5 ms·
“There can be no such thing, in law or in morality, as actions forbidden to an individual, but permitted to a mob” - Ayn Rand
by jerf 16y ago
“There can be no such thing, in law or in morality, as actions forbidden to an individual, but permitted to a mob” - Ayn Rand
- fleitz 16y agoDefinitely agree with you I'd hate to see Anonymous individuals restricted from actions that HBGary, its subsidiaries, its employees, and clients take.
- cagenut 16y ago"the opposite of anything ayn rand says" -me
- jerf 16y agoWhich specific thing should be permitted to only mobs that is not permitted of individuals? Or is that a vacuous snark?
- njharman 16y agoTaxing, ownership of life fundamentals (land, air, water), rearing/teaching of young, use of electromagnetic spectrum, governing. But, I'm a socialist. Would also use the terms family, tribe, society, etc. instead of the purposefully biased "mob".
- jerf 16y agoTo be honest, I'm a bit surprised at the number of people who had a difficult time identifying who I mean. I'm actually a little-l libertarian and no great lover of government, so I understand the knee-jerk inclination, but why would I be stretching for the definition of a mob when there is another thing that can be called a "mob" in the story with no stretch at all?
- cookiecaper 16y agoTaxation on things is a normal thing that is allowed to all individual entities within their sphere of control. If you own some item, you can effectively set up any taxation system on the usage of that item that you want. The governmental entity is allowed taxation powers because the people under its authority utilize its public benefits, such as police work, court systems, legislative considerations, and so on. Likewise control of commons exists on an individual level as well -- if you are near a certain amount of water, you are generally free to own and control it. To the extent that you don't secure and maintain your property, your ownership is a vain deed. Rearing and teaching of young is a really easy one, commonly given to individuals. Do you think all children should be taken out of individual households and placed in government-run child-rearing centers? That's what this one sounds like, and that is horrifically scary and ridiculous.
- Charuru 16y agoDefine mob? It's ok for the government to imprison people. But when I do it it's called kidnapping. Edit: Just to clarify, I agree if you mean mob as in an actual mob. However you're replying to a parent who's talking about government, so that led me to think you're implying government is some form of a mob. A representative government with powers endowed to them by the people and working within the limits of a codified legal system is very different from a mob.
- sgrove 16y agoI took it that the OP was referring to Anonymous as a mob... which is essentially one of the big draws of huge mobs - their anonymity. Although I'm intrigued by the whole drama unfolding, I don't know that we can say there's justice/liberty in what the mob does if when one person did the same thing we'd say otherwise.
- jerf 16y agoYes. It makes me very uncomfortable when the fact that "Anonymous" is committing some fairly serious crimes is apparently just glossed over because hey, we didn't like the target, so thumbs up! It also makes me uncomfortable that I'm a bit nervous posting this point. This is not progress. This is not good. This is mob rule. We should be fighting this, not applauding it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sigzero 16y agoUm no. What they did was illegal. When you stoop to that level you aren't any better than the people your are trying to give the lesson to.
- sage_joch 16y agoYou shouldn't confuse legality with morality. Pointing out that something is illegal is not a very compelling argument that it's wrong. Imagine how ridiculous it would sound to chastise the Egyptians for breaking their curfew.
- heed 16y agoWhat about 'being a mob'?
- pyre 16y agoIf a mob overthrows the government that means that there were a lot of people upset with the government and it can be taken as the 'will of the people.' If a single person overthrows a government it could be seen as a dictatorship. I think that the Rand-ian sound byte fails here.
- gwern 16y ago> "What is the government? nothing, unless supported by opinion." --Napoleon Bonaparte
- Xurinos 16y ago"Don't live your life according to quotes." -- Keith Malley