3 ms·
I would posture that much of what the author is trying to describe is differences in thinking patterns. We've got loads of psychological research that shows tha
by chrisco255 7y ago
I would posture that much of what the author is trying to describe is differences in thinking patterns. We've got loads of psychological research that shows that across the population spectrum, various patterns of thought dominate (MBTI, for example). I think this is a case where people who think logically are attracted to professions where this skill is valued highly. Perhaps creative thinking is another skillset that's also influenced by personality. These folks are going to be more attracted to fields where they can exercise their creativity.
- bitwize 7y agoMBTI is pure quackery. The only personality model shown to have any statistical legs whatsoever is the Big Five model and even that I have reservations about because it relies so heavily on subjective descriptors rather than measured quantities.
- callesgg 7y agoIt is not pure quackery, you can make measurements on anything and use it for anything. The fact that it is not biologically "real" is a different thing. I can make up a model for the human mind called there carboat model. It splits everyone up on a spectrum on how much they like boats and cars. Now I can use that model to make statistical assumptions about the people I measured. It bet the assumptions will have high accuracy on boat and car related matters.
- burfog 7y agoI object. Engineers are the most creative. Every valid patent is evidence of that. When I'm judging creativity, the marketing gunk on the side of a Kashi cereal box ranks far lower than the design of the exhaust valve cooling in the Ford Mustang. Thomas Edison was more creative than Banksy. The people who created Vantablack were more creative than Anish Kapoor and other users. There was more creativity in the Antikythera mechanism than in the Mona Lisa.
- vikramkr 7y agoMyers-Brigg is not a scientifically rigorous/valid personality scale, while it's popular with HR and corporate that has far more to do with good marketing than any sort of genuine psychological insight, so I would be very skeptical of the research that uses MBTI as a valid indicator to show differences in thinking patters accross the population. The big 5 is what's generally used and considered the best personality scale available for use currently to the best of my knowledge, and most scientific research papers should be using that. https://www.vox.com/2014/7/15/5881947/myers-briggs-personality-test-meaningless https://www.vox.com/2014/7/15/5881947/myers-briggs-personali... ^Obviously not a scholary source, decent overall summary, take with a grain of salt.
- wool_gather 7y agoParent mentioned MBTI only as a side note. And the point stands regardless of this detail: there is a diversity of thinking styles, temperaments, whatever you want to call it. Whether (and how) those styles are quantified or not, people, quite naturally, often end up with careers that fit well with them.