3 ms·
If Google wins it basically re-establishes the status quo. Unless you think things are a disaster now I don't really understand your conclusion. >The differen
by jayd16 7y ago
If Google wins it basically re-establishes the status quo. Unless you think things are a disaster now I don't really understand your conclusion.
>The difference between a free/proprietary API is that you can't use a drop-in replacement, but we already avoid proprietary software, or overly restrictive software, all the time. So wouldn't we just continue doing so?
Right now we can drop in implementations as we see fit. Oracle's win would mean all proprietary APIs become vendor lock in. This would be a massive sea change that would shake the industry (possibly many industries?) to its foundation.
>it's code just as much as a library is code
APIs enforce a representation. We are free to re implement the functionality of other software without copying it verbatim. Any implementation of an API will produce an exact copy of code at the API boundary. This is inescapable and we should not treat this as copyright infringement.
- paulddraper 7y ago> Unless you think things are a disaster now Reread the comment, like "I see a far more daunting problem."