4 ms·
Companies operating legally under governments, are much more transparent to states (any state, not just the one they exist under) than other states are, because
by derefr 7y ago
Companies operating legally under governments, are much more transparent to states (any state, not just the one they exist under) than other states are, because they interact through markets rather than through handshake deals. Amazon and Google have "public APIs" that they get all their chips through, and the NSA can see the "API calls." :)
On the other hand, this is exactly the reason that entities that do operate through handshake deals with no visible economic activity—organized crime and the zaibatsu/chaebol type of conglomerate—tend to be considered imminent threats to states. They're opaque to logistical analysis! (Not that your average mob boss would have any inherent reason to commit treason against the United States, but other nations might be rather motivated to give them extrinsic reasons.)
For this reason, even "benign" domestic crime syndicates or conglomerates will have their intelligence opacity hacked through with the application of good old-fashioned HUMINT.
- vonseel 7y agoDon’t most government contracts tend to go through competitive bidding processes and such? Sans NSA and some top secret military ones, I’d think a bunch of this stuff is pretty open knowledge, at least somewhere out there.
- toyg 7y agoWhy would you throw zaibatsu/chaebols in with criminals...? They are just business conglomerates, their only difference from American-style corporations is that the ownership is organised around families a bit more explicitly on average - something that happens in the States as well, just with less success. The various governments they operate under have the same degree of visibility into them as in any other business. If they didn’t, you wouldn’t know they are zaibatsu in the first place. Are you confusing them with the actual Yakuza...? Why would you class the likes of Samsung as some sort of criminal enterprise outside the law?
- derefr 7y agoIt’s basically just the fact that they’re large enough to have a “complete economy” composed entirely of their business units. Samsung (or, for example, GE) doesn’t have to go outside itself to source chips, or trucks to transport them, or, well, anything, really. One business unit can “buy” those products/services from another business unit without anything necessarily appearing on a balance sheet of either business unit. (It’ll appear if it’s beneficial for them to do so, but half the reason they’ve conglomerated in the first place is to hide the things that’re not beneficial.) Thus, such entities can do an entire skunkworks project without needing to touch the economy. Just like a state can.
- toyg 7y agoThat’s completely theoretical. They still have to report on plenty of things, starting from detailed payroll, handling of substances and so on. In some countries (like Australia or the US, no idea about JP/SK but I bet there too) the government can compel workers to reveal data without anyone else knowing. Zaibatsu are complementary to (corporatist) governments, not adversarial. They feed off each other.