7 ms·
The Equality Conundrum: What kind of equality is good?
- thrower123 7y agoEquality under the law. Full stop.
- claudiawerner 7y ago“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.” - Anatole France Besides, what does equality under the law mean? Arguably we already have that, but we see massive inequalities that cannot be entirely chalked up to inherent dispositions of the people that face them. Either the law, in its equality, does not do as it should (in which case the justice system needs strengthening), or the pure bluntness of law is insufficient for change. How does one encode "meritocracy", into the law without being unjust and interfering with private life? What if we were to find an inequality that can be remedied with law? Would it mean that we should use the law, to imprison people? Or how about conflicts of rights? Many feminists (rightly or wrongly) claim that the pornographer's right to freedom of speech interferes with women's equality - some (Maitra, Langton, Hornsby, et al.) claim that it interferes with womens' right to be understood (and thereby freedom of speech)? Is justice blind, as is often claimed? There are reasons to doubt that even Rawls himself considered the current system of justice as near his theory of the veil of ignorance. The law, considered alone, does not do a great job of reducing inequality, except as a gesture.
- thrower123 7y agoEliminating inequality is a fool's game, unless you really want to bulldoze the high spots and Harrison Bergeron the best. And then the commissars who define the inequalities and dole out the spoils feast.
- claudiawerner 7y agoWhat gave you the impression I was talking about equality of sporting ability, or even equality of wages? I'm not talking about either of those, and neither is the article. Equality clearly (and charitably) does not mean absolute sameness. No philosopher, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy notes, except Barbeuf (in the year 1796) has ever demanded "strict equality".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoSo we should not teach kids of poor people how to read and write, unless they can pay for it. We will have a massive uneducated underclass so we can finally compete with china in manufacturing!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y agoPlease don't use HN for ideological battle. This kind of rhetoric is predictable and tedious regardless of which ideology you're for or against. What we want here is curious conversation, which is in another area altogether. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoThen we must get right of all private law firms. Why should a wealthy person get a better lawyer?
- azangru 7y ago> Why should a wealthy person get a better lawyer The moment we acknowledge that some lawyers (doctors, teachers, chefs, etc.) are better and some are worse, we must by necessity accept that there is no such thing as equality. Because some will by necessity get a better deal, and some will get a poorer one.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoNot at all, we could make the process random and take money out of the equation. We already do that with some services - you dont get to choose the best firemen, soldiers or policemen.
- speedplane 7y ago> The moment we acknowledge that some lawyers (doctors, teachers, chefs, etc.) are better and some are worse, we must by necessity accept that there is no such thing as equality. Because some will by necessity get a better deal, and some will get a poorer one. Some analogies work better here than others. Sure, a rich person may get a better chef and better food than a poor person. But should a rich person get better justice than a poor person? The entire idea of justice is that it's blind, everyone who comes before it is equal. If we accept the fact that rich folks get more justice than poor folks, we are by definition admitting that there is no justice at all.
- tsukurimashou 7y agoYou realize that "the law" don't really have a good track record of making things fair for the average person?
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here. You started an ideological flamewar and perpetuated it below. We ban accounts that do that. HN's guidelines say: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive." Please follow that one along with the others. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- GrayTextIsTruth 7y ago> We all agree that inequality is bad False I don’t like blanket moral labels like “bad” and “good” used for things like inequality. It’s simply a fact of existence... it is what it is.
- claudiawerner 7y agoA great many things that were facts of existence (such as warlordism and human sacrifice) no longer are, at least partially, I think, because people go as far as to apply those labels, in order to change them. Recognition of what is and isn't does not go as far as what will be or could be.
- pasquinelli 7y agoRight. The word "bad" is an adjective one applies to nouns one wants to change. It's good to identify what you want changed.
- GrayTextIsTruth 7y agoInequality is always seen as negative, but the best art, literature, anything are also products of inequality. Diversity of skills and circumstance cause people to do great things. It’s a universal truth, a law of nature. Warlordism and human sacrifice are not.
- claudiawerner 7y ago"Inequality" here clearly does not refer to the idea that diversity of skills or circumstance (circumstance considered above a certain baseline) should be eradicated[0] - of course, they cannot be, as you point out. However, both warlordism and human sacrifice also had their uses within the societies that used them (or they would not have emerged as cultural phenomena). The fact of a positive (such as literature or art) obviously does not outweigh whatever negatives there may be - after all, it is possible to create an artistic threatening letter, or artistic child pornography. But we are justified in prohibiting both of these regardless of their artistic merit. People having different qualities and experiences is a positive. That inequality is generally agreed upon to be good. People living in poverty in first world nations which hosts billionaires is generally agreed upon to be bad. [0] If you don't believe me, here is a quote from a famous Russian who advocated against inequality, dated 1914. Your objection was replied to more than one hundred years ago: "It goes without saying that in this respect men are not equal. No sensible person and no socialist forgets this. But this kind of equality has nothing whatever to do with socialism. [...] he would find there a special section explaining the absurdity of imagining that economic equality means anything else than the abolition of classes."
- echlebek 7y agoSome may find this trite, but for me, the best part of the article is how one of the twins, James, gets absolutely thrown under the bus for being a stoner. Utterly savage.
- josteink 7y agoI thought it was funny too, in that it was a super-obvious attempt at reversing the typical gender-stereotypes: > Chloe, the oldest, is a math wiz with a coding job at Google; she hopes to start her own company soon. Smart. Successful. Can't be man. Must be a woman. > Will, who has a degree in social work Man assigned to non-stereotypical female role? Check! > James, a perpetually stoned underachiever, is convinced that he can make it as a YouTuber. The typical guys being lazy and stupid stereo-type, that's a bad stereotype... Can't put women in that one, can we? That would uh... not serve equality? So by desperately trying to reverse gender stereotypes, but bailing out where it's not beneficial to women to do the gender juxtaposition, this article helps highlight the gender stereo-types it wants to avoid more than anything else. Modern PC equality is pretty funny at it's heart :)
- yokaze 7y ago> this article helps highlight the gender stereo-types it wants to avoid more than anything else. What makes you think that they don't know that is highlighting stereotypes, and that is actually the intend?
