3 ms·
First, "indebt their youth basically for life" is just false. Just 1/3 of people 18-29 in the US have student debt at all: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank
by rayiner 7y ago
First, "indebt their youth basically for life" is just false. Just 1/3 of people 18-29 in the US have student debt at all: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/08/13/facts-about-student-loans https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/08/13/facts-about.... 40% of college seniors take out no loans at all.
Out of people who do have debt, the median student debt for someone with a bachelors degree is $25,000. That's less than the average U.S. new car loan. Over a career, a typical college graduate will pay much more in extra taxes in one of those countries with "free public education" than the $25,000 median student debt for college.
Second, the United States has "free public education." The question is do we need to extend that to tertiary education. We sent a man to the moon back when just 5% of adults had a college degree. It's not clear that sending vastly more people to college is actually going to add value.
- enraged_camel 7y ago>>We sent a man to the moon back when just 5% of adults had a college degree. It's not clear that sending vastly more people to college is actually going to add value. This is just such incredibly shoddy reasoning, and such a stunningly bad faith argument. Come on rayiner, you can do better than this. What does sending a man to the moon have anything whatsoever to do with whether college education should be free?
- Thorrez 7y ago> What does sending a man to the moon have anything whatsoever to do with whether college education should be free? raynier is saying it's not clear that more people going to college is better. raynier is certainly not the first person to say that. How it relates to the Moon is that sending a man to the Moon is evidence of scientific progress, and it shows that scientific progress was happening even when many fewer people went to college.
- henrikschroder 7y agoEvery single person involved with sending people to the moon in the 60's graduated college, but it doesn't matter that the graduation rate was 5% back then, because you don't need more than 5% of the entire population to send people to the moon. It's a weird non sequitur argument. The reason there are more college graduates today in the US is that the US labour market requires more college graduates than it did in the 60's. Partly because the available jobs today have higher requirements, and partly because of credential inflation. Now, having your domestic labour market require more and more educated workers is a good thing, because it means that your country is moving up the value chain. You're getting rid of low qualified, easily automatable, easily outsourcable jobs, and replacing them with higher-value jobs that (presumably) produce more value per worker. Therefore, it is in your nation's interest to keep this process going, to make sure there's an ever-increasing stream of highly educated people entering the labour force. And if it's in your nation's interest, it might be worth spending tax money on it, and not leave the process up to for-profit companies whose incentives do not align with the national interest.
- rayiner 7y ago> Every single person involved with sending people to the moon in the 60's graduated college That's completely false. Yes, the engineers and mathematicians and astronauts had degrees. Most everyone else did not. The folks handling what we'd call HR today likely didn't. The administrative assistants certainly didn't. > The reason there are more college graduates today in the US is that the US labour market requires more college graduates than it did in the 60's. Partly because the available jobs today have higher requirements, and partly because of credential inflation. The burning question is how much is jobs today having higher requirements, and how much is credential inflation? I don't think the U.S. economy is intrinsically more requiring of college degrees than it was in the 1960's, and it's possibly less necessary today. 30% of police officers today have college degrees. I can't find a figure for 1960 online, but I'd be floored if it was more than low single digits back then. Has the nature of policing changed? No. You still don't need a college degree to be a cop. Even things we think of as “white collar” jobs don’t (and historically didn’t) require a college degree. Every single paralegal I’ve met has a college degree. But it was historically, something that required only a certificate. The job hasn’t changed. But it’s harder to find smart people who didn’t go to college, so college gets required as a filter. Look, you don’t need a bachelors degree to be a nurse (even an RN can qualify with an associates degree). Or a computer programmer. If those highly skilled jobs don’t require college degrees, then you don’t need half of everyone going to college.
- henrikschroder 7y ago> I don't think the U.S. economy is intrinsically more requiring of college degrees than it was in the 1960's, and it's possibly less necessary today. That's as bold a claim as my opposite claim is, and your anecdotes offer about as much evidence for it as I did, i.e. none. I'll offer a counter-anecdote: I'm a better programmer for having gone to college, I've used the knowledge gained there, my value to the labour market is higher because of my education. I'm sure there are more people like me. I would love to know what the truth really is though. I'm not disagreeing with you that there is a massive problem with credential inflation, it's absolutely huge, but I still think there's been a net gain in real demand for college education since the 60's, and that the US as a nation has benefited from it. Digging out the truth seems like an incredibly complex task though, and you have to use the educational system to do it, a system which would be incredibly biased against any findings that it itself is useless... So yeah.
- rayiner 7y ago> What does sending a man to the moon have anything whatsoever to do with whether college education should be free? The economy of the 1960s-1970s was highly sophisticated. We not only sent a man to the moon, but we built the interstate freeway network, we had self-driving trains, we created the Internet, we invented UNIX, etc. In some ways, the economy was even more sophisticated than today's. Manufacturing employed a third of the work force, versus a tenth today. But in 1970, just 10% of adults over 25 had a college degree, and only half had a high school degree. I'm exceedingly skeptical that the massive increase in college attainment since then (to 1/3 of the population) is actually creating economic value (versus shifting it around). If that hypothesis is true, we shouldn't have free college. That would just subsidize an unproductive activity. Indeed, we should probably take the opposite approach--discouraging "college inflation" (the phenomenon where jobs today require a college degree where identical jobs in 1970 did not). I think it’s highly telling that a majority of college graduates have a “degree required” job, but only a quarter have a job related to their major: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/20/only-27-percent-of-college-grads-have-a-job-related-to-their-major/?outputType=amp https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2013/05/20/only-.... I think that is strong evidence that the majority of college graduates are in “college required” jobs that don’t actually benefit from anything the learned in college. (Except insofar as college might teach general writing and analytical skills that should be taught in high school.)