6 ms·
Almost Everything in “Dr. Strangelove” Was True (2014)
- lb1lf 7y agoDr. Strangelove is the origin of what I consider the most brilliantly absurd one-liner in cinematic history. 'Gentlemen, you can't fight in here - this is the war room!'
- quantumhobbit 7y agoMy work would insist on calling the incident response or monitoring room a "war room". And I would quote this every time it was mentioned. It gets old, but I literally can not stop myself from repeating the quote when i hear the phrase "war room".
- lb1lf 7y agoWe had a major incident go down during our Christmas party, of the "We've got $50M of payload slamming into a wellhead at 1,400m, please advise" variety. Our service hotline was overwhelmed, and promptly proceeded to provide the rather irate (for very valid reasons!) customer the personal cell numbers of half the engineering departement. Thus, as we were in a bar in advanced stages of inebriation, all of our cell phones started ringing. Oops. The bartender was brilliant, realizing that something very out of the ordinary had just happened, came over, got the basics from a panicking engineer, threw the other guests out of the pool /pinball lounge at the back, put on coffee (lots!), found some paper and pens and left us to sort it out as best as we could. The disbelief at the customer end as they heard Motörhead in the background while we were on the phone with them? Priceless. We eventually had a couple of laptops taxied in and set up a sort of proper war room, still with Motörhead blaring in from the bar. Good times. We even got the system offshore going again before the wellhead called it quits.
- AdmiralAsshat 7y agoI've also had a customer service desk rep give my personal cell number to a customer. Fun times. Chalk it up to "cultural differences": the CSD rep simply could not understand why I might be incensed that a debt collection agency who believes I am singularly responsible for some hiccup in their collection software now has a direct line to me.
- m463 7y agoThere are euphemisms for everything. Senior citizens, defense department, correctional facility, adult entertainment...
- gerdesj 7y agoDr Strangelove is an absolute classic. The flight and build up to the bomb drop is both comic and tense. The finale with the bloke riding the bomb like a bucking bronco is near genius: slapstick armageddon. I think I need to watch it again. There are quite a few contenders for your award. Might I proffer: "I'm Brian and so's my wife"
- CamperBob2 7y agoIt was a Dadaist film, through and through. Wrong time period, but the influences are striking, down to Strangelove's own physical appearance [1]. Interesting thing to have caught my eye while I was reading about something else entirely. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dada , specifically the painting in front of Hanna Höch. It's almost unthinkable that Kubrick or Peter Sellers didn't run across this image at some point.
- jMyles 7y agoAlthough not a one-liner, I'm partial to: "Buck, should I get it?" "Yeah, you have to!"
- W-Stool 7y agoIf you like "Dr Strangelove" and "Fail Safe" I highly recommend "The Bedford Incident".
- peterwwillis 7y ago> “We don’t care if things go properly,” a launch officer told RAND. “We just don’t want to get in trouble.” Who would you rather have in control of the nukes: people who don't care, or people who care a whole, whole, WHOLE LOT?
- alpha_squared 7y agoPeople who care _that_ much are also more prone to emotional reaction lacking thorough evaluation of a situation that impacted them personally. So, I'm actually really not sure. At least the ones who don't want to get in trouble are motivated by the fact that they are beholden to others in some fashion.
- java-man 7y agoWasn't there an event recently when a U.S. bomber took off with six nuclear tipped missiles which at the time were thought to be inert? And then landed with only five?
- rarecoil 7y agoNot recent, but in 2007 a B-52 took off with six AGM-129 cruise missiles. [1] All were recovered. The root cause: "A later investigation found that the reason for the error was that the electronic production system for tracking the missiles 'had been subverted in favor of an informal process that did not identify the pylon as prepared for the flight.'" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_United_States_Air_Force_nuclear_weapons_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_United_States_Air_Force_n...
- lkbm 7y agoThis sounds like the 2007 incident[0], but the Wikipedia article doesn't say anything about one going missing. That sounds like the sort of thing that would get added as part of the regular mutation in story transmission, and would likely be pretty well-documented if it were true. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_United_States_Air_Force_nuclear_weapons_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_United_States_Air_Force_n...
- Freak_NL 7y agoDid they land with a USAF major missing as well?
- pinewurst 7y ago(2014)
- gdubs 7y agoThe original “Fail Safe” is a great movie btw, if you’ve never seen it. As mentioned in the article, that and “Dr Strangelove” were based on the same book, with “Fail Safe” being the more sober interpretation. Amazing cast, and Lumet (“Dog Day Afternoon”, “Network”, “Twelve Angry Men”) is a legendary director.
- rospaya 7y agoIf I recall correctly there's also a remake, made in the same style.
- scrumper 7y agoYou're referring to the George Clooney, er, teleplay (correct word?) right? It was filmed and broadcast live, if I remember correctly. It was excellent - and I say that as a big fan of the 1964 original.
- cwmma 7y agoFail Safe is was based on a book called 'Fail Safe' while Dr Strangelove was based on one called 'Red Alert'. It's an easy mistake to make as they have incredibly similar plots which really hurt Fail Safe (which I agree is a great movie)
- gdubs 7y agoAh, thanks for that — I’ve held that mistaken view for over a decade now. So in essence it was more of “A Bugs Life” / “Antz” situation.
- kn0where 7y agoExcept Dreamworks did Antz specifically because they found out Pixar was going to do A Bugs Life, and they were taking every opportunity they had to stick it to Disney.
- jhbadger 7y agoOne key difference is that Red Alert/Dr. Strangelove has a mad general start the war. Fail Safe has the war caused by error, which is in a way scarier.
- cjslep 7y agoAnd what's even more scary is what's true beyond the movie. Like dropping nuclear bombs on Goldsboro, NC.
