3 ms·
Most Americans can't manage daily necessities (groceries, childcare, doctor's visits, etc.) without a car. Then maybe you ask why they don't have a cheaper car
by smt88 7y ago
Most Americans can't manage daily necessities (groceries, childcare, doctor's visits, etc.) without a car.
Then maybe you ask why they don't have a cheaper car.
Generally, a cheaper car costs far more to maintain. The total annual cost of ownership of a 2-year-old Camry is far lower than a 10-year-old Camry. But to get that lower cost, you have to temporarily convert more of your money into that car asset.
End result: your cash is stuck in your car, and DoorDash/Uber/whatever lets you liquidate it without selling your car.
- jiofih 7y agoThis whole economic trap is so undeniably American, it’s hard to deal with the urge to laugh mixed with drear for the people subjected to it :/
- taneq 7y agoThe trap’s there for everyone. It was almost certainly a thing in 1800s London before it was ever an “American thing”.
- amscanne 7y ago> Generally, a cheaper car costs far more to maintain. The total annual cost of ownership of a 2-year-old Camry is far lower than a 10-year-old Camry. But to get that lower cost, you have to temporarily convert more of your money into that car asset. That’s a poor example, since a Camry is notoriously reliable and needs minimal maintenance. And ten years really isn’t that old. The depreciation on the two year old car would outweigh the maintenance on the ten year old car. I believe that 5-10 years old is the sweet spot for TCO.
- taneq 7y ago> The total annual cost of ownership of a 2-year-old Camry is far lower than a 10-year-old Camry. Really? Maybe 10 years ago but cars have become remarkably good recently. I wouldn’t expect a 10 year old car to give you many problems beyond maybe the difficulty of sourcing parts.
- csharptwdec19 7y agoA lot of the push towards fuel efficiency led to tech that was in some ways or another half baked. Examples: - Direct Injection : Good for Emissions and Fuel economy, but many first generation systems have carbon build-up issues (Toyota D4S and -newer- Ford Ecoboosts don't have this problem because they have 2 sets of injectors) - All the transmissions: Ford's DCT is notorious at this point for reliability issues, Hyundai's DCT is not looking so hot so far, Nissan's CVT is a joke, Subaru's CVT is a bit of a diceroll as to whether it blows up at 100k or not, the ZF 9 speed that many manufacturers uses has issues... I'll note that SOME of these are newer problems, but most of them started happening around 10 years ago and are only finally getting smoothed out. As a counterpoint, however, the costs of all of these newer safety systems is driving up repair costs in accidents, as well as the insurance premiums for newer cars.
- o-__-o 7y agoRe the direct injection comment.. one small trick can save you $300 on engine flushes from carbon buildup: you can get an oil catch can installed for under $100 that solves this problem. But you can’t argue direct injection is worse than older fuel injection. You save more gas, get better performance (even though you don’t get as many valves), and have a cooler running engine with direct injection. That’s a net positive for the environment and your wallet over the life of your car
- beatgammit 7y agoI think it's more that dealerships usually carry newer cars, and it's a lot easier to get qualified for a loan at a dealership than for a private car sale (or at least it's perceived that way). The types of people doing Uber or Doordash aren't the type that can pay cash for a car (Uber even restricts you to newer cars last I checked). A lot of people see car payments as being "normal" and a necessary expense. I have never had a car payment, so adding $200+/month is not something I'm going to consider. However, many people don't have any real cash in savings[1] 40% would struggle with an unexpected $400 expense, 20% don't have $400 in the bank. Personally, I keep at least $500 in cash at home, and I keep enough to cover my single largest "expected" sudden expense (e.g. replace my car), or last at least 3 months without pay (6 months right now since I'm a contractor), whichever is bigger. The culture around debt is truly alarming. People pay $20k+ at 4+% to drive a car that may be more "reliable", when they could pay ~$10k at 0% (or enter your opportunity cost here for keeping cash) for a car that's approximately as reliable over ~5 years. If both follow the same depreciation curve, buying an older car with cash is way better than buying a newer car on credit. My advice is: buy a cheaper car, pay yourself whatever the car payment would've been on the more expensive car, and use that fund to replace/repair your cheaper car (never pay more than 50% of the value of your car for a repair). I would be very surprised if the majority weren't better off buying older cars with cash than newer cars with credit. - [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/20/heres-why-so-many-americans-cant-handle-a-400-unexpected-expense.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/20/heres-why-so-many-americans-...
- everdrive 7y agoDefinitely agreed. A cheaper car can be a better deal, however anyone who's poor isn't necessarily going to have the resources (time, secondary transportation, and $650 for a water pump repair) to manage it safely. A financially well-off family may have multiple cars, a garage, and some spare time. They can incur the risk of an old cheap car much more easily.