7 ms·
> for misdirecting the company? As someone who has been using Netscape before even Internet Explorer exists, and followed all of its development through to Fir
by ksec 7y ago
> for misdirecting the company?
As someone who has been using Netscape before even Internet Explorer exists, and followed all of its development through to Firefox till recent few years. I am not surprised.
At first you give them benefits of doubt, because their ideal were good. Then it happened again, again, and again.
>Mozilla Corporation (as opposed to the much smaller Mozilla Foundation) said it had about 1,000 employees worldwide.
Yes, you do need lots of people for making something as complex as browser, But 1000? Out of the 70 employees, they decided to lay off more than a few senior engineers with a decade of experience.
I dont know if this will change HN's perspective on Firefox and Mozilla. Every time I pointed something negative on Mozilla there are someone quick to defend it. As someone who used to religiously defend Netscape and Mozilla when I was much younger. I get it. I could understand the appeal, the ideal. Until you grow older and realise, You didn't have that ideal, the ideal had you.
- pergadad 7y agoWhat's the alternative? Google? Not really better even if this disappoints about Mozilla.
- YZAEoSM 7y agoI use the browser created by the founder of Mozilla that they chose to purge for political reasons. Works well.
- qbaqbaqba 7y agoEdge or Brave. Different business models than Google's and to some extent Mozilla's.
- eslaught 7y agoBut still beholden to the same rendering engine, and therefore Google's technical decisions about the future of the web. Which is exactly why I would strongly prefer for Mozilla to stay strong, even aside from the non-profit aspect of it.
- m3adow 7y agoStill 100% depending on Google, still supporting a near monopolistic position for the browser. Every Chromium fork is part of the problem, not the solution.
- BrendanEich 7y agoEngine consolidation happened, the fight now is over privacy. When and if Brave is big enough we will chart our own engine course.
- loulouxiv 7y agoThe more influence Google gets over the web standards, the more they will steer it in order to raise the barrier of entry for web engine makers. It will also get them more and more power over what can be commercially viable on the web. Making it easier for them to set the rules for everyone on the web seems directly detrimental to your business. As time passes by for Brave to became "big enough" (supposedly to develop a 2020 state of the art web engine), the complexity of starting a new engine from scratch would continue to grow. It seems that keeping Gecko up to date with the web standards is the only way to have an concurrent implementation for mid-term. This will get more and more difficult to do the more marketshare Blink gets, since it gets easier for Google to shoehorn whatever they want in the web standards by first making it a "de-facto" standard by implementing it in Blink.
- BrendanEich 7y agoThis happens already, e.g. AirBnB deploys new content that breaks in Firefox (perhaps not totally; could be cosmetic or a corner case). Webdevs do not test in low share browsers.
- BrendanEich 7y agoFind "slow forking" elsewhere to see my response to your concern that we would have to make an entirely new engine from scratch this year or next. That's not the threat. We strip out Google tracking already and work in W3C to keep them from jamming premature standards through -- if they try turning any such on without other browsers agreeing, we will disable.
- anon463637 7y agoThere are no good alternatives. The corporations have hijacked the design-by-committee "open standards" by requiring DRM. Hobbyists are shut-out. Mozilla's FF was once a viable alternative to FAANG privacy monetization, but they're flailing around like their leadership doesn't know what to do but fire engineers and re-organize the deck chairs (org chart) on the Titanic.
- tripzilch 7y agoBoth run the Chrome engine! That's not an alternative. You really want all available browsers run the same engine, and one that is developed by Google?? You realize they are at step two of "embrace extend extinguish", right? And you realize that by showing their cards with AMP, they totally aren't above actually doing it too? What do you suppose will happen when the entire web runs on the Chrome engine? No good things.
- MzHN 7y ago>I dont know if this will change HN's perspective on Firefox and Mozilla. Even if it did, what can we do? Giving Chrome more market share gives Google more power to shape the future of web technologies, controversial stuff like Manifest v3 and AMP that HN loves to hate. Personally I'm rooting for Firefox and Mozilla, not out of being a fan of them, but because I'm afraid of the alternative.
- feminintendo 7y agoCompletely agree, but do we have to root for Mozilla if we want to root for Firefox?
- tripzilch 7y agoI'm not sure what your question is, there's all sorts of uninteresting complications to the trademarks on the name "Firefox" and how Mozilla deals with it.
- neuronic 7y agoInterestingly this appears like the same misconception and misdirection that lets people be deluded by their idea of "science". A field that should be an ideal, inherently good space for knowledge and humanity to expand is in fact a cesspool of greedy assholes chasing grants and prestige, reflected in the circumstances around journal publishing. Egos first, then comes science. If your priorities are the other way around, then sincerely good luck to you.
- timwaagh 7y agoi don't know what they do for money, but i suppose it's not giving away free internet browsers. so it might have something to do with that.
- BrendanEich 7y agoSearch revenue share deals, mainly with Google.
- timwaagh 7y agoThanks. Although it doesn't really clear up the mystery of what that workforce of theirs is doing.
- BrendanEich 7y agoLook at the majority of the titles under https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/leadership/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/leadership/.