- lightedman 7y agoBombs were not purposefully DROPPED on Goldsboro. The B-52 transporting those broke up in mid-air and as a result lost the cargo of the couple of megaton-range bombs. Thank you for purposefully misaligning the actual event with your words of intent attack on the city.
- rhizome 7y agoThank you for adding sarcasm to your comment, it really helps.
- ceejayoz 7y agoNo one said purposefully, and they were dropped. It's the sort of incident Dr. Strangelove predicted might accidentally cause a nuclear war.
- ourmandave 7y agoPretty sure you have to purposely arm them before there's any chance it would go off for just such a scenario. Otherwise every time you transport one it could end in disaster.
- jacobush 7y agoThat's the intention, yes. But in at least one case, the fail safe came very closing to failing, and not in a good way.
- ceejayoz 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1961_Goldsboro_B-52_crash > Information newly declassified in 2013 showed that one of the bombs came very close to detonating. > In 2013, Revelle recalled the moment the second bomb's switch was found: "Until my death I will never forget hearing my sergeant say, 'Lieutenant, we found the arm/safe switch.' And I said, 'Great.' He said, 'Not great. It's on arm.'" If I'm reading the article right, the other bomb also had the other three arming steps happen and was stopped only by the arm/safe switch, so between the two bombs, each of the four safety steps failed.
- daveslash 7y agoPrevious Discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13051974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13051974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8576707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8576707 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7109345 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7109345
- colordrops 7y agoAs was everything in Eyes Wide Shut.
- new2628 7y agoIt is one of my favorite movies, so I'm curious about others' take on it. In what sense do you find it true/accurate?
- jessaustin 7y agoLots of rich assholes get together on private estates to do demented sexual shit. Not included in the movie: occasionally one of them oversteps some bound that we subjects don't even know exists, and then is fake-suicided while in federal custody. (Great idea for the sequel!)
- AceJohnny2 7y agoThe movie really is a great illustration of the gap between "policy" and implementation, especially in a time of crisis, and how ultimately it still boils down to human decisions. There are some lessons to apply to tech's "on-call", 5-9s culture...
- papito 7y agoAlternately, we have a much less credible scenario in Broken Arrow.
- trasz 7y agoThere’s a book, Command and Control, which tells the story of USA’s nuclear arsenal safety and security over the years. Lots of scary stuff, including how it was discovered that it’s been possible to break into Titan centre and launch stuff with a credit card-shaped object and small team of unarmed man.
- phasetransition 7y agoThis article was written by the author of Command and Control.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThere's so many great scenes about this topic in "Yes Prime Minister". I think this one is the most valuable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKbDKsNsjac https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKbDKsNsjac I've understood the futility of MAD, but this scene helped me really grok it in such a short, practical way.
- nabla9 7y agoWhat the video describes is massive retaliation doctrine. Mutually assured destruction is not the same as massive retaliation doctrine. Massive retaliation was abandoned soon after the the Cuban crisis. Kennedy saw how impossible it was in practice and demanded more options. At the time this episode of Yes Prime minister was written NATO had completely different strategy called flexible response.
- Waterluvian 7y agoMakes sense. I guess what I confuse or don't understand well is how there's anything but MAD. The moment you push any button for any amount of nuclear usage, aren't you basically triggering MAD? The only possible responses are conventional ones, right?
- nabla9 7y agoFlexible response means that the response is proportional to the threat just like in normal war. Nuclear bomb is just a big bomb after all. First comes conventional response. If that fails to stop Soviet advance, tactical nukes are used. If tactical nukes fail, war escalates but no counter value targets are hit (no cities doctrine). Only after all these steps are exhausted and enemy escalates, nuclear war expands to total nuclear war. Nuclear sharing is political side of this. If Soviets attack West Germany, US president hands keys to nuclear gravity bombs to German Chancellor and German pilots who have been trained to deliver those bomb are delivering them. If Germany uses nukes, Soviet union would retaliate against German nuclear attack, not the US based attack. Alternative Germany may choose to surrender and not to use the weapons. In that case NATO withdraws from Germany.
- angst_ridden 7y ago"You're going to have to answer to the Coca-Cola Corporation"
- teeray 7y agoCommand and Control by Eric Schlosser[0] was a fascinating (and chilling) read about many of the incidents people have mentioned in the comments here. It focuses closely on the 374-7 Damascus Incident, but covers many many other “Broken Arrow”[1] incidents that have occurred. It’s not a short read, but it’s eye-opening from the engineering perspective that nuclear arsenals are wildly complicated beasts with on-going maintenance, like any machine. EDIT: It’s also available as a documentary on Netflix[2] Not as in-depth, but it covers the Damascus incident pretty well. [0] https://www.amazon.com/dp/0143125788 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0143125788 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_military_nuclear_incident_terminology#Broken_Arrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_military_nuclear... [2] https://www.netflix.com/title/80107656 https://www.netflix.com/title/80107656
- phasetransition 7y agoEric is the author of the linked article
- teeray 7y agoHeh, so he is! Totally missed that. The writing style (and subject matter) brought him back to mind.
- pmoriarty 7y agoAnyone interested in a quite good, serious film with similar themes to and released around the same time as Dr. Strangelove, should check out Seven Days in May.
- Symmetry 7y agoEveryone is giving book recommendations but nobody has mentioned The Doomsday Machine Confessions of a Nuclear War Planner by Daniel Ellsberg?
- jessaustin 7y agoGenerals and other Pentagon reptiles lie about the dangers of their massive death spending programs. Film at 11.
- mrinfinite 7y agoI consider the storyline that one of the generals has in regard to: water supply contamination, as a main plot.