
The author is missing the forest for the trees. She argues that a specific kind of sexism (harrassment) is not sufficient to explain why so many women are force
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
The author is missing the forest for the trees. She argues that a specific
kind of sexism (harrassment) is not sufficient to explain why so many women
are forced out of their careers in STEM academia. She argues that the real
reason is that those women want to start a family and they can't do both at
once. She herself is considering leaving academia to start a family (she wants
to have two or three children). Yet she never for a moment stops to wonder why
it is that a woman like her has to make a choice between family and career,
why that is a choice that so many women have to make and why it is a choice
that so few men have to make. The answer to all that is sexism, of course, the
kind of sexism that the author is so used to she doesn't even consider it
sexism anymore, just the normal order of things. Yes, of course a young,
talented researcher _has_ to leave academia to raise her kids. Because she's a
woman. And that's what happens to women.
That is sexism. It is clear sexism, it is classic sexism and it will not go
away by pretending that it is not. And I agree very much with the author that
it is the real reason behind the constant stream of promising female
researchers leaving STEM academia.
- deyouz 7y agoI completely agree with you. I just wanted to comment to tell you that you are absolutely right.
- wilg 7y agoI agree with you. However, I think slicing up the various types of sexism in the way the author does is tactically useful for solving the issue in the fastest possible way.
- kendallpark 7y agoAgreed. How many times have you heard a man say he had to choose between his career and having kids? The fact that it is predominantly women who feel they have to choose between children and career IS institutional sexism. We say we've achieved "equal opportunity" when women are allowed to participate in career fields that had originally evolved around the male workforce. Is that parity? That women can succeed in certain industries as long as they are like men in that they never become pregnant? Jobs and industries designed by women for a female workforce would look a lot different. We need to--as much as we are able--change societal expectations, workforce expectations, and the way jobs are structured so that women are not at a disadvantage. These changes can also benefit men (eg, equal parental leave and other policies that it more affordable and feasible for people to have children). It hurts both sexes when workplaces are biased towards this archetype of a male breadwinner that is content putting in long hours away from his family. You could view this as anti-family bias, which, due to society and biology, disproportionately affects women.
- falcor84 7y ago>How many times have you heard a man say he had to choose between his career and having kids? I agree with your sentiment, but there's a big biological difference here in terms of the fertility age. As discussed in the article, this question is very urgent for women in their 30s, but men can delay reproduction until their late 40s with no major issues. As such, men don't face an ultimatum on this, the way that women do.
- kendallpark 7y ago> As such, men don't face an ultimatum on this, the way that women do. But at late 40's do these men feel like they have to choose between children and early retirement? Furthermore, most men don't just wait around until their late 40's to find a young woman to reproduce with. Human relationships aren't this calculated. You don't get to plan when you end up meeting the right person. Life happens. There are plenty of men in their 30's in committed relationships with women in their 30's. Just because he can delay reproducing doesn't mean they can. Usually this is a decision that a couple makes together. And I haven't heard a man say that he had to choose between his career and having kids because his wife's biological clock was ticking.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThere is a difference in fertility age, but men don't start leaving STEM academia in droves when they approach their fertility limits- only women do. So the part about it being urgent to have children at a certain age may be a biological difference, as you say, but the part about leaving academia to have children is not a biological difference. Or, to put it more simply: why don't men leave their careers to have children at any age?
- blub 7y agoBy the time men approach their fertility limits they either have children or have decided they don't want them. Most men don't leave their careers at any age because they have to provide for the preganant wife which can't work and needs lots of care.
- n4r9 7y agoIn full agreement. It's frustrating that increasing paternity leave and encouraging new fathers to spend more time caring for their children is not highlighted as a potential solution.
- barry-cotter 7y agoDoesn’t work. See Sweden. Men who do more parental care work and up having fewer children. People still end up costing between work and family.
- n4r9 7y agoThe goal is not necessarily to eliminate that choice, but to stop it falling disproportionately to women. By that measure, Sweden's high female labour participation suggests that it's policies are a roaring success.
- hanniabu 7y agoProbably going to get downvoted for this, but how exactly is this sexism? It seems to be just plain old biology.
- ximm 7y agoYou are defining equality via inputs. OP is defining equality via outputs, as in "society is obligated to even out the different starting conditions".
- erikpukinskis 7y agoIf it turned out that it was just women’s breasts that caused the disparity... that women who have mastectomies do just fine in Academia, would you consider that to be “case solved, situation normal, plain old biology, no sexism here”? Or would you keep looking for a solution that allows women, who have the very normal female attribute of “having breasts”, to also be catered to and be able to get work done and be compensated despite the whole “breast having” thing?
- hanniabu 7y agoTry to think of it more in this way. Men are under-represented in breastfeeding and giving birth. How come we aren't looking for solutions to these issues? It's easy to claim this is plain old biology, not sexism. We need to be looking for solutions that allow women to also contribute to child births and rearing in these ways.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoHow is it biology that only women are expected to leave work to care for children? I don't follow. Is there some biological reason why men are not expected to do the same? Do you mean something else by the "it" in "It seems to be just plain old biology"?
- enraged_camel 7y agoThe article literally talks about this. The problem is unborn children, i.e. pregnancy. That's solely a burden for the mother, who will not be able to travel and keep up with strenuous work schedules for most of the duration of their pregnancy.
- allovernow 7y ago>Yet she never for a moment stops to wonder why it is that a woman like her has to make a choice between family and career, why that is a choice that so many women have to make and why it is a choice that so few men have to make. She literally spends 25%+ of the post explaining the fertility wall that does not affect men.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThe fertility wall explains why women need to take time off to gestate and give birth before they are in their 40's. It does not begin to explain why womeen in their 20s are expected to give up a career that lasts considerably longer than either gestation or giving birth and recovering from it. That's what the author is failing to discuss. Why do women need to give up their career to _raise_ children when the business of _having_ children takes a tiny portion of the duration of a career in STEM academia. Do you have an explanation for that?
- jmpeax 7y agoI agree. We should try to guide women to date and marry men who are poorer or make less money, rather than the sexist women choosing rich guys over poor guys. After time this will reduce the pressure on men to sacrifice their life for money. If women's top mate selection criteria was how nurturing a male is rather than how much money he can provide for the family, then the problem would quickly solve itself.