9 ms·
First of all, this was announced more than 3 years ago, and it still won't happen for another 2.5 years. Second of all, this should be treated as good news for
by crazygringo 7y ago
First of all, this was announced more than 3 years ago, and it still won't happen for another 2.5 years.
Second of all, this should be treated as good news for the HN crowd: Google is transitioning from a proprietary, Chrome-only app model to the open-standard, PWA model. Who doesn't support that?
There are a bunch of "typical Google cancelling a product" comments here. But for real, I simply cannot imagine any Chrome app which people actually use, whose developer is not going to transition to PWA and gain a bigger market.
Seriously, this is like complaining that Microsoft Edge doesn't support ActiveX controls. (And I certainly don't recall any complaints about that here.)
This is good news, people. Less fragmentation and more open standards.
- jermaustin1 7y agoAs a person who uses the Hangouts chrome app daily, I have been expecting a day when I go to launch it and it wont open for the last 3 years. Google doesn't want to support "Classic Hangouts" anymore (and supposedly they killed it in October for GSuite, but not for my domain, I guess). Hangouts is one of the only ways I privately communicate with old friends and past co-workers since EVERYONE has at least one gmail account. And trying to get 20 people to switch to something else is a complete non-starter.
- skinkestek 7y ago> And trying to get 20 people to switch to something else is a complete non-starter. Eh. I participated in getting all my friends to start using WhatsApp and later to stop using it. Way more than 20.
- crazygringo 7y agoDoes hangouts.google.com not work for you? It works for me. You don't need an installable app to use it. And it works inside Gmail too, of course. (True, for companies Google's currently transitioning to the alternative "Hangouts Chat" which has enterprise features. But that's different from consumer Hangouts, and in any case obviously neither depends on Chrome Apps.)
- jermaustin1 7y agohangouts.google.com will actually launch the chrome app since I have it installed. Also, I only use hangouts for the chatting and SMS features, so all that cruft for video conferencing and stuff really detracts from the simplicity of the hangouts app.
- rockostrich 7y agoSo uninstall the app and then just use hangouts.google.com? There are buttons for video/audio calls, but if you don't click them then it behaves like a chat app and when you have 2 conversations open they get hidden anyway.
- starshadowx2 7y agoOver a year ago the Hangouts app had a notice at the top saying support was going away and to switch to the extension. That is still working fine. We've been moving people over to Chat in our domain but a large (probably majority) still use Hangouts.
- ajosh 7y agoIn addition to the Chrome app, there is the Chrome extension. They basically do the same thing and the extension has no expiration message. The main reason I wasn't using the extension before is that it didn't provide a desktop icon in Linux. There is a way to fix that by creating a .desktop file[1]. I'm don't remember if there is a similar problem and/or fix on Windows/Mac. For what it's worth, I've found Hangouts to be the better consumer communications tools. I use other software like Signal and Whatsapp but Hangouts works better between devices. It also makes moving to a voice/video call easy for my less-technically-inclined family members. This is especially true when you want to have a call with multiple users, want to switch for your phone to your computer or want to start a screen share. All of these things can be very useful, even with family members. Of course, there are trade-offs. There isn't E2E encryption. The video takes a lot of battery on many devices. You never know what's going to happen to the service in the future. What you discuss is being recorded and probably used to target ads. [1] https://askubuntu.com/questions/771408/separate-icons-for-chromium-and-hangouts-in-unity-ubuntu-16-04 https://askubuntu.com/questions/771408/separate-icons-for-ch...
- djsumdog 7y agoI still have SMS tied to Hangouts. I moved my phone number to Google Voice when I left the US years ago and kept it on there when I moved back. It's been migrated to hangouts, which is pretty much total garbage now. I want to migrate my phone number to another service, but I also want to get off Android entirely at some point and want to find a service with a public API so I can eventually write Plasma Apps or a Matrix bridge. Are there any good VoIP providers I can pay for monthly that fit that bill?
- techntoke 7y agoDuo is their future replacement and works fine on the desktop.
