3 ms·
This kind of lines up w/ my Unified Privacy Theory, which is: Our largest data problem isn't privacy but disproportionate access to data. This is made worse -
by WarOnPrivacy 7y ago
This kind of lines up w/ my Unified Privacy Theory, which is:
Our largest data problem isn't privacy but disproportionate access to data.
This is made worse - btw - by privacy laws that limit access to data by you and me but not by powerful interests, w/ a history of ruining lives.
- dredmorbius 7y agoWould you happen to have any expansion of this theory posted somewhere? I'd add a few other observations: - Information by itself isn't power, but is a power multiplier. Given any two entities, and an extant power imbalance, an informational equality between the two still favours the more powerful. Yonatan Zunger, chief architect of G+, made this point eloquently rebutting David Brin's "Transparent Society" argument. - Privacy alone (or analogues such as anonymity or pseudonymity) are secondary to impunity as an enabling mechansim. For the disadvantaged, privacy and anonymity rights allow redress against the privileged. For the privileged, it's often immunity or impunity that offers sufficient protection. The "MeToo" movement, particularly Epstein and Weinstein cases, are examples of a sudden loss of immunity. For international espionage and terrorism, it's not mastermind wizardry so much as inability to effectively sanction which enables actors, state or non-state. Some of the arguments raised against GDPR address this -- that the powerful will seek to have inconvenient content redacted, while ordinary citizens would be unable to. My read is that this risk is overstated, though it's one to consider. The whole data-broker sector, predicated on bulk access to consolidated and well-structured data (postal address change records, DMV, voter registration, credit card purchases, credit scores, browser history, etc., etc., etc.) is a case in point of what you describe.