5 ms·
The guy who works for the Turkish aviation company claims that he was threatened with his family being harmed if he doesn't participate in the operation. Consid
by mrtksn 7y ago
The guy who works for the Turkish aviation company claims that he was threatened with his family being harmed if he doesn't participate in the operation. Considering that he is in jail for his participation, it is fair to assume that he is not one of the well-paid-identity-protected people in the operation and he did what he did to protect his family.
I am not very comfortable with glorifying this story, why exactly this guy's life and family is more important than the airline professional's?
Although I would watch the movie about it, this whole ordeal feels wrong as it resembles a story where justice is only for the wealthy and collateral damage to unrelated people's lives is O.K. as if those people are not real humans but NPC that just vanish when you're done with them.
- cheema33 7y ago"The guy who works for the Turkish aviation company claims that he was threatened with his family being harmed" That would be my excuse also if I got caught.
- mrtksn 7y agoWhy he would be caught when the others are not? The guy was not caught in a police chase, they simply looked at the records to see who is involved. If he was getting his fair share of the money and protection he would have been boarding the plane with the rest of the team as it is obvious that the authorities would be coming after him. Why they are coming after him? Because Ghosn entered Lebanon legally, exposing the plane he came in, thus compromising everyone in the logistics of the operation while protecting the reportedly well-paid organizers. This Ghosn guy looks like the kind of a car company CEO that would crunch the number and decide not to do a recall of the fatally faulty cars if the legal fees are less than the cost of a recall.
- clamprecht 7y agoAnd if your family were actually threatened, what would be your excuse?
- darawk 7y agoI think the point is, his statement that his family was threatened provides essentially no information at all, since many people would say that even if it were not true.
- mrtksn 7y agoSo we are supposed to assume that the CEO fled injustice, him an all the reportedly very well-paid conspirators are heroes but this one guy who did the leg work is lying. If he was one of the conspirators, why he is not together with the rest of the team? AFAIK there was no police chase, Ghosn simply did not protect the identities of the people involved in the logistics by entering Lebanon openly instead of using the box. If his family was not threatened, why he did it then? Why Carlos did not even try to protect his identity, why the guy did not run with the rest of the team and enjoy his millions somewhere nice?
- aflag 7y agoThe police arrested him based on the facts they have. I assume there will still be a trial and he can argument that his family was threatened, but from what we know, there's not that much evidence for that.
- mrtksn 7y agoThe exact same thing could have been said for Ghosn. But hey, He is special so it is O.K. for him not to face trial and land other people in jail in the process and those people should face a trial. Right?
- jonathanstrange 7y agoNo. You seem to falsely assume that nobody has empathy for the guy who was arrested. I personally think that it was alright for Ghosn to flee, because the Japanese "justice" system is inherently unjust. It does not fulfill the basic requirements for due process, and that is also the reason why e.g. France has already stated they would not extradite him if he came to France. At the same time it is very regrettable that someone in Turkey was arrested for helping him. I also think that the claim that his family was threatened is not very credible and likely a protection assertion. I'd be surprised if Ghosn thought about this in any other way. People tend to assert all kinds of evilness to wealthy top managers when in the end most of them are just ordinary people who made the right career choices at the right time.
- Thorrez 7y agoIs it really glorifying it? The article doesn't exactly make Ghosn sound like a hero to me. > But as Ghosn’s speech went on, entropy took hold. He jumped rapidly from allegation to allegation at a pace that was difficult to follow even for observers versed in the latest Ghosniana. At one point he committed the No. 1 faux pas for foreigners in Japan, comparing his arrest to the attack on Pearl Harbor. There were flashes of arrogance, with Ghosn describing Nissan as “in the dirt” before he arrived and boasting that “20 books of management were written about me.” He devoted a significant stretch of time to a relatively minor issue—whether his comped use of a room at Versailles for his 2016 wedding celebration constituted a sort of kickback for Renault’s sponsorship of the palace—providing a convoluted explanation that he later summed up with, “If I had thought there had been an ethical problem, I wouldn’t have done it.”
- mrtksn 7y agoReportedly the guy is considered a hero in Lebanon. The reactions on the press articles are also very favourable, just not perfectly behind him and raising some eyebrows. Let's ask this question after the movie comes, even better let's ask the kids of the guy in jail to rate the movie about the tragedy of an imprisoned rich CEO that their father was forced to help and go to jail. Let's hope that the mother has a decent income so that they can afford the ticket to the movie.
- true_religion 7y agoIf his family was threatened why is he still in jail? Did the judge not believe him? Or was it simply that you are always imprisoned in that country regardless of mitigating circumstances.
- mrtksn 7y agoBecause, unlike Ghosn, the guy will face trail since you don't go free by simply saying that you did what you did because someone made you. He obviously committed a crime, now it will take time to receive a ruling and a sentence(which hopefully will be a fair one, based on his claims and the findings of the prosecutor). He will probably lose his job, his family will go through an ordeal and possibly poverty until the case closes. Or maybe he willingly participated and took some serious money, who knows? Unlike with Ghosn, his incident would be put on trial.