6 ms·
Lessons Learned from Writing the San Diego Homeless Survival Guide
- endothrowho333 7y agoFrom my own experiences, the author is slightly overstating the danger of being homeless: The police -- for the most part -- don't care. As long as you're not causing trouble (e.g trespassing and getting complaints against you), they just want you to go away and not cause them any problems either. Maybe it was because I was white, well-spoken, and generally pleasent, but I've never had issues with the police during that period in my life. I was going to write more on how the biggest danger you face homeless is other homeless (and tweakers!) and very poor sleep, but I don't have the time. The poor sleep sneaks up on you and slowly erodes your decision-making and risk-assessment skills and consistantly compromised my ability to make good decisions, i.e get myself out of that mess. I believe the author experienced the same, because his belief in the impending danger he felt does not match the reality of my experiences, but does match a mindset I would fall into while sleep-deprived.
- homonculus1 7y agoFYI the author's name isn't directly listed on the article but she is our very own DoreenMichele
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYeah, my paranoid fears about being picked up by the police (as a consequence of my blog writing) were in part due to my prominence as the highest ranked woman on HN. I hit the leader board of HN (under my previous handle) about a month after I got back into housing. If you're a big fat nobody, your online activities will fly under the radar and you don't need to worry too much. But being the most prominent woman on HN sometimes goes weird places and I have a very long history of attracting problematic attention for things that aren't a problem for other people.
- pc86 7y agoI don't think the San Diego PD cares about how highly ranked someone is on Hacker News. What's more, I don't think 99.9% of the SDPD has ever heard of Hacker News.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI've had reporters and what not contact me due to my remarks on HN. It's okay if you think I was being paranoid. I've already allowed as I was being paranoid. But I had my reasons.
- jshevek 7y agoThis doesn't change the fact that the risks of harrassment for a homeless person can increase (or also decrease, depending on details of the situation) if they become well known. For example, a local business owner or homeowner could start their own private campaign of harrassment by making a series of reports to the police. This can even be done anonymously. Edit: Also, people who live far away, and know her only as someone on HN, can find ways make her life difficult.
- burfog 7y agoI found the story about sleeping under the bridge to be interesting. You had a tent, and you determined that the bridge made you sick, so why be under the bridge? It doesn't seem to offer any shelter advantage in the conditions. You lose the sunlight which disinfects and keeps you warmer. Looking back on that, was the bridge just a mistake?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNo, it wasn't a mistake.
- burfog 7y agoI'm still wondering why you picked the bridge when you had a tent and didn't like the bridge. Did the tent have a huge leak? Was there baseball-sized hail? Were you on concrete or something else, and did that make the difference somehow?
- xenocyon 7y agoPerhaps, but trespassing and getting complained about is something that can happen fairly easily to a homeless person. As a young (housed) person I once called the cops on a person sleeping soundly in the exterior stairwell of my apartment complex - a thoughtless decision on my part that I now regret. The cops who responded were unnecessarily brutal: kicking him awake, then demanding he stand against a wall and spread his legs to be frisked (when there wasn't any reason to suspect a weapon). The trespasser was compliant and meek throughout, but the cops nonetheless spoke roughly to him. I later asked myself why I had been so naive as to expect any other outcome. Since then I've learned better. And this was in Seattle, where cops are reputedly much gentler than many other places.
- vkou 7y ago> And this was in Seattle, where cops are reputedly much gentler than many other places. SPD are not gentler than many other places. They've been absolutely blasted for police brutality in a 2011 DOJ investigation. [1] Now, to SPD's credit, it has been taking steps to improve since then. [2] What you can count on, though, is them usually ignoring homelessness - if nobody complains. There's just too many homeless people in Seattle for them to do anything proactive about it. If somebody does, and it's a slow day, the homeless person in question will get ran off by them. Law enforcement against the homeless is incredibly selective, which is one of the reasons why being homeless is so hard - you always live in fear of being the target of essentially random violence. You never know if you're actually going to get 8 hours of sleep, or if you're going to be kicked (Or shouted) awake half-way through it. [1] https://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Feds-findings-in-Seattle-Police-abuse-2407378.php https://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Feds-findings-in-Sea... [2] https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/crime/in-major-step-federal-monitor-finds-seattle-police-use-of-force-reforms-are-working/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/crime/in-major-ste...
- catalogia 7y agoSPD often ignore matters even if somebody complains. Two years ago there was a homeless woman in my neighborhood who began screaming in the middle of the night as though she were being murdered. I called 911, obviously. An hour later she was still screaming and there were no police in sight. The next night she was still screaming. A week later she was still screaming. Thankfully she wasn't being murdered, not that the police would know, because they never came. Incidentally this experience gave me a new perspective on the bystander effect. After I stopped calling 911 because it was accomplishing nothing, what if one night she really was being murdered? But what is somebody meant to do, call 911 every night until they stop taking your calls?
- mc32 7y agoAlthough not homeless, but rather being a “vagrant” in youth, I agree that cops will not go out of their way to rustle trespassers (schoolyards, parks, golf courses, under highways, etc) unless someone calls in or you bring attention to yourself/selves (causing smoke for example).
