2 ms·
> Putting words in my mouth. No one said anything about perfect security. No, you mentioned the highest level which I took to read as perfect. Given the oppor
by stcredzero 16y ago
> Putting words in my mouth. No one said anything about perfect security.
No, you mentioned the highest level which I took to read as perfect.
Given the opportunity, you choose a mediocre interpretation instead of the most intelligent one. (Actually, that's charitable. You ascribed an idea to me that everyone knows doesn't exist.) This results in a lower level of discussion.
> I bet I could find a company that could set up an email server that couldn't be compromised just because the web server was compromised.
I've no doubt you could find someone who'd claim that they could do it, but it's all going to depend on the architecture, configuration, software and maintenance involved. FWIW I don't believe that HBGary used a company for their mail, I read somewhere that Aaron Barr was the administrator
And how isn't this a red flag for organizational incompetence at HBGary?
- iuguy 16y agoI think we're talking across purposes here. I'm asserting that the fact that they were compromised isn't particularly bad. People get hit all the time. The fact that they were hit by an SQL injection bug is unfortunate and should've been picked up but these things happen all the time. I'd also say that while they're a security firm they should still be held to the same standards as everyone else, there's nothing inherently special about a security firm being compromised anymore than a plumber's getting a leak - what matters is the damage and how they fix it. The red flags as you call them are not the facts nor the means of the compromise alone, it's the data that is lost and whether or not HBGary Federal a) practiced what they preached and b) followed appropriate processes and policies to protect the information assets according to their sensitivity. My hope is that on balance they did b fairly well and maybe some of a. My expectation is that they did some of a and probably not a lot of b, the results of which would be the red flag. Again, I don't think that security companies should be held to higher standards than others as on balance we tend to hold less sensitive data than our customers (although that which we hold we should handle correctly). If this were an online pet shop people would talk about the attacks being quite advanced, laugh a little and move on. HBGary Federal aren't the first security firm to get hacked into and won't be the last.
- stcredzero 16y agothere's nothing inherently special about a security firm being compromised anymore than a plumber's getting a leak - what matters is the damage and how they fix it. A word of advice: If a plumber gets a leak, it's no big deal. If a plumber's office gets massive but avoidable water damage through their short-sighted incompetence, don't hire them.
- sambe 16y agoYou don't think there's any truth in "the cobbler's children have no shoes"?
- stcredzero 16y ago"Eat your own cooking."
- sambe 16y agoI don't think the down-vote was necessary. I agree it will always look bad, and obviously they need to do better. But there's no logical inference about the quality of the work they do for clients that can be made from them not securing themselves. In particular, if they are busy and thorough with clients they may not have the time to sort themselves out. As the saying goes... Dogfooding is not so appropriate, regular testing of software/cooking through continuous use is quite different to infrequent security attacks. Perhaps they are testing intrusion detection ;)