3 ms·
> "...and places a significant burden on health resources." How can 174 people place significant burden on NHS? I understand their concern but certainly there
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
> "...and places a significant burden on health resources."
How can 174 people place significant burden on NHS? I understand their concern but certainly there are bigger fish to fry.
Also, more importantly, the analysis is completely flawed. Their ROI is based on the injuried, not all who donated and dived.
- refurb 7y agoParachute jumping for charity is not cost-effective in raising money, as the cost of treatment of the 11% who are injured is far in excess of any money raised by the rest. There analysis is correct. They looked across all charity parachutists, the medical costs for those injured versus total amount raised. How can it put a burden on the NHS? Of 105 patients admitted to hospital, 66 (63%) required operative intervention. Can you imagine the 1 or 2 hospitals dealing with this? The system overall can deal with it, but not the local providers.
- Apfel 7y agoTheir analysis actually only focused on two centres in the east of Scotland. There were ~1500 jumpers in 5 years across the two centres, of which 174 (11%) were injured at a cost of £3751 per injury.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoWhere does it mention the total universe of donors/jumpers? It says the average donation was 30 quid. That said, 30 to jump is not the same as 30 per donated. Too many loose ends here, or a sloppy job at communication.
- refurb 7y agoIt’s in the open access article. They calculated the “net” donation after costs.