- kevingadd 7y agoThis has changed in recent years depending on where you live. Some locales in the US make a big deal of paying police to go around and do sweeps of places where you'd think nobody is causing trouble, it's been a source of controversy. https://mynorthwest.com/1445501/seattle-homeless-sweeps-2019/ https://mynorthwest.com/1445501/seattle-homeless-sweeps-2019... https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/We-don-t-want-to-be-outside-Homeless-say-14882625.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/We-don-t-want-to... A common theme in sweeps is also intentional destruction of property including personal belongings and medicine: https://www.courthousenews.com/homeless-residents-rip-la-over-tossed-belongings/ https://www.courthousenews.com/homeless-residents-rip-la-ove...
- nabnob 7y agoHm, I'm not sure about that. In uptown Charlotte, I see homeless people (white or black) getting harassed by police and security guards when they're just sitting in a public area with a sign.
- aksss 7y agoRight, now compare the degree of homelessness in uptown Charlotte vs San Diego. There's probably a relationship between how prevalent the homeless are and how the police treat them.
- Jamwinner 7y agoI just want to quote the most important thing in the article as I have found personal truth in it generally, in hopes someone who may not read the whole article may benefit: "If you are doing things that you wouldn't do if you weren't homeless, you are probably entrenching your situation. If you are pursuing solutions that you would use even if you weren't homeless, you are potentially building a future."
- virtuous_signal 7y agoIt is appalling to me that anyone with the caliber of ability this person has, clear from her writing, ever became homeless in the first place (not that I'm saying anyone deserves to be homeless). I do have a few questions though: >The other reason this website does not list homeless services is because I became increasingly concerned about creating a website that could serve as an attractive nuisance. In other words, I didn't want to cause problems for a particular area by advertising all the free meal sites and the like in that area and potentially having homeless people from elsewhere flock to that area and overwhelm their services. 1) How common was this attitude among your fellow homeless? My experience is that people in American cities rarely feel a sense of "ownership" for keeping things nice around them, much less homeless people who are probably focused on survival. 2) Have you been accused of "pulling the ladder up behind you" for not sharing whatever info you had, and how would you respond to that?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt is appalling to me that anyone with the caliber of ability this person has, clear from her writing, ever became homeless in the first place I have a serious medical condition. As best I can tell, this is a much more common root cause of homelessness than the addiction and mental health issues that get so much more attention. 1) How common was this attitude among your fellow homeless? My experience is that people in American cities rarely feel a sense of "ownership" for keeping things nice around them, much less homeless people who are probably focused on survival. I can't really answer that. I didn't interact that much with other homeless individuals. I did my best to stay away from both other homeless individuals and homeless services. I'm a woman. Most street homeless are male and they were pretty quick to sexually harass me as one of the few females in their perceived "price range" so to speak I also avoided other homeless people for germ control reasons due to the aforementioned medical condition. 2) Have you been accused of "pulling the ladder up behind you" for not sharing whatever info you had, and how would you respond to that? Nope. The San Diego Homeless Survival Guide remains online. Whatever info it had is still accessible. Everyone who talks to me about such things seems to see me as a valued homeless advocate. The Yimby wiki lists multiple of my websites and the local police department has been handing out my flyers listing my websites for over a year. https://www.yimby.wiki/wiki/Homelessness https://www.yimby.wiki/wiki/Homelessness The fact that I've moved on to focusing on other types of info has not gotten me accused of abandoning the cause because I haven't. Standard practice in most locales seems to be to share such info via paper handouts rather than putting it online. I think that's a best practice for helping local homeless individuals find the resources they need without creating an attractive nuisance.
- nelsondev 7y agoApologies if this is covered in another post; but what’s preventing you from getting a job and getting back into stable housing?
- jshevek 7y agoYou frame your question in the present tense, but this post describes her homelessness in the past tense. > I don't think I stated online that I had been in Fresno until after I left California entirely and got back into housing.
- jshevek 7y agoAddressing causes of her prior homelessness, she says: > I have a serious medical condition. As best I can tell, this is a much more common root cause of homelessness than the addiction and mental health issues that get so much more attention.
- stebann 7y agoHow did this person go homeless in first place? As a person who has a mental condition and still can purchase its medication, I have always being worried getting into that situation.
- stebann 7y agohttps://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2019/10/when-family-safety-net-fails.html https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2019/10/when-family...
- stebann 7y agohttps://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2019/09/homelessness-as-social-death.html https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2019/09/homelessnes...
- stebann 7y agoI really appreciate that you put this online.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoFor your edification, I will add that I also made a choice to be homeless. When I was evicted from my crappy apartment that was contributing to my health problems and family said "No, you can't come home again." I chose to not look for another crappy apartment. I chose to sleep in a tent and quit my job and try to get healthier because my job and crappy housing were barriers to me getting well. I didn't think it would take nearly six years to return to conventional housing. I figured I would be homeless for a few months. It's much, much easier to just walk away from a job and an apartment than to find your way back. Edit: Homelessness often involves some degree of choice, but most homeless don't want to admit that because it just gets them more crap from people. That choice might be "I can stay with an abusive spouse or go be homeless. I'd rather be homeless." Homelessness is frequently the lesser evil. If they had better options available, they would be thrilled to go with some other option. But they don't. Point being: If you genuinely think homelessness is the absolute worst thing, you probably have other options. They may be less than optimal, but they likely exist.