4 ms·
It's almost as if capital is too concentrated, to the point that the people with who control it don't know what to do with it. Oh wait. The basis of capitalism
by nicoburns 7y ago
It's almost as if capital is too concentrated, to the point that the people with who control it don't know what to do with it. Oh wait.
The basis of capitalism is markets, and the wisdom of the crowd (the "invisible hand") controlling them and making them efficient. VC's (and wealth concentration in general) are the opposite of that. They are the very-much-visible hand.
We'd solve this problem with progressive taxation and a basic income (a healthy side-helping of better funding for public services wouldn't go amiss either).
IMO, if you believe in free markets, then your position is inconsistent if you also believe if you also believe in unconstrained wealth collection. Because once that wealth is concentrated, the market is automatically distorted.
- wesammikhail 7y ago> We'd solve this problem with progressive taxation and a basic income. Interested in how you definitely know for a fact and with 100% certainty that what you suggested would solve the problem.
- inerte 7y agoThe article actually hints that there are too many VCs (with lots of money, sure) and not enough good deals. Doesn't mean your opinion is right or wrong or invalid, since I personally happen to agree with this line of reasoning, but I don't see how it fits within what the author is talking about.
- bawolff 7y agoWouldn't the obvious capitalism solution to that be - loans become very cheap because people dont know what else to do with their money. Lots of people now have access to (other people's) capital. Wealth is no longer as concentrated, wisdom of crowds prevail?
- jyounker 7y agoOr you could pay works more so that, in their role as consumers, they can buy more.
- bawolff 7y agoSure, you could do a lot of things. I'm not arguing for capitalism as a fair and moral system, just that i think that OP should account for why this isn't happening/doesnt work in order for his argument that the issue is concentration of capital (as opposed to some other issue) to make sense
- randomdata 7y agoOnce one's basic needs are met, which has a upper limit on how much needs to be purchased, what else is there to buy? In the olden days people needed to buy things to keep themselves entertained, but in this day of age we just hop onto the internet for free (effectively).
- gwright 7y agoHow is the Internet (effectively) free? * desktops, laptops, phones, tablets, etc aren't free * wireless data plans aren't free * wired Internet connections aren't free * streaming services aren't free
- randomdata 7y ago> desktops, laptops, phones, tablets, etc aren't free But can be obtained for free. People literally throw out perfectly functional machines daily. But anyway, "effectively" was meant to cover the marginal costs of getting onto the internet. > streaming services aren't free Okay. While I don't quite see the appeal when there is already an infinite depth of content that is not a paid streaming service, let's talk about streaming services. The assertion was that if you make more money, you will buy more things. While there is some variation from service to service, streaming services have carved out a price point of around $10 per month. Does that mean for every $10 you make over and above the cost of necessities that you will buy another streaming service? If you are given a $10,000 raise above an income that already provides necessities will you buy 1,000 streaming services? Probably not. Let's narrow our focus to music streaming services. I like to listen to music at work. Other places too, but work gives us a tidy eight hour window. 173 hours per month, on average. The average song is around three minutes, so nearly 3,500 songs a month. Using the Spotify free music service there are ads and time to queue up songs, so let's say 3,000 songs a month. For argument's sake, let's assume they are all performed by different artists. When I was younger a CD sold for around $20. Not having much money, I might buy one or two a month, but that's it. If I had more money would I conceivably buy more CDs to access those 3,000 songs I listen to now? I think the answer is yes. I would have bought more CDs if I had more money. But now I get that for what is effectively free. Even if I did pay the marginal cost to access a non-free tier on a music steaming service, that payment buys me all the music, so to speak. What would have cost $60,000 per month 30 years ago would now cost somewhere around $10 a month, with, most importantly, no linear increase in price with consumption. So, sure, you need to buy a few things, like a computer and internet access. But the point is that, even given unlimited money, one quickly runs out of things to buy in this day of age.
- jyounker 7y agoWe've been trying that for a good chunk of the last decade. That's why interest rates have gone to near zero, and in some places negative. It's not working so well.
- TuringNYC 7y ago>> That's why interest rates have gone to near zero, and in some places negative. It's not working so well. To elaborate on the great comment above -- this is not working well because it creates asset bubbles. It also makes one of the most important things people need -- homes -- inflate in value beyond reach for many.
- zzzcpan 7y agoWell, yeah, free market and capitalism are conflicting ideologies. It's the same with free software, you can't have both user freedom and freedom for corporations to take away user freedom. Second will always just subvert the first one.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> IMO, if you believe in free markets, then your position is inconsistent if you also believe if you also believe in unconstrained wealth collection. But if you believe in free markets, then your position is also inconsistent if you don't believe in unconstrained wealth collection. Because that's one of the things that the market sometimes does when it's free. And I'm sure that someone will say "That means that the idea of a free market is self-inconsistent, and therefore we should abandon the idea." I think it is more likely that the logic in the parent's last paragraph is incorrect. Instead, one has laws to prevent wealth from distorting the market. (Tax the wealth to extinction is not the only possible form that such laws could take.)
- zzzcpan 7y agoHow is it inconsistent? You simply have to constrain wealth collection to ensure free markets.
- JohnFen 7y ago> Because that's one of the things that the market sometimes does when it's free. Correct -- a truly unconstrained market tends to devolve to a highly unfree market. This is why even Adam Smith commented that proper regulation is essential to ensure markets remain free.
- MiroF 7y agoMore likely is that there is no objective "free" market. Is it more "free" to include pricing information from externalities (say with a carbon tax)? Or is it more "free" when those participating in the market are able to harm me without my consent through those externalities? There's no ground standard for non-interference in the affairs of others.
- salawat 7y agoIt should happen extremely infrequently, and when it does, the odds are it isn't because someone is that good, but rather in the right position to reap the benefit of a previously unexploitable network effect. This indicates the Market may be in a position to restructure/reorganize to take into account a new local maximum/minima. The original point the poster made still stands. The point of the invisible hand is to parallelize capital expenditure decisions. Once everything consolidates in a few hands, the market is no longer operating in that mode. You have few people making increasingly large and underinformed decisions about capital movement, which coincidentally, further constrains the ability for money to move throughout the world unless your people sitting on top of capital are spending each and every day doing nothing but trying to unload capital to facilitate the rest of the world's business. The idea of a Free Market does not discount the possibility of Market participants organizing to redistribute and reprime the Market optimizer in the name of shifting away from destabilizing economic circumstances. After all,a market that can no longer function due to civil unrest makes no one but the engines of violence any money. The sooner people start to to take that to heart, the better we'll all end up.