10 ms·
The CIA will ever be judged by its failures while its successes will be invisible, classified, and by the nature of their success, known to almost nobody. Stat
by colechristensen 7y ago
The CIA will ever be judged by its failures while its successes will be invisible, classified, and by the nature of their success, known to almost nobody.
Statecraft is messy business. If you don't get your hands dirty you either don't matter or you don't last.
It is hard to judge these things fairly. Acting like we live in a perfect world and everyone who doesn't match that needs to be burned at the stake... well that's not helpful. Acting like the state gets a free pass for everything it does because being a government is hard makes us more and more terrible until something breaks.
Yes, a state in a leading world position needs to have a morally flexible arm to get things done, but that arm also needs to be regularly held in check, even if it's just for show.
The CIA and related agencies need pressure to keep them on their toes and doing the "right thing", but not expectation that everything they do will be entirely honorable. If you want that kind of thing, you have to move to somewhere small without much attention which has the luxury of honest opposition to all disreputable state behavior... because it is not in the position to be obligated to respond. (looking at you, smaller western Europe nations)
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>The CIA and related agencies need pressure to keep them on their toes and doing the "right thing" How is that pressure supposed to happen when the referenced case, Nixon's "plumbers," shows them directly interfering with politics? No matter how vital you view an organization able to control foreign states, what you're building is an organization to control your state.
- colechristensen 7y agoDevelop and hold sacred the idea that organizations like the CIA, DIA, NSA, and the military (et. al) do not operate within national borders. i.e. when your military becomes police, your people become the enemy. It is a legitimately a difficult problem, perhaps among the most difficult problems in governing. How do you create and maintain a government for centuries which keeps its primary goal of serving the people. The US founders thought about this very much drawing on philosophers modern and ancient and they did a pretty good job setting up checks and balances, or more bluntly, competition. How do you keep the CIA and its like in check? Create opposing government entities specifically immune to its actions and allow them to compete for prestige. This is why we have three branches of government, two houses of congress with different election strategies, etc. Set up separation of powers, imbue the population to value and cherish that separation, and honestly, hope for the best.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>Develop and hold sacred the idea that organizations like the CIA, DIA, NSA, and the military (et. al) do not operate within national borders Sulla already existed, the idea that "tradition" will keep us safe from ambition has been disproved. >How do you keep the CIA and its like in check? Create opposing government entities specifically immune to its actions and allow them to compete for prestige What kind of organization is immune to an intelligence agency? >honestly, hope for the best Again, we have conclusive proof that this failed with the Nixon plumbers.
- colechristensen 7y ago>Sulla already existed, the idea that "tradition" will keep us safe from ambition has been disproved. There isn't anything else besides tradition. Government in all of its forms ultimate exists and runs in a manner compatible with the consent of the people. Documents, laws, institutions, policy, what have you... they all derive out of that consent, that tradition, that mythology. You have to maintain the mythology as it grows and transforms over time. Tradition can't rule with a dead hand, it is alive with each citizen, each generation. Nothing is forever. >What kind of organization is immune to an intelligence agency? Nothing is perfect. Intelligence agencies aren't all-powerful, and the legislators, judges, executives, and population aren't hopeless. An independent judiciary, senators with long election cycles, and a population with freedom of the press are all resistant to the influence an intelligence agency has. >Again, we have conclusive proof that this failed with the Nixon plumbers. Did it? Nixon was forced out of office, he didn't win. Checks and balances aren't about preventing misbehavior, they're about fixing it when it happens. How it worked with Nixon was, as far as I can determine, satisfactory.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>There isn't anything else besides tradition. It takes one person ignoring tradition to make it worthless. >An independent judiciary, senators with long election cycles, and a population with freedom of the press are all resistant to the influence an intelligence agency has. Intelligence agencies are made to control countries even if they have all those things. They aren't a meaningful resistance. Plus, the best resistance listed, a free press, is directly under attack in the Assange case. >Did it? Nixon was forced out of office, he didn't win. Checks and balances aren't about preventing misbehavior, they're about fixing it when it happens. How it worked with Nixon was, as far as I can determine, satisfactory. The CIA however had one of their own elected vice president in 1980, and the spying they did to get elected then was completely overlooked. Oh, and Nixon was only caught as part of a power struggle in the FBI. If that's "satisfactory" I don't think you care what the CIA does.