3 ms·
It seems like the sample size is too low/varied and data is too closed to have studies. And Stack Overflow 2012 and Stack Overflow 2020 are different communitie
by muzani 7y ago
It seems like the sample size is too low/varied and data is too closed to have studies. And Stack Overflow 2012 and Stack Overflow 2020 are different communities, even though they are structured the same.
I think what matters more is the goal of the system.
SO has a downvoting penalty on answers but not questions, because asking questions is a privilege, but answers are rare. HN has a similar attitude with comments - be careful what you say as you will be judged for it and it can't be taken back.
The downside of cost-free downvoting is that it allows people to throw punches without any repercussions. Someone saying something unpopular will just get downvoted. If it were good, the upvotes would balance it out, but downvotes do hurt feelings and discourage people with a particular slant. I think HN and SO has attracted a certain niche of people and discouraged others.
On the other hand, without downvoting, you'll still get hostile comments, like you would on Tumblr or Daily Mail.
I'd say if you want to encourage downvoting as a form of decentralized moderation, then it should be without penalty.
But I'm not sure if you even need karma in the first place. In almost every system, quantity matters more than quality, and the kind of people who should be discouraged by downvotes aren't.