4 ms·
Wouldn't communicating an "untrue statement of fact" that certain people are leaders of an allegedly law-breaking group to government officials or other people
by ilamont 16y ago
Wouldn't communicating an "untrue statement of fact" that certain people are leaders of an allegedly law-breaking group to government officials or other people constitute defamation (assuming that their reputations were harmed as a result)?
- noahc 16y agoI think there are two issues here: 1. The first is that he did not release the report publicly, which is what would cause the defamation. Anonymous did. Thus he wouldn't be responsible for the release of the data. The issue here is really the publishing of it. He did not publish it, and selling it to a private law enforcement agency, in my mind at least is not publishing it. 2. The second issue is related to false police reports. In America, it is illegal to file a false police report. However, this is not what is happening here. He is not claiming to police that a crime was actually committed, instead he is providing information related to that crime. He is basically selling criminal leads to law enforcement. He's basically doing a crime stoppers like program, but generating the leads himself and going straight to the feds.
- sudonim 16y ago2. On #2, so if you want to harass someone without putting yourself on the line, generate "evidence" about them and provide it to law enforcement, but don't file a police report. Good to know!
- cookiecaper 16y agoDefamation and libel are civil offenses, meaning (in my lay understanding) a person can be held financially liable if sued but cannot be imprisoned or otherwise restricted except as far as he can be constrained to pay the judgment filed against him.