4 ms·
20 years on, and nobody has ever found anything signed with this "NSAKEY". That means either the conspiracy theorists were right, but the NSA only used it for
by londons_explore 7y ago
20 years on, and nobody has ever found anything signed with this "NSAKEY".
That means either the conspiracy theorists were right, but the NSA only used it for hyper targeted attacks, or Microsofts explanation was correct.
I doubt anyone will ever know.
- imdsm 7y agoThey probably decided to rename the variable to something unfamiliar and legit sounding like _winsysdg or _realtek2100m
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mapcars 7y ago>20 years on, and nobody has ever found anything signed with this "NSAKEY". Hm, wouldn't Microsoft make a proof by singing something publically with a private key?
- EvanAnderson 7y agoIn the scenario where NSA gave Microsoft a public key to include in the product Microsoft doesn't have the private key. That's the point-- NSA would want their own root-of-trust in the product.
- tribaal 7y agoI think that's the point the comment you are replying to made: if it was legitimately a microsoft key that just serves a different purpose, it would be trivial for microsoft to prove it by just signing a message or anything with the corresponding private key. The fact that they haven't reinforces the argument that they don't own the private key (likely, the NSA does as the conspiracy goes)
- ziftface 7y agoWell I don't know if that would necessarily prove anything, since in this scenario, microsoft and the nsa are working closely enough together to modify one of their drivers. In that case, couldn't the point of contact at microsoft simply send the message to the nsa to have it signed, and then show it as proof that the key is owned by microsoft?
- mlyle 7y ago> it would be trivial for microsoft to prove it by just signing a message or anything with the corresponding private key. It would also be trivial for Microsoft to call up the NSA and say "they're ON TO US and it looks bad to our customers, can you please sign this message?" That is, the test you suggest proves nothing-- you can't prove that only you hold a private key.
- ta999999171 7y agoFISA orders only work one way.
- smolder 7y ago> (likely, the NSA does as the conspiracy goes) Pardon my pedantry but I think you meant conspiracy theory. Conspiracies happen all the time, and by itself the word doesn't imply anything far-fetched or unproven, just plotting to do harm.
- ta999999171 7y agoAt least someone's allowed to point it out. Maybe next time I'll write a paragraph shrugs Time for me to find another community.
- smolder 7y agoI don't understand this post.
- 7y ago
- sterlind 7y agoAFAIK, NSAKEY was a mechanism where the NSA could install their own cipher suites on their Windows machines, without needing to know or trust Microsoft's signing key (and vice-versa.) DoD and IC use Suite A algorithms, which are classified. So they needed NSAKEY, or a private build of Windows that would let them do what they wanted. I think all they could do maliciously with this key is install backdoored crypto suites on victims' computers, which would require Administrator access anyway. Disclaimer: work at MS, this is well before my time, I have no inside knowledge.
- piracy1 7y agoMS said: "the key ensures compliance with U.S. export laws" "the conspiracy theorists were right, but the NSA only used it for hyper targeted attacks" Why not both?
- ryanlol 7y agoBecause nobody has managed to demonstrate a possible attack in the past 20 years.