3 ms·
They’re a user experience improvement over things like butterfly ballots (where part of user experience is ability to understand who you’re casting a vote for.)
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
They’re a user experience improvement over things like butterfly ballots (where part of user experience is ability to understand who you’re casting a vote for.)
Of course, the right solution would be paper ballots that aren’t stupid.
- reaperducer 7y agoOf course, the right solution would be paper ballots that aren’t stupid. Much like computer interfaces, it doesn't matter how much you dumb down the experience, there will always been dumber people. I know that sounds harsh, but part of my job is building web sites for low-education people. There's a ton of research into this problem, much of it very interesting, and some of it just downright amazing. For example, I follow a recommendation to use "Go" instead of "Search" for search submission buttons because more than one study has shown that a remarkable number of people with low education and poor computer skills will just click the Search button without typing anything in the search box because they believe the computer will actually read their mind and know what they want to search for. I shit you not. The next time you're looking at your logs and you see clicks on search buttons with no text entered in the search field, it may not be a bot. It may just be someone struggling to understand your web page.
- jessaustin 7y agoAnother solution would be to instruct the user to type something in the search box, whenever the search button is clicked on an empty box.
- reaperducer 7y agoThe problem is that instructions are text. The sort of people who think the computer will magically know what they want are the kind who won't read or understand instructions.
- jessaustin 7y agoSure, you can't be successful with every user. If they refuse to type in search terms, I don't see how substituting "Go" for "Search" improves anything.
- reaperducer 7y agoSure, you can't be successful with every user For the types of web sites I build (healthcare), I don't get to just ignore a certain group of people because they're inconvenient, or don't fit into my assumptions about how people should work or behave. I don't see how substituting "Go" for "Search" improves anything. The research shows it works. I'm going with the research, in large part because it involved actual testing on actual people and not just people in cubicles making presumptions.
- ars 7y agoThey'll read single words, but not longer sentences. I've experienced it as well, where the page literally says right there what to do, and I get calls from confused users not sure what to do. I want to say "Did you read what it says 2 inches above where you clicked?" But I never do and am just polite to them.
- nkrisc 7y ago> I don't see how substituting "Go" for "Search" improves anything. You didn't see it in the studies you ran, or are you just thinking about through your perspective instead of that of the low-education, tech-illiterate users?
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI don't doubt that, but the butterfly ballots were uniquely stupid. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidential_election_recount_in_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidentia... (There's probably a better link than generic Wikipedia, but it's all I have on hand at the moment.) I'm not bringing up this specific instance for no reason—the 2000 election caused a lot of states to redo their voting systems in a relatively short amount of time, in order to make them understandable. In many (most?) cases, that meant moving to digital voting. Something like a scantron ballot (which is digitally counted, but has a paper backup) is pretty darn good. Not perfect—some people will be confused—but if you put instructions at the the top with visual examples, it's pretty darn understandable.
- slg 7y agoA paper trail doesn't necessarily require paper ballets. Electronic voting machines can spit out a receipt to be reviewed by the voter in order to be counted in a potential audit while allowing the electronic tally to be used for initial results. With electronic machines with no paper trail, there is no way to recover from a failed or compromised machine.