3 ms·
>Motorola (edit: and Google, Nokia, probably other) phones come without bloatware - vote with your wallets. Yes, vote with your wallet, but also vote with your
by Barrin92 7y ago
>Motorola (edit: and Google, Nokia, probably other) phones come without bloatware - vote with your wallets.
Yes, vote with your wallet, but also vote with your actual votes. I'd very much like to see a decision from the EU or FCC to finally stop this practice of making it impossible for people to remove the software from the phones they own.
Consumer rights when it comes to mobile devices which are arguably already the primary platform for end users need to be extended. The extent to which businesses are able to lock down devices is just a disaster.
- el_nino 7y agoThis might be a bit of a rabbit hole. My OnePlus has a relatively clean Android but comes with a few apps like Calculator, Notes, or Chrome that don't seem to be removable. They're also not core functionality. So I wonder how easy is it to draw the line between these and the crap that many phones come with. Also stuff like Play services or the Google Store are somewhat replaceable. How could these be categorized?
- tjoff 7y agoSo what if someone wants to remove a non-core functionality calculator? Let them.
- lobotryas 7y agoI wouldn’t. Why is the knee-jerk reaction to solve problems (especially trivial ones like this) with more red tape and bureaucracy? Remember that HN is a bubble. We might care about bloatware, but maybe millions of regular users don’t (or even find some of the bloat useful).
- Barrin92 7y agoit wouldn't be a knee-jerk reaction given how long this has been an issue, and there is little to no bureaucracy or legislation involved other than telling companies what not to do with their consumer's devices. Giving users the right to delete applications is technically straight forward and involves zero additional bureaucrats. Honestly the only knee-jerk thing about this is describing freedom-enhancing measures in the interest of users with the absolutely meaningless 'red tape' buzzword. And I don't think this is a bubble issue either. People being frustrated with having applications fill up their menus or screens and memory is an everyday issue that everyone complains about.
- pdimitar 7y ago> We might care about bloatware, but maybe millions of regular users don’t (or even find some of the bloat useful). Users don't care about technical details as "bloatware" one bit. That's true. They do care about their phones running slower and having a much worse battery life though (compared to iPhones with background app refresh turned off).
- ahartmetz 7y agoOh, I'm not against rules that enforce good behavior.