3 ms·
The actual fix is to have a completely separate wrapper type (usually an option type) which signals in a type-safe and unambiguous manner that the key was missi
by masklinn 7y ago
The actual fix is to have a completely separate wrapper type (usually an option type) which signals in a type-safe and unambiguous manner that the key was missing.
Then you don’t have the issues of in-band signalling.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoThis isn't really different from the multiple values approach. For example, python could have table accesses return (None, True) for a None value that was present, (None, False) for a value that wasn't present, (5, True) for a 5 value that was present... Is that multiple values? (Yes.) Or a wrapper type? (Also yes, it's a tuple, a collection of values.) This works, but it's unpopular because it makes every table access more difficult.
- masklinn 7y ago> This isn't really different from the multiple values approach. If you ignore most of what I said then it’s not. > Is that multiple values? (Yes.) Or a wrapper type? (Also yes, it's a tuple, a collection of values.) It’s neither type-safe nor unambiguous. > This works For low value of works. Which I guess is all you can ask for in a dynamically typed langage (eg Erlang uses this pattern to fairly good effect, but it has very good support for it). But it should not be confused with an actual solution to the issue. It can make things less bad (again given good support for this pattern which Python does not have), not actually good.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> It’s neither type-safe nor unambiguous. How'd you get here? It's exactly as type-safe as the unwrapped hash table, which is admittedly not especially type-safe, and it's fully unambiguous.
- masklinn 7y ago> It's exactly as type-safe as the unwrapped hash table, which is admittedly not especially type-safe Yes. > and it's fully unambiguous. No, you have any random value flagged as not present (in fact you can forget about or ignore the flag entirely), and no clue if that means anything.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoCan you provide an example of what you mean by "ambiguity"?