5 ms·
Anyone who writes an article like this should be required to disclose up front the current scale of the project they are talking about. (Users, data, number of
by gfodor 16y ago
Anyone who writes an article like this should be required to disclose up front the current scale of the project they are talking about. (Users, data, number of developers, etc.)
In his case, it sounds like a fairly small website developed by just himself. Sorry if I'm not going to take this advice too seriously until this is disproven.
- idlewords 16y agoIt is a fairly small website developed just by myself. I don't think I've ever characterized it otherwise.
- naner 16y agoIs this thing profitable? It appears you've only got the one-time fee.
- rgrieselhuber 16y agoHe supports himself with it / it's his fulltime job, so assuming yes.
- gavingmiller 16y agoHis website pricing gives a hint as to how much the app has made him: > The [Pinboard] fee is based on the formula (number of users * $0.001), so the earlier you join, the less you pay. The current price is $9.22, so following this formula he has ~9220 users, which has paid him roughly 42K. He also charges $25 (minus your sign up fee) for archiving, which would bump that number up a bit.
- jarek 16y agoI hate to be That Guy but they have repeatedly said that's not the entire formula. The most recent figure I saw them share puts them at around 15k users.
- idlewords 16y agoRight now it's 18k users, with 11k active. The signup fee has brought in just over $120k, most of that coming in December (thanks, Yahoo!).
- idlewords 16y agoYes, it's profitable. Recurring revenue comes from the archiving feature, which costs $25/year. The signup fee is mostly there to serve as a brake on growth.
- buro9 16y agoI would love it if you added something between full archiving and the basic account. I want the freetext search, but don't need to be able to access the archived page (except for the equivalent of Google's text cache if the remote page is down). So yes I want archiving, but I don't need asset archiving for things like the images, css, javascript on the pages. And yes I realise for a lot of hashbang sites this would break, but that's just dandy with me. I could sign up to the archiving, but with over 1,700 bookmarks I hesitate... will it go and download all of them? I think that's creating a burden on your service so I am not upgrading. I'd even pay the same price, or damn near it, as the full archiving, but I really want to get the fulltext search in a guilt-free way.
- idlewords 16y agoIf you upgrade, we do go fetch all the link content. We have users with 70k+ archived bookmarks, so you'd really be just a drop in the bucket. It comes down to this - storage is cheap and development time is expensive. It would take considerable work to retrofit the crawler to only fetch dependencies for certain users, manage the case where they upgraded/downgraded between levels, and so on.
- buro9 16y agoCool, that makes me feel guilt-free... one upgrade coming.
- gfodor 16y agoWell, I don't know if you intended this article to be posted on hacker news or not, but it certainly lacks any compelling data or facts to make a real argument for your claims.
- msbarnett 16y agoYou appear to be under the impression that pinboard.in isn't a reasonably well-known site, as sites go. It saw a huge influx of users the day the delicious end-of-life-ing was announced, and held up admirably.
- arctangent 16y agoAnd I for one am glad you made it. When I finally ditched Delicious I looked around and your service seemed to be the best.
- idlewords 16y agoThank you, I really appreciate that!
- zeemonkee 16y agoCurrent debate aside, just like to say thanks for Pinboard from a happy customer. Good example of something that "just works", so you must be doing something right :-)
- arctangent 16y agoI don't understand your criticism. All that the article says is that there are benefits to using well-understood technologies that have been around for a while and have proven to be fairly stable. As someone who works (during the day) for a government agency with well over a million employees, this is something I understand well. Granted, we're not Twitter - but we do serve a silly amount of data using old-fashioned and "boring" technology, and we're glad that we use it because it's proven itself to be reliable.
- gfodor 16y agoHe says: "I think many developers (myself included) are easily seduced by new technology and are willing to burn a lot of time rigging it together just for the joy of tinkering. So nowadays we see a lot of fairly uninteresting web apps with very technically sweet implementations." This is rather insulting to two groups of people: people that are working on things this author would not think are interesting, and people who are overcoming technical challenges by deciding to use new, less mature tools since things like the LAMP stack have well known limitations. (the overlap of these people, as you can probably guess, is pretty high.)
- benologist 16y agoI like everything he had to say in that article and share his beliefs. It's easy to lose yourself in the myriad of fancy new technologies and stuff where you go to extraordinary measures to hack together a solution. Simple is good - it's mature, it's easy to understand, it's easy to optimize, and it works. And you don't need to spend a bunch of time and make a bunch of mistakes learning it. Scale: 120+ million people a month. Stack: IIS + SQL Server + MongoDB, glued together almost exclusively with C#. The only part of my stack that's remotely cool is MongoDB, and I only use it on a little bit of my platform and I outsource it to MongoHQ.
- gfodor 16y agoIf you're using MongoDB when you already have SQL Server I'd wager this author would argue you are being "seduced" by shiny technology.
- benologist 16y agoYou're right - MongoDB did seduce me with big, bold promises and I even had it set up across some of my servers. Took me a whole lot of effort to get that far, then BAM, it all fell over and there I was like an idiot trying to get it back up when I could have been working on my startup instead. The hard part of any new technology is bouncing back when things go wrong, and I don't have to do that now that a 3rd party does it for me, which brings me back around to Simple again. There's a whole bunch of stuff I would like to learn but the reality is I can't have my startup falling over every time I fumble through learning something new, especially when what I already know can still solve problems.