13 ms·
I didn't see anything that specified who owns the copyright. Tencent, I presume? It also seems like a self-evident ruling. I don't see much difference, except
by ineedasername 7y ago
I didn't see anything that specified who owns the copyright. Tencent, I presume?
It also seems like a self-evident ruling. I don't see much difference, except a matter of degree, between computer-generated prose in this case, and something like LaTex. Page composition (graphic design) is generally covered by copyright [0]. In fact just about every creative content has some form of technological intermediary. An "AI" algorithm, or even something more basic, performs touch-up work on a photo. The photographer didn't do it, they just hit the button, just like whoever setup the system for Tencent. So I just don't see how courts could hold that copyright wouldn't apply in a case like this when so much content depends on computational generation of some sort.
[0] https://www.commarts.com/columns/is-it-true-that-copyright-doesn-t-protect-graphic-design https://www.commarts.com/columns/is-it-true-that-copyright-d...
- EGreg 7y agoThe issue is that the AI can generate all viable versions of the article by front-running someone else’s style. Our society is built on the assumption that attackers are inefficient or dumb.
- ineedasername 7y agoIf the AI is generating content using a corpus which 1) has copyright attached (say Matt Levine's content for Bloomberg) and 2) isn't owned by the person/corporation that developed the AI, then you're absolutely right and waters are muddied. An argument could be made that the end-product is transformative enough to be its own things, eligible for copyright, but use and, presumably, copying of the original content into a corpus would seem a violation of that copyright. On the other hand, if Tencent owned the corpus, that isn't really an issue. Similarly, there have been automated finance articles for more than a decade using knowledge extraction algorithms against things like earnings reports, and copyright of those reports has not been an issue. Admittedly, that may only be because those releasing the reports do so in part to get the word out, and so they want reporting to be done on them. Even if they had a copyright claim that it wasn't fair use, they may not have the incentive to enforce it. Regardless, this all opens up some fascinating discussions of the agency of AI, what constitutes true AI vs. a simple program or algorithm, assignment of who actually would own the copyrights of computer generated content... I think it's going to take some time for the law to catch up to technology on these topics.
- EGreg 7y agoCopyright’s stated purpose was to promote the Progress of useful arts and science. That’s why the monopoly was secured to the authors. Bots don’t care about those incentives. Once built, that’s all they do.
- yorwba 7y agoYes, but the people writing and running the bots still care about those incentives. So it makes sense that they should own the copyright to the articles they generate with their bot.
- EGreg 7y agoI disagree — because the goal was to promote a laborious activity. Once we reach a whole new level, we no longer need to give the same incentives. It’s clear that people would be doing this even without copyright.
- ineedasername 7y agoNow THAT is the first reasonable argument I've heard against copyright for such things. Once it becomes easy, trivial, and for most purposes "free" to hit button and make a best-selling novel, a temporary monopoly on that work wouldn't seem to benefit the goal of incentivising future work. Of course, the person/people that built the system may still need some type of temporary monopoly to incentivize refinements, increased quality, genre variation, etc., maybe even the ability to tailor made a novel to a specific individual's tastes for them alone... but I'm not sure "copyright" would then be the best tool for this. I think there would need to be something new and, given that I think copyright terms are already extremely too long, much shorter than traditional copyright. Thanks for such an insightful idea! I'm not 100% sure which side I come down on, but it's very thought provoking, the sort of discussion that draws me in to HN.
- shmerl 7y agoMust the AI itself, otherwise it makes no sense. Though it makes none even for AI (at least at present), since it's far from human comparable. It's not different from saying that monkey with a camera can have copyright, or someone giving monkey a camera gets it, if monkey makes a picture.
- ineedasername 7y agoAnd in fact animal art, in the US, has been deemed ineligible for copyright [0] I still think the law has much gray are in it though. In between Monkey and Human Photographer with a finished, edited photo, there are many shades of gray with any number of technology-mediated transformations of the work. AI-driven methods of sharpening a photo, for example [1]. Why should the photographer own the resulting AI-adjusted photo's copyright? Certainly they own the original, but it was AI that made the end result. Not unlike a writer making a corpus of text for Tencent's algorithm to learn how to write its own articles, I think. I'm asking the question, because I honestly don't know: Where would/should the line be drawn? [0] https://www.swansonlawmn.com/blog/2014/08/23/artwork-created-by-animals-not-copyright-eligible/ https://www.swansonlawmn.com/blog/2014/08/23/artwork-created... [1] https://topazlabs.com/let-ai-sharpen-your-photos/ https://topazlabs.com/let-ai-sharpen-your-photos/
- shmerl 7y agoI suppose at some level of autonomy. A dummy tool is clearly conveying author's intent. Autonomous AI clearly breaks that authorship chain. So where exactly is an interesting question. I'd say it also has to tie into incentive to create which is the basis of copyright.
- IIAOPSW 7y agoWhen a person creates X as part of their job, the company owns the IP. When an AI creates X as part of its job, the company owns the IP. When a person creates X on their own, they own the IP. When an AI creates X on its own... we aren't there yet.
- shmerl 7y ago> When an AI creates X as part of its job, the company owns the IP I'd say that depends. If something is created by AI randomly, owners of the AI didn't create it. It's all about the level of autonomy. If AI simply follows instructions and is a dummy tool - then yeah. But if it does stuff on its own and isn't a conveyor of the owners creative intent - then owners of the AI didn't make it, they shouldn't own the result. And besides, if you claim it's doing it as "part of the job" and that's why owners of the AI should get it, then give the AI job related rights first as well ;)
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoShouldn't it depend on who ran the AI? If I use the shell to generate a very long random number, I'd expect the output to belong to me.
- shmerl 7y agoFirst of all, a number can't belong to anyone. Also, consider a generative algorithm, that creates every possible combination. Do you expect to potentially own everything that wasn't yet created? Because at some point, that algorithm will get to it. Secondly, no, it doesn't depend on who run the AI. Because running the AI isn't called creating the result. The one who run it didn't provide creative input. How is it different from telling someone else "go create"? You didn't create the result either. Another point - copyright by definition is given as an incentive to create. I don't see much need for an incentive to press a button and do nothing after that.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> First of all, a number can't belong to anyone. My understanding is that's not true, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_number. I agree it's stupid but not up to me. > Also, consider a generative algorithm, that creates every possible combination. Do you expect to potentially own everything that wasn't yet created? Because at some point, that algorithm will get to it. Well yes, given infinite time, you could write a program to generate every possible sentence. If I saved those sentences on an infinitely large hard drive, yes, I would expect to own the rights to each one. Note, that doesn't mean I'd be able to sue anyone else who ever speaks. The color of bits [0] matters. IMO, the alternative of assigning copyright to the algorithm's creator gets really messy. If an author uses GPT-2 for writing inspiration[1], and at some point, they copy out a GPT-2 paragraph verbatim, does the author not own that paragraph? Same question for music which incorporates AI-generated samples (or just randomly generated samples). --- [0]: https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 [1]: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/8/30/20840194/ai-art-fiction-writing-language-gpt-2 https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/8/30/20840194/ai-art...