4 ms·
I love CGP Grey's animations, and you can clearly tell this one involved a lot of work. The problem with his analyses is that they're frequently wrong because
by reaperducer 7y ago
I love CGP Grey's animations, and you can clearly tell this one involved a lot of work.
The problem with his analyses is that they're frequently wrong because he look at problems in a very academic way and severely oversimplifies them.
For example, his video about cars going through intersections makes perfect sense in a simulated world on a computer. But it falls down instantly in real life because it presumes that every car is identical, with the same mechanical characteristics, the same acceleration capability, the same connectivity (for the magic fictional traffic control signal), the same latency, they never break down, there are never any external factors at an intersection, and on and on and on.
Similarly, his plane boarding simulation falls down as soon as someone shows up late, or in a wheelchair, or with a bum leg, drunk, a baby, luggage that the wheel has fallen off of, etc...
He seems to live in a world where there is no difference between theory and reality. I still watch his videos, but I consume them as entertainment, not as documentaries.
- ntsplnkv2 7y ago> Similarly, his plane boarding simulation falls down as soon as someone shows up late, or in a wheelchair, or with a bum leg, drunk, a baby, luggage that the wheel has fallen off of, etc... All of these things occur in non-ideal boarding scenarios as well. I don't see how they affect his solution more so than what we currently have.
- cgriswald 7y agoIt’s sort of like comparing two algorithms and using the one that has the simplest best case time complexity without considering the average case or that your particular real-world use might actually be a worst case.
- ntsplnkv2 7y agoBut ultimately the same problems affect both algorithms in the same way. So the best case algorithm will be slower in the real world, but should still be faster than the other cases.
- reaperducer 7y agoOnly if all algorithms are affected the same way by the same external factors, which simply doesn't happen. It's like when a Toyota and a Freightliner crash into the same wall. They both crashed at the same speed, why is one damaged more than the other?
- ntsplnkv2 7y agoYou can come up with endless scenarios to justify it, but the fact is you can't design something that will deal with all of them. So you design for the typical scenario. Maybe there is an algorithm that boards a plane faster when there are 2 handicapped people, 3 drunks, and 1 person being late. But how typical is that? And is it realistic to design the whole algorithm around that? I would argue it isn't.
- cgriswald 7y agoReal flights have those things in some numbers and a model probably ought to attempt to account for them, since, as you noted in a separate post I can’t seem to find now, they’ll affect the model negatively. The goal isn’t to find the best number of late people and wheelchairs. It’s to be able to board real flights as quickly as possible and every real flight I’ve ever seen, except the flight I took shortly after 9/11, has had some number of strollers, wheelchairs, or what have you.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoI don't think we can make that claim. There is no reason to believe the problems will affect both algorithms the same way. Some may be more fragile or failure resistant to different failure modes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 7y agoExcept this is not true. Quicksort is typically faster than mergesort, but worst case it can be very much slower. The worst case does not affect both algorithms the same way.
- NoodleIncident 7y agoI was under the impression that his conclusions come from the same sort of papers we're discussing in the OP, and that the animation is just a demonstration of the effect. Some real-life issues should be addressed in future studies, for sure; for airplanes, it's probably important to model "families" that sit, board, and deplane together. But just listing the variables not accounted for in the study or video isn't scientific criticism, you have to do your own work to actually demonstrate that it makes a difference.
- reaperducer 7y agoYou are correct. But his videos aren't presented as "this is possibly the best way, and it should be further investigated." They're presented as "This is the best way because I say so, even though I haven't done any testing but I'm a college professor and on YouTube so you should believe me."
- emiliobumachar 7y agoThey're presented more like "This is the best way", the rest of your characterization is unfair. This doesn't invalidate your core criticism, but there's no need to accuse him of trying to impose authority. I've watched a lot of CGP grey and I just learned now, from you, that he's a college professor. I may have missed or forgotten it being mentioned a couple times, but I'm sure it's not front and center as you imply. Being on YouTube is, tautologically, obvious from being on YouTube, but it's also necessarily obvious from being on YouTube, and a similar accusation of appeal to authority could be constructed for any other medium, e.g."it's best because I say so and I have a blog".