3 ms·
I'm at a loss as to how to respond to a comment that basically says "It's better to let someone die than do something for them that might have a less than optim
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I'm at a loss as to how to respond to a comment that basically says "It's better to let someone die than do something for them that might have a less than optimal outcome."
This flies in the face of every moral rubric I have ever heard. When faced with a choice between certain death and possible death, possible death is the better bet.
The entire world seems to know this if you are in imminent danger of dying. It seems to forget it when you are dying more slowly.
It's actually amazingly horrifying to have such a condition and listen to other people justify doing (essentially) nothing for you because they imagine there is some better answer around the corner or something when you are going through absolute hell every single day of your life right here, right now.
For the record, I have a diagnosis of atypical cystic fibrosis. I am speaking from first-hand experience. This isn't remotely hypothetical for me.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> I'm at a loss as to how to respond to a comment that basically says "It's better to let someone die than do something for them that might have a less than optimal outcome." My comment doesn't "basically say" anything remotely like that. Generally, I'd suggest that it's a very bad idea to respond to comments by spelling out some thing that they "basically" or "essentially", "really" etc "say" when that thing is nowhere in the comment's original text. Perhaps you _imagine_ that I said something like that, or you _think_ I did- but I didn't. Why not respond to exactly what the comment said? Here, I'll repeat it: just because someone, for example, _you_, is willing to be a guinea pig, doesn't mean that other people should turn them into a guinea pig. Nothing there about "better" or "letting someone die" or anything of the sort. EDIT: >> For the record, I have a diagnosis of atypical cystic fibrosis. It's your business if you want to discuss matters of your health in a public forum, but have you considered the possibility that you are not the only commenter who has a personal interest in this subject?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThis is what I said that you quoted and rebutted with asserting that it's not okay: >> And our drug approval process is often maddeningly conservative already in the eyes of people with various terrible conditions who would be happy to be a guinea pig to have some kind of shot at survival. I have no idea how else to interpret your assertion other than "Just let people die rather than let them try experimental treatments. Letting them die is the morally superior option, even if it's not what they want." I'm well aware I'm not the only person with a vested interest. Stating where I'm coming from isn't intended to be dismissive. It's to clarify what my view is based upon. If you are talking about circumstances other than "I'm dying and willing to try experimental treatments as my only shot at survival" then you aren't actually rebutting the line from me that you quoted. Your talking about something else. And if you are rebutting the line you quoted, you are, in fact, saying it's morally superior to let people die rather than let them try experimental treatments.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI'm not trying to "rebut" anything, I'm not saying any of the things you keep insisting I'm saying and you have a really awful way of communicating. Did you even try to ask me what I mean, rather than jumping to conclusions? There's nothing that can come out of this exchange that's of any use to anyone. Except maybe if you keep trying to score a few points, you might get the warm fuzzies. Suit yourself.