4 ms·
And in fact animal art, in the US, has been deemed ineligible for copyright [0] I still think the law has much gray are in it though. In between Monkey and Hum
by ineedasername 7y ago
And in fact animal art, in the US, has been deemed ineligible for copyright [0]
I still think the law has much gray are in it though. In between Monkey and Human Photographer with a finished, edited photo, there are many shades of gray with any number of technology-mediated transformations of the work. AI-driven methods of sharpening a photo, for example [1]. Why should the photographer own the resulting AI-adjusted photo's copyright? Certainly they own the original, but it was AI that made the end result. Not unlike a writer making a corpus of text for Tencent's algorithm to learn how to write its own articles, I think.
I'm asking the question, because I honestly don't know: Where would/should the line be drawn?
[0] https://www.swansonlawmn.com/blog/2014/08/23/artwork-created-by-animals-not-copyright-eligible/ https://www.swansonlawmn.com/blog/2014/08/23/artwork-created...
[1] https://topazlabs.com/let-ai-sharpen-your-photos/ https://topazlabs.com/let-ai-sharpen-your-photos/
- shmerl 7y agoI suppose at some level of autonomy. A dummy tool is clearly conveying author's intent. Autonomous AI clearly breaks that authorship chain. So where exactly is an interesting question. I'd say it also has to tie into incentive to create which is the basis of copyright.