4 ms·
The purpose of a controlled burn is to remove underbrush and create gaps that an uncontrolled fire could not cross, right? Wouldn't it be possible to archive th
by xg15 7y ago
The purpose of a controlled burn is to remove underbrush and create gaps that an uncontrolled fire could not cross, right? Wouldn't it be possible to archive those goals without fire? (e.g. just going through the forest and clearing underbrush manually)
Of course some fires are still needed, e.g. to trigger fire-dependant seeds.
- thewizardofaus 7y agoThe amount of bush in Australia is incredible. 120+ million hectares, equivalent to three times the size of California ! Doing this manually would be far too time consuming.
- duskwuff 7y ago> Wouldn't it be possible to archive those goals without fire? (e.g. just going through the forest and clearing underbrush manually) Not at the scale that'd be needed. Clearing underbrush is a labor-intensive process, and the amount of it involved is staggering.
- rasz 7y agoPerhaps we could introduce a non indigenous animal to do it for us, Australia had some experience in this area :)
- grawprog 7y agoIt's not just about clearing underbrush. Ecosystems that experience frequent wildfires actually need fire for succession. Long lived plants in those ecosystems tend to be more fire resistant, they're smaller with thicker bark, shrubs and herbaceous plants will have seeds that lay dormant in the ground for years until a fire. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_ecology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_ecology A lack of controlled burns leads to a buildup of dead wood and underbrush so when there eventually is a fire, it becomes the raging out of control bushfires going on in Australia right now, or in California not long ago, or in BC not long before that.
- pvaldes 7y agoTo express it grafically I would say that ecosystems need fire in the same way as humans need to suck pacifiers.