- int_19h 7y agoDuo is about video calling specifically, no? Hangouts is a generic IM client. I'm on Google Fi, and one major feature of Fi is that it lets you receive texts and calls to your phone number on your desktop, and access voicemail there. But it's all done via Hangouts now, and Google has been very vague on what the replacement is going to be going forward.
- techntoke 7y agoThey have reverted back to Google Voice for this and I'm pretty sure it'll be the replacement.
- int_19h 7y agoWhen I open voice.google.com, as soon as I login, it immediately redirects me to the Google Fi account page. Which does not have any of this functionality.
- techntoke 7y agoWorks fine for me. Also if you look at the GV Android app it has gotten a lot of recent updates compared to Hangouts, including Dark Mode. Additionally they have added the option to text from it which has newer features than Hangouts.
- summerlight 7y agoI believe Google wants to release Hangouts Chat to general consumers and replace Classic Hangouts.
- Aissen 7y agoThis is very good news unless you bought a Chrome app (say, a game), and you won't be able to use it anymore.
- falcolas 7y agoA chrome app that people use? There’s a lot of hobby flight controllers which are/were programmed using a Chrome app. There was no alternative. And since most web apps can’t get access to the host USB (webUSB seems to exist, but still seems pretty nascent), that whole system is probably going to have to find a new app deployment method.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThese should probably be native mobile apps, no?
- rkeene2 7y agoOn a Chromebook ? The Android on ChromeOS stuff isn't as complete and has a hard time seeing e.g. USB peripherals. I've reached out to the people I work with at Google to see what this will mean for my Chrome Application [0], which is a Certificate Provider [1] that talks to a Google provided ChromeOS Application [2]. Technically I can turn it into a Chrome extension now that there's built-in PIN prompting support, but the built-in SSH Agent will suffer as a result, since it will have no way to prompt for a PIN. [0] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/cackey/lpimdiknnpijeigckalekdccibdmeojg https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/cackey/lpimdiknnpi... [1] https://developer.chrome.com/extensions/certificateProvider https://developer.chrome.com/extensions/certificateProvider [2] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smart-card-connector/khpfeaanjngmcnplbdlpegiifgpfgdco https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/smart-card-connect...
- toomuchtodo 7y agoNot on a Chromebook, as it appears it is no longer a usable dev or runtime environment for such applications.
- Spooky23 7y agoComplaining about Google is a sport these days.
- laurent123456 7y agoAs often, the top HN comment is an answer to comments that very few people made. Almost nobody complains here, and even the article states that Chrome Apps weren't widely used.
- jefftk 7y agoThe top comment when the GP comment was posted was the thread starting with "Typical Google move ... now I suppose my Chromebook will be soon a useless brick." (Disclosure: I work at Google, speaking only for myself)
- ma2rten 7y agoAny comment can be the top comment because the time decay factor dominates until there is a comment that amassed a certain amount of upvotes.
- CydeWeys 7y agoIt's 5 hours old now, so the time decay factor is insignificant, and it's still the second highest comment. So it's not accurate to say that no one is complaining about this, or that the response was not to opinions that are actually held.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 7y agoThis is not accurate in this case and feels like a response that is dismissive of but does not actually address the points made by the person you're responding to.
- jcastro 7y agoAnyone know the status of being able to install PWAs on the desktop? The reason I use chrome apps is to have "Gmail" as an application on my desktop so I can alt-tab to it, put it on my dock, etc and treat it as a normal app instead of a tab.
- joshuacc 7y agoThe new MS Edge supports this.
- maxhille 7y ago"add to desktop" option has been available for a couple of years now I think.
- Stratoscope 7y agoIn Chrome, open the page you want, then on the Chrome menu select More Tools / Create Shortcut... Give it a name and check "Open as window". Now you have a shortcut you can use like any other application shortcut. (I've only tried this on Windows and Linux, but it should work on macOS too.)
- ericabiz 7y agoIf you are a Windows or Mac user, third-party apps like Kiwi for Gmail support this functionality (plus support multiple accounts.)
