3 ms·
What if our ideas about consciousness were an artifact of our language? Just like our ideas about morality? Where a lot of the time if you are explicit all the
by EGreg 7y ago
What if our ideas about consciousness were an artifact of our language?
Just like our ideas about morality? Where a lot of the time if you are explicit all the “mystery” goes away?
So when you say an ought statement “A should do B”, what you really mean is “A should do B if A wants C to happen” which expands to “If A does B and C doesn’t happen, then any D can’t blame A if D wants to be rational”. It’s a bit self referential like that.
Ok so now everything suddenly becomes clear and you find you can’t formulate a single basic question about morality in English that doesn’t have an obvious answer. “You should do your homework! Unless you don’t care about your grades.” or “You should be consistent! Unless you don’t care about being viewed as a hypocrite.”
What if things simply were, and scrupulously including unspoken clauses made all basic questions about consciousness have obvious answers?
“What is it like to be a bat” is not a well formulated question.
However, try including the subject and object of the sentence all the time.
The bat saw the phenomenon
The bat’s body experienced a feeling
And so on.
Then the question comes down to two things:
1) Identity. That is a mental construct that organisms develop. It can have a lot of layers, such as how you see yourself, how you choose to express yourself, etc. But the biggest one is how you identify with the person you were a few years ago and with who you will be in the future. If you were gonna go on a vacation for 2 weeks but later not remember anything about it, does it matter where you go? Do you do things just to make your 80 year old self proud to remember them? And so on.
2) Existence. Yes actually the word existence has no well-defined meaning without resorting to conscious observers. Consider the question of whether the Harry Potter World exists or not. How is it different than not existing or a made-up work like blabladeblaa? The sentence “the Harry Potter World Really Exists” has almost no meaning without resorting to consciousness, we are just used to saying that word. Be thorough and you’ll always invoke yourself and your conscious awareness.
Now what if life never arose in the universe? In what sense would the universe exist any more than a Harry Potter world?
So in a way, the concepts of existence of consciousness are duals of each other!
People often think that the concept of existence is something fundamental. But it is really a dual of the concept of consciousness.