3 ms·
Even if Lion Air had done simulator training, it seems unlikely to have helped, unless there was specifically material on MCAS or at least stabilizer runaway by
by toast0 7y ago
Even if Lion Air had done simulator training, it seems unlikely to have helped, unless there was specifically material on MCAS or at least stabilizer runaway by the electric trim system.
One airline demanding and getting simulator time doesn't help if the decision has already been made to not inform pilots about MCAS. Boeing's flight rules model has always been around the pilot(s) having situational awareness and being in absolute control; the problem with MCAS is not what it does, or that it's needed to avoid stalling, the problem is that it was not known to pilots, that it operates without any clear indication that it's operating, and that it can only be disabled by disabling electric trim, and that manual trim is extremely difficult to impossible to use if the stabilizer is at full nose down (there was an old 737 procedure for this, but it was removed some number of redesigns ago, it was reportedly not in the 737 NG manual)
- willyt 7y agoHere is a video explaining how difficult the manual trim procedure is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoNOVlxJmow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aoNOVlxJmow
- tzs 7y agoNote that the video is about manual trim in extreme conditions. If pilots knew about MCAS and that in the case of a runaway trim due to MCAS they need to disable electrical trim and switch to manual trim early and keep it manual for the rest of the flight, they would not get into the conditions where it is hard to turn the manual trim wheels.
- willyt 7y agoBut even if they had known about MCAS, I think I read somewhere that they had 30 seconds to diagnose the problem before it put the trim in this configuration.