- outworlder 7y agoJust make a simple bash script that goes: open -n /Applications/Google\ Chrome.app --args --app="https://gmail.com" https://gmail.com" Add shortcuts to that.
- m-p-3 7y agoI was using those on an old Chromebook that never received support for Google Play / Android. VLC was available as a Chrome app, so that filled a need I had.
- fenwick67 7y agoOff the top of my head, these were the Chrome apps I used: * VideoStream (allowed casting to Chromecast from filesystem) * PostMan * Internal tools at previous job that used MDNS None of these applications work as a PWA. All of these moved to Electron instead. Which is heavier and just as non-standard and dependent on Chromium as Chrome Apps.
- mffnbs 7y agoPostman has become so bloated in the past two years to a degree where I don’t enjoy using it anymore. Anyone know of an alternative that keeps it simple?
- outworlder 7y agoI use this thing: https://insomnia.rest/ https://insomnia.rest/
- zerocrates 7y agoI've been using Insomnia instead, but it's also Electron I believe.
- jmull 7y agoI agree that this was a terrible idea from day one and am glad it has been killed and will soon be buried. But this: "typical Google cancelling a product" is still an important message. Google routinely floats out APIs, services, and platforms and encourages their use despite fatal flaws that mean they are doomed from day one. And some developers fall for it and later have to pay the price. Hopefully, the repeated warning will minimize this. Think of the devs right now that are mistaking Flutter for a platform that will last.
- gman83 7y agoFlutter is an open-source framework that targets Android, iOS, Web & Desktop. That's rather different to something that just targets Chrome. The developer experience is amazing. Personally I'm using it and not too worried about Flutter lasting. Just like I use react on the web and I'm not worried about that either.
- andybak 7y ago> But this: "typical Google cancelling a product" is still an important message. But it's one that appears with such regularity in HN comments that it drowns out all other discussion. I've frequently seen otherwise interesting posts related to Google derailed into yet another pile on - or even worse full of people that think they are being witty by posting "how soon before it's cancelled?"
- callalex 7y agoYou’re interpereting it as someone being witty, but consider that people have legitimate concerns and are supplying mountains of concrete evidence for their position.
- andybak 7y agoI wasn't disputing the validity of their complaint. That's orthogonal to being unfunny through repetition.
- 7y ago
- shemnon42 7y agoWait what? Edge doesn't support ActiveX controls? Why didn't I notice until now?
- artificial 7y agoI smell another round of consulting fees!
- tmpz22 7y agoThe problem is the Google Brand approach of replacing a used consumer product with a backwards incompatible replacement and forcing the expense/risk of a port onto the end-user as if they have the same resources as Google does. There will be a lot of cases where this approach is reasonable. But because Google has built a strong reputation of constantly doing it, each event will be a new outrage causing more and more churn. You reap what you sow and all that.
- eberkund 7y agoPostman used to be available as a Chrome app but when this was announced they released it as an Electron app instead.
- offmycloud 7y agoThe end of support for Chrome Apps on Windows, Mac, and Linux is June of this year, unless you have paid Enterprise/Education support.
- beached_whale 7y agopeople supporting enterprise. enterprise software is bad to begin with and often has long shelf lives. ActiveX, old java, flash et al are all still flourishing at a large corp near you
- reaperducer 7y agoSo sadly true. Why does my company's spam filter require Flash in order to view a list of messages that were flagged? That's insane.
- beached_whale 7y agotraining sites(internal/external) will be using flash/java for a long long time
- thefounder 7y ago>> This is good news, people. Less fragmentation and more open standards. reply Actually is bad news. PWAs are pretty useless and when I say useless I mean no better than a website. All the web restrictions(i.e cors) apply to PWAs. It's just a "webpage shortcut". The alternative to Chrome apps are really Electron apps not PWAs.
- lmedinas 7y agobesides Chrome Remote Desktop i cannot think about any other useful Chrome app.
- tracker1 7y agoThere were SSH and RDP (windows RDP protocol) apps when I used a chromebook that were pretty decent (getting the private key in the SSH client on the chromebook was, well, interesting). Not sure of others.