3 ms·
Thank you for your comment. At any conference where a major result is presented, people in the audience get up and ask questions about the value of the interve
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Thank you for your comment.
At any conference where a major result is presented, people in the audience get up and ask questions about the value of the intervention, the conduct of the study etc, just the kind of things Prasad rants about.
For people with incurable conditions, "dread diseases" and very deadly conditions, the current system is already too conservative. They denied approval for a non-drug treatment for cystic fibrosis because some participants had lung bleeds. Lung bleeds are common with CF. CF is extremely miserable and has a very short average life expectancy.
There are many stories like this out there. People with horrible conditions hear the news that some new drug they were hoping would get approved has been denied by people who seem to be comparing it to some internalized standard for someone relatively healthy and not actually comparing it to "Is it better for this group of people than what they currently have?"
There are very, very expensive drugs and surgeries that get approved at times and that's a whole other issue for such communities. But it's a very real problem that some people are dying and drug approvals don't seem to actually take that into account. I've seen people say things like "Just let me live the additional five years that it takes to get these horrible side effects instead of dying before then. I will worry about the horrible side effects then."
Most people want to live, even when that involves terrible suffering. Most people want that chance. And our drug approval process is often maddeningly conservative already in the eyes of people with various terrible conditions who would be happy to be a guinea pig to have some kind of shot at survival.
It's a logic that makes sense to the people enduring these diseases, but one the medical establishment recoils from.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> And our drug approval process is often maddeningly conservative already in the eyes of people with various terrible conditions who would be happy to be a guinea pig to have some kind of shot at survival. Maybe some people are happy to become guinea pigs. That doesn't mean that other people should be happy to turn them into guinea pigs. "The patient asked for it" is no excuse for the dispensation of interventions that harm the patient.
- tapland 7y agoYes it is? Yes it is!
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm at a loss as to how to respond to a comment that basically says "It's better to let someone die than do something for them that might have a less than optimal outcome." This flies in the face of every moral rubric I have ever heard. When faced with a choice between certain death and possible death, possible death is the better bet. The entire world seems to know this if you are in imminent danger of dying. It seems to forget it when you are dying more slowly. It's actually amazingly horrifying to have such a condition and listen to other people justify doing (essentially) nothing for you because they imagine there is some better answer around the corner or something when you are going through absolute hell every single day of your life right here, right now. For the record, I have a diagnosis of atypical cystic fibrosis. I am speaking from first-hand experience. This isn't remotely hypothetical for me.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> I'm at a loss as to how to respond to a comment that basically says "It's better to let someone die than do something for them that might have a less than optimal outcome." My comment doesn't "basically say" anything remotely like that. Generally, I'd suggest that it's a very bad idea to respond to comments by spelling out some thing that they "basically" or "essentially", "really" etc "say" when that thing is nowhere in the comment's original text. Perhaps you _imagine_ that I said something like that, or you _think_ I did- but I didn't. Why not respond to exactly what the comment said? Here, I'll repeat it: just because someone, for example, _you_, is willing to be a guinea pig, doesn't mean that other people should turn them into a guinea pig. Nothing there about "better" or "letting someone die" or anything of the sort. EDIT: >> For the record, I have a diagnosis of atypical cystic fibrosis. It's your business if you want to discuss matters of your health in a public forum, but have you considered the possibility that you are not the only commenter who has a personal interest in this subject?
- 7y ago
- leereeves 7y agoMy grandmother was killed by an FDA approved drug, so my experience is that sometimes the current system is not conservative enough. What's worse, the company reportedly knew about the danger of the drug, and didn't tell anyone. Eventually the drug was removed from the market, but not before hurting thousands of people. This particular story is about Baycol (1), but perhaps, while reading this, you may have been thinking about another similar story. It's happened many times. If "medical conservatives" can help prevent this from happening even one time, they are creating something of value. I think it's ridiculous to claim, as GP did, that protecting people from harm does not "generate anything of actual value". 1: https://www.nytimes.com/2003/02/22/business/papers-indicate-that-bayer-knew-of-dangers-of-its-cholesterol-drug.html https://www.nytimes.com/2003/02/22/business/papers-indicate-...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm very sorry for your loss.
- leereeves 7y agoThank you.
- roenxi 7y agoThe medical system is always going to be an ongoing series of tragedies. People are going to die stupidly in the medical system because it is run by humans who make mistakes. The human body is not a controlled and repeatable environment like an aircraft; it is a mess, a lot of the parts look accidental and it is a miracle it works on a good day. "A mistake was made so we must adjust the system to stop that happening" isn't a workable philosophy in this specific instance. There is no scenario where mistakes don't happen. A strategy that attempts to achieve the impossible is not a good idea. Tradeoffs will be made that are bad. I can acknowledge that your story is horrible and unfair; but if that thinking takes hold in medicine (which realistically it probably already has) then people will suffer for no reason in a predictable way. It is better that at least people suffering is a surprise or at least somewhat unexpected. Decisions must be made using statistics and risk assessments rather than grasping hopelessly at certainty and happiness. We must tolerate a few bad drugs slipping through.