4 ms·
"The world as first seen by the child becomes his lifelong standard of excellence, mindless of the fact that he is admiring the ruins of his parents." [...] "G
by kibwen 7y ago
"The world as first seen by the child becomes his lifelong standard of excellence, mindless of the fact that he is admiring the ruins of his parents." [...]
"Generation to Generation, the natural world decays, the ratchet of perception tightens. Gradually, imperceptibly, big sharks give way to small sharks, small sharks to baitfish, baitfish to jellyfish to slime (algae and cyanobacteria). On land, the big cats and wolves becomes feral cats and coyotes. The wild standard sinks ever lower and becomes ever heavier to raise. Few notice, few care. Eventually nobody remembers that wolves not long ago freely roamed the Adirondacks, and hence there is mad howling over the suggestion of returning them to their homeland. Southern Californians panic on learning that a cougar track has been discovered on the fringes of their neighborhood- mindless that cougars roamed these hills and canyons long before gated communities drew their lines in the chaparral. 'Shifting baselines' help explain why the Pennsylvania deer hunter sees everything right and nothing wrong in a forest that's swarming with deer yet as barren of biodiversity as a city park."
~ William Stolzenburg, Where the Wild Things Were
- carlmr 7y ago"A scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it." - Max Planck The same effect, but the good side of it.
- pavlov 7y agoThis is what’s happening with Greta Thunberg and young climate activists, and explains why the boomer generation is so upset about it.
- gatherhunterer 7y agoThat’s only part of it. She is also a woman and a foreigner and she is reasonably well-educated. Americans spend more on the war efforts of other countries than we do to our own public schools. Fear, xenophobia and intellectual insecurity are part of this phenomenon as well. She is also economically privileged and Americans are increasingly divided by income and income-related health factors like physical fitness and addiction. Taking advice from a wealthy, educated European female is simply not an option without opening the door to some uncomfortable observations. These people make take some unscientific ideas to their graves but they will also take a lot of fear and hatred with them.
- malandrew 7y agoDon't forget that a Facebook glitch a few days ago accidentally doxxed the person updating her Facebook posts, revealing that it's her father, Svante Thunberg, authoring her posts. https://pluralist.com/greta-thunberg-facebook-bug-dad-svante-thunberg/ https://pluralist.com/greta-thunberg-facebook-bug-dad-svante... I acknowledge climate change is a thing and should be taken seriously, but the left does itself no favors by manufacturing a petulant child as its messenger. You need messengers that are credible and aren't just preaching to the choir if you want to make progress in convincing people.
- pavlov 7y agoHer primary audience is teenagers. She seems to be doing a good job of convincing them globally.
- turk73 7y agoPropaganda. Teenagers are not intellectually equipped to decide such complex matters for themselves and can be easily swayed into making decisions that are bad for them. The frontal lobe is not fully matured until around age 25--the monsters who push propaganda know this--get them young, fill their heads with bs indoctrination, and then you have them for life. It's the communist playbook! Anyone that takes two seconds to think about Greta Thunberg knows what's going on there. Why do you think 18 year olds are conscripted into armies? This is sad, but communists refer to it as "the children's revolution" or some such, it's a long-time tactic that they have used many times before, look it up. It's pretty consistent for Time Magazine to name ol' Greta Person of The Year given their previous adulation for Adolf Hitler. Great judge of character that magazine is.
- yongjik 7y agoIt's more like the right picked a "petulant child" as their archenemy, rather than the left picked her. It's not a leftist scheme that Trump is engaging in a twitter feud with Thunberg. The right ignored IPCC scientists, they laughed at Al Gore (for having a private jet - yeah I get that it's a very easy thing to hate), but somehow they can't do a thing to a teenager largely repeating the points already made (and ignored) by IPCC and Al Gore, all their usual propaganda tactics do nothing against her, and somehow that makes the right frothing mad. I guess tasting one's own medicine feels awful. Shrug.
- keiferski 7y agoThe Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas Kuhn is essentially a book-length version of this quote.
- turk73 7y agoI'm worried about the nature of scientific inquiry under those circumstances, but yes, I have witnessed the same behaviors in my work--innovation happens when the people standing in the way retire or get new jobs and are out of the way. Then necessary changes happen. Watched it many, many times.
- mooreds 7y agoIf you want a read that takes this to the utmost extreme, I recommend "People of Sand and Slag": https://windupstories.com/books/pump-six-and-other-stories/people-of-sand-and-slag/ https://windupstories.com/books/pump-six-and-other-stories/p... It's scary to me how true it rings.
- specialist 7y ago'Shifting baselines' is a good heuristic. Like Overton Windows. The reason the modern environmental movement started in Southern California is because the degradation happened within people's life times. I testified at one of the public hearings about protecting pacific salmon. [1] I mentioned, much less eloquently than Stolzenburg, that new arrivals to the PNW had no idea what had been lost. Just like I could barely imagine the rivers full of fish, as told by the First Peoples. Maybe we all should be telling more stories. When I was teenager, my boss (from Canada) said they'd play hockey every day, but now their lakes didn't freeze enough. I tell my son that we used to have slugs every where and most every (non summer) morning was foggy until noon. 1] https://www.stoel.com/nmfs-final-4d-rule-for-salmon-and-steelhead https://www.stoel.com/nmfs-final-4d-rule-for-salmon-and-stee...
- blaser-waffle 7y ago> Maybe we all should be telling more stories. When I was teenager, my boss (from Canada) said they'd play hockey every day, but now their lakes didn't freeze enough. I tell my son that we used to have slugs every where and most every (non summer) morning was foggy until noon. It's -40C in Canada where I am currently. Not uncommon, honestly. What is uncommon though, is that the rest of the winter has been very mild. My wife tells similar stories of skating on a local creek that used to freeze at the end of November...