5 ms·
>> I’ve got a big scholarship, and a lot of people supporting me to give me the best shot at an academic career — a career I dearly want. But, I also want a fam
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> I’ve got a big scholarship, and a lot of people supporting me to give me the
best shot at an academic career — a career I dearly want. But, I also want a
family — maybe two or three kids
Oh.
Up to this point I was keeping notes with my criticism of this article, but
this caused me to stop and reconsider.
If I may advise the author, I understand how difficult it is to balance
life decisions that seem to be at odds, but trying to deny the very reason why
those life decisions are hard to combine will not make the choice any easier.
It is stupid and sexist that you have to think of pursuing a PhD and having
two or three kids as an either/or option, when the (probably) man you'll want
to start a family with will not have to do that, even if they are also a PhD
in STEM.
This is part and parcel of the sexism that people complain about. It's not
just inappropriate behaviour by senior male academics. There is no reason why
a woman must put her career on hold to start a family when a man in the same
career does not need to. There is no reason why women are expected to be the
ones most concerned with the business of having and raising children when men
are expected to be the most concerned with advancing their careers. How is
that not sexist? How is that not the sexism that's keeping women from
advancing their careers in STEM academia?
- blub 7y agoYes, nature and sexual selection were sexist and designed women so that they have to bear the brunt of having children. That's reality, I don't see how it helps in any way to call reality sexist. And having a career is not the most awesome thing in the world. Many fathers would very much prefer to spend time with their families, but can't because they're expected to first and foremost provide for them.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoNature and sexual selection have nothing to do with it. A complete lack of societal support for women who want to have children and maintain a career in STEM academia (or similar) is all there is to it. >> Many fathers would very much prefer to spend time with their families, but can't because they're expected to first and foremost provide for them. Why do the fathers "have to provide"? Why is it so difficult for a man to stay at home and take care of the kids, after they're born (which he can obviously not really do)? Is that nature, again?
- blub 7y agoSociety is supporting women who raise children and men who provide. This worked quite fine for the history of human civilization, but it's painful for women that want to build careers and men who want to be with their families. First of all, there are very many people that are content with that situation. There is no easy solution for those that aren't, because nature does play a huge part and those 9 months and at least the first year are very important for the baby and mother. There is no way the father can provide the same emotional and physical support, so he might as well ensure that his family is otherwise taken care of.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThe father can't provide emotional and physical support in the first year of life of a child? Why? What is it that a father can't do during the first year of a child's life, other than breastfeed it, that the mother can?
- icandoit 7y agoI thought the pre-industrial role of women included crafts and gathering. I would put those under the "providing" umbrella. If we imagine that fathers taught their children to hunt and fight we would expect children to be raised those abilities too. I wonder if role specialization is more prevalent now than it used to be. Perhaps some pre-industrial societies were more egalitarian than we pretend to be today.
- hackinthebochs 7y ago>How is that not sexist? How is that not the sexism that's keeping women from advancing their careers in STEM academia? Why should the academy structure itself so that women who choose to put their attention into their families do not have a career impact? If academic positions are necessarily zero-sum, it seems impossible to correct for this without seriously unfair negative externalities? How is it that the biases inherent in collective decisions of individuals within society are the responsibility of the academy to correct for (that men tend to choose to focus on career and women on family)?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- abathur 7y agoMaybe it helps if I knock the particulars out of your case: Why should <organization> structure itself <in response to reasoned feedback from the humans who constitute it>? Do you have some clear argument for why members of an organization aren't entitled to participate in shaping it?
- hackinthebochs 7y agoI don't see how my point served to excluded a member of the academy weighing in. Note that my question was specific in the context of a zero-sum industry. I'm happy to see reasoned arguments that address this point.
- abathur 7y agoYou didn't expressly exclude it, but weighing it answers your question. The academy should structure itself in the way its members decide it should be structured.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]