- vore 7y agoThey are literally just talking about what their children do. What do you expect them to say? Make up careers for them?
- ramblerman 7y ago> Modern PC equality is pretty funny at it's heart :) Do you realize you are doing the exact same thing as the PC equality types you mock, just from the other gender. It obviously annoys you that they chose the girl for the successful job, but that is precisely the same annoyance people have when they always read it's a man. You are picking and choosing examples, feeding your confirmation bias to get offended.
- throwGuardian 7y agoThe best we can do as society is to offer equal opportunity at success. Success is multifold: physical, mental and economic health jump to mind. Beyond opportunity equalized, an equitable society should bestow success proportional to the ambitious, persistent hard-working individuals. That might be imperfect, as a few statistical outliers who tend to have outsized innate advantages (Einstein, Ramanujam & Usain Bolt for instance) are likely to be more successful, but that's the most equitable design possible, within the bounds of reality, including evolution - where the fitter tend to survive better
- Pfhreak 7y agoIf only we were remotely close to giving everyone equal opportunities. Sadly, we've got a lot of work to do before we're there, and to some it's going to feel very unfair when they start to lose their advantages.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI feel we have a huge collective blindspot - hard work is emphasized at the expense of working smart. Mode than half of all work in our society is unnecessary and inefficient busywork. Once you start considering efficiency of peoples work, it's very difficult to have a consistent framework.
- adwn 7y ago> More than half of all work in our society is unnecessary and inefficient busywork. Source? Data? That sounds completely made up and does not match the reality I live in, at all.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI am not sure about hard data, but it matches my perception very well and is a widely discussed observation: https://www.vox.com/2018/5/8/17308744/bullshit-jobs-book-david-graeber-occupy-wall-street-karl-marx https://www.vox.com/2018/5/8/17308744/bullshit-jobs-book-dav... If you search meaningless jobs or bullshit jobs, you will find countless articles, and various percentages given, from 25% to 70%. I think it's safe to say the number I not zero
- cjfd 7y agoThis piece is jumping from (un)equality in the family to (un)equality in the state. That itself does not seem to be a good idea. The state cannot be run as if it were a family. Regarding the family conundrum I would say that the four children should get an equal amount unless there is a very severe reason not to do so. One does not want to risk poisoning the relationship between the children after one is gone. Regarding equality in the state the answer is that the state should strive to not have severe inequalities of opportunity, especially if they are so severe that they inhibit social mobility. This can never be done perfectly, though. Also, a situation of equality of opportunity will not lead to equality of outcome because, as this piece also discusses, people have different abilities, interests, and other attributes.
- CaptArmchair 7y agoThat's exact the conclusion of the article. The author opens with a description of (in)equality in very different contexts, in order to put a thesis in front of us: it's not possible to devise and apply an absolute definition of equality based on first principles, because the meaning or significance of equality is rooted in the complexity of our human condition. How we approach equality is always context dependent. Your argument to split the inheritance equally is just as valid as splitting inequally as far as the Universe and the rest of humanity is concerned. Whereas from the point of view of the parents, favoring one strategy over the other is based on moral principle as well as opportunity costs. The relationship between children and children/parents being a factor of varying importance. As far as states are concerned, preserving social mobility isn't the end goal; it's a way station. The main goal of a state is to ensure the survival of a collective. No more, no less. Let's not forget that a 'state' only exists as a social construct. Equality and inequality alike are a function of how the vast number of interests - needs and wants - of individuals either align or collide with each other. When you look at both families and states, you will see that similar dynamics and behaviors are at play. Individuals will always make a cost/benefit calculation in order to find out the extent to which a given strategy will yield value; either by contributing to the group and/or choose their own personal gain over the group. The main difference is the context, and so different variables will be used to calculate trade offs. As far as social mobility is concerned, your parents will have very different motivators to fund your high-ed schooling as opposed to what a state is willing to facilitate. The latter will only invest in individuals to the extent that doing so ensures the benefit of the collective, but there's little incentive to go beyond that. The idea that the state "should take care of its citizens" has always been and will always be at odds with the individual interests of those same citizens. Hence why the dilapitated state of an education or healthcare system isn't a pressing problem until it becomes a problem for too many individuals and it threatens the survival of the collective as a whole. The main concern of the state is not to pursue an ideal amount of equality amongst its citizens, but an optimum amount to ensure its continued existence. Whereas your parents will always hope that an ideal situation can be attained for the sake of their own children... which is very much a personal interest indeed.
- username90 7y agoWe should use inequality whenever it is more efficient than equality to reach our goals. No free society will ever get rid of the following list of inequalities, we can reduce them but never completely eliminate them: Having leaders is a good thing, it makes decision making a lot more efficient. But having leaders is a direct source of inequality. Having owners is a good thing, it incentives people to take care and grow humanity's wealth and resources instead of falling for the tragedy of the commons. But having ownership is a direct source of inequality. Having highly skill dependent jobs be better paid is a good thing, it incentivizes top talent to solve more important problems. But this is also a source of inequality since not every person is equally talented (hard work is a part of talent). Valuing what you know and are used to is a good thing, it helps you reduce variance and risk so you can focus better on other things. But this is a source of inequality since it means that you discriminate against people who are different than you are used to.