6 ms·
"In 2014–15 mineral extraction in Australia was valued at 212 billion Australian dollars. Of this, Coal represented 45,869 million, oil and natural gas 40,369 m
by azinman2 7y ago
"In 2014–15 mineral extraction in Australia was valued at 212 billion Australian dollars. Of this, Coal represented 45,869 million, oil and natural gas 40,369 million, Iron ore 69,486 million, Gold ore 13,685 million, and other metals 7,903 million." [1]
45B is still a lot of money to remove from the economy. It's less than I would have predicted (mining is only 5.8% of economy), but it's still a non-trivial amount. And 45B gets you a lot of lobbyists.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Australia
- throwaway2048 7y agoHow much money do you think climate change is going to take out of the economy? Its going to be a lot more than 45 billion.
- Mirioron 7y ago$45 billion in 1913 would be $1,179 billion today purely through inflation. Money that's available right now can be invested to make life better in the long run. That's why governments usually borrow money. I think it's not that straightforward of a situation.
- Retric 7y agoInflation does not represent an increase in value. Otherwise Zimbabwe would have turned into the world’s richest country. Further there is a weak link between resource extraction an long term economic growth. It requires a huge investment in resources and education that becomes worthless after the resource runs out. Just look at West Virginia to see the long term boons from coal mining.
- Mirioron 7y ago>Just look at West Virginia to see the long term boons from coal mining I don't understand what you're getting at. Compare the life of an average person in West Virginia today to the average person in West Virginia before coal mining and the person today is immensely better off. Technological improvements are the payoffs from investment.
- Retric 7y agoTechnology has increased standards of living everywhere, that’s independent of coal mining because the technology was developed globally. West Virginia however has fallen behind the economic development of other states without coal.
- azinman2 7y agoLong term of course. But you still need power in the mean time, as well as money and jobs. You’re also assuming those who are good at mining coal could somehow instead be good at both protecting the planet AND making as much money. That’s seldom the case.
- throwaway2048 7y agoThat assumption is not necessary to make it a huge net negative.
- bamboozled 7y agoHow many people are employed by the mining of thermal coal in Australia. You’re taking like it’s greater than 10%. I can assure you it’s not as many as you would imagine.
- pjc50 7y agoHow much has the cost of the fires been so far?
- perl4ever 7y agoSo fill in the blank. Climate change will cost X billion a year by 2050. If you don't have any idea, then it shouldn't be hard to Google an estimate from someone knowledgeable, but shouldn't you already know before you make a comment?
- ggm 7y ago45B of revenue does not translate to 45B of revenue effects in the Australian economy. it underpins GDP. next to none of it appears as either royalties or income because the companies have massive tax holidays and find ways to legally avoid the upside. Its more like 4B of effect in the functional economy than 45 and has to be set against Tourism which is probably 9B and directly into small to medium enterprise, which has massive effect on rural economy directly. Economics is dismal. 45B evaporates very quickly when you (sorry) drill down.
- Mirioron 7y agoAnd where does that $45B evaporate to? They will invest that money somewhere, which can spur on Australian business. Even if they don't invest it, it'll still be in a bank account, which means that it can still be loaned and invested. The only way I can think of where it wouldn't benefit Australia is if the investors of the mining companies are not from Australia or don't invest it in Australia. >because the companies have massive tax holidays and find ways to legally avoid the upside. Another thing to note is that quite often the way companies legal avoid taxes is by investing that money instead of taking out profits. That's still beneficial for Australia. The world doesn't only revolve around how much people pay income taxes.
- ggm 7y agoThe only way I can think of where it wouldn't benefit Australia is if the investors of the mining companies are not from Australia or don't invest it in Australia. Invest meaning purchase Australian Goods and services, and invest in Australian enterprises. Well.. Labour hire aside, there aren't many heavy machinery manufacturers onshore, and there are cost issues in sourcing construction materials fabricated onshore. The least-cost tender tends to favour Chinese and Indian sourced goods and materials, even if made with Australian steel they don't always come from domestic sources. The shareholdings are a mixture of Australian and International and there is a huge upside in shareholder benefit which includes pension funds and state investment funds, no denying that. Another thing to note is that quite often the way companies legal avoid taxes is by investing that money instead of taking out profits. That's still beneficial for Australia. The world doesn't only revolve around how much people pay income taxes. Yes, but they also seek tax holidays for sunk costs, and then seek co-funding for investment costs, so they avoid the cost of actually having to build the ports and railway lines, but get a tax holiday on the investment made: the state government has to pick up the difference. Investments are valuable for australia in the longer term, but have to be offset against longer term downside costs, like remediation of the minesite which has historically been avoided, or damage to the water table, or the groundwater, or the effect on local property prices which disadvantages local residents not engaged in mining, or the downside effect on tourism from damage to the environment.. Nothing is simple. if I over-state the evaporation of the $45B, then the positives of the $45B have been equally if not more so overstated. Much of the money is fictive, never actively enters the economy, and instead "enhances shareholder value" at the expense of actual, incurred real-world costs in the state. Mines make money: they also incur costs. Who bears the costs is not the same as who makes the money.