4 ms·
Panpsychism is interesting but I'm not convinced. If I can summarise the idea it's answering the question "how can consciousness arise from unconscious matter
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
Panpsychism is interesting but I'm not convinced.
If I can summarise the idea it's answering the question "how can consciousness
arise from unconscious matter (like the human brain)" with "it can't, matter is
already conscious (i.e. it has conscious experience)".
It's a very simple explanation, a very Occamist explanation. But at the same
time it is not _really_ an explanation. It just pushes the question back from
"how can complex matter like the human brain be conscious?" to "how can simple
matter like quarks be conscious?". But panpsychism does not even attempt to
answer the further question- it's simply ignored. That is, panpsychism says
that "matter is conscious" but it doesn't say _why_ matter is conscious, or
what exactly consciousness _is_ after all. It just passes the buck.
So it's not very different than answering the question with "because God
willed it". I mean, that's an answer too. It's a metaphysical answer- but so
what? Panpsychism is not metaphysical but it's not more explanatory than God.
Not until it explains _what_ consciousness is and _why_ quarks have it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]