3 ms·
I am always a little frustrated by people who make arguments like "Women just prefer to do other things besides code"; there is always an implicit assumption th
by cortesoft 7y ago
I am always a little frustrated by people who make arguments like "Women just prefer to do other things besides code"; there is always an implicit assumption that preferences are completely genetic and not affected by the same culture that shapes all the other reasons why women might not be as represented in tech.
Preferences are strongly influenced by our culture. Just think about other areas; kids in Brazil are WAY more likely to be into soccer than a kid in the United States. Do people think this is because Brazilians have a genetic disposal to liking soccer? Of course not, if a kid born to American parents grew up in Brazil, he or she would be just as likely to 'prefer' soccer over other sports as any other kid in Brazil.
Preferences are shaped by our culture (and of course there is a genetic component), and there is no easy way to tease out what factors go into setting our preferences.
The only clear answer is that preferences are not set in stone at birth, and we shouldn't assume that differences in preferences between men and women will always remain static and shouldn't be talked about as being influenced by culture.
tl;dr you can't end the conversation by appealing to preference.
- DuskStar 7y agoYou can't end the conversation by appealing to prevalence, either. Unequal representation does not imply discrimination.
- cortesoft 7y agoI did not say it did.
- leereeves 7y agoIf different preferences are related to culture, why are they seen most strongly in the societies that try hardest to eliminate differences between the sexes? > They observed that the more that women have equal opportunities, the more they differ from men in their preferences. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/362/6412/eaas9899 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/362/6412/eaas9899
- cortesoft 7y agoI am not sure how that is related... how culture affects preferences is not just about how much a society pushes for equality. Culture is complicated, and isn't as simple as a culture supporting women or not. I am not even arguing that sexes having different preferences is necessarily bad... I am simply arguing that preferences are heavily influenced by culture.
- leereeves 7y agoIt's related because Western cultures have made a conscious effort to eliminate such influences, and yet those preferences stubbornly remain, or even grow stronger. And psychologists have reported these preferences across very different cultures throughout the world. It seems like you are stating what you'd like to think is true rather than drawing conclusions from the available evidence.
- cortesoft 7y agoI think you underestimate how much of our culture still perpetuates gender stereotypes.
- leereeves 7y agoNo, I really don't. But there's a biological reason for that: women have a choice that men do not. Many women who want to become stay-at-home (and, increasingly, single) mothers choose careers that prepare them for that (which do not include software development). Men don't really have that choice, so naturally men are overrepresented in other life choices. How many men do you know who planned to have a child and raise it on their own, without a mother, and therefore studied education and medicine to prepare to be a better primary caregiver? How could that even be made a viable option for men without forcing women to have children against their will?
- cortesoft 7y agoI know zero men who have done that... I also know zero women who have done that