3 ms·
Personally, although I generally despise their practices, I think that Oracle is fully in the right here. APIs are obviously the result of human creativity and
by tsimionescu 7y ago
Personally, although I generally despise their practices, I think that Oracle is fully in the right here. APIs are obviously the result of human creativity and they do deserve protection. Google only chose to copy the Java API for their new platform because they liked it aesthetically and didn't want to invest into creating a new API to use for their platform (a decision I'm sure they are regretting).
What I think would make most sense is to allow APIs to be copyrighted, but to enshrine a specific fair-use exception for interoperability. If that were granted, WINE and other emulators would be allowed to copy Windows' API under that fair-use exception, whereas Google would still not be allowed to do what they did.
- extropy 7y agoThe concept is tempting. However in most cases the implementation is only partial. As in Wine and Samba, etc do not implement the full extent of the API. Just the part that's practical for their purposes. And that's essentially what Google did - made a partial implementation of the API. I don't see a good way to rule that Google use was protected but other not 100% complete implementations are.