3 ms·
I didn't think the were saying that this function of balancing risk was unnecessary, just that it's already being done as part of the process. It's like if you
by ZeroGravitas 7y ago
I didn't think the were saying that this function of balancing risk was unnecessary, just that it's already being done as part of the process.
It's like if you proposed an open source project for some purpose and someone loudly announced to the non-technical stakeholders that they'd found a list of 1,000 problems with it on the internet.
Yes, that's the bugtracker. A bugtracker has value. Someone publicizing it to people who don't understand what it is for their own self-promotion can have negative value and undermine the whole process.
- leereeves 7y agoIf that project was the control software for an airplane, and thousands of people were going to risk their lives on that plane, I think we'd appreciate someone saying: "wait, there are still hundreds of potentially fatal bugs in the firmware. Let's fix those bugs and do some more testing before we trust our lives to the system." Even if there was a risk to remaining where we are (as in medicine), and the plane was our only hope, it would still be wise to know about the risks and make an informed decision. Perhaps, in theory, the system balances the risks, as you said. But in reality people often cheat, take shortcuts, make mistakes, or believe what they want to believe. We will probably always need the contrarians and skeptics to balance out the overly optimistic and the plainly dishonest.