3 ms·
That is not how human learning works. Manuals don't contain hundreds of thousands of examples to allow students to draw their own conclusion. And for inventing
by tsimionescu 7y ago
That is not how human learning works. Manuals don't contain hundreds of thousands of examples to allow students to draw their own conclusion.
And for inventing new physics, there are two very different approaches. One is perhaps similar to machine learning, where people look at an existing model, find experimental data that doesn't match the model, and adjust the model slightly until it matches the new data. But another mode is where you have a model with certain mathematical properties, then you discover new mathatics that give more properties, and you only then ask for more data to check these extensions.
- Schiphol 7y agoHow does human learning work, then? Do you have pointers to literature on alternative formal learning theories? I am genuinely curious :)
- tsimionescu 7y agoThere's a field called pedagogy which explores some principles of how to teach humans things.
- smallnamespace 7y ago> That is not how human learning works. As someone who has a baby in the house, I assure you that it is indeed how a human learns and refines motor skills, at the very least - by repeated experiment and play, with thousands of permutations of position, speed, weight, and situation. They also try to infer causal models [1]. Just what do you think 'play' is for a child, if not (in part) an opportunity to safely explore its surroundings and refine mental models? [1] https://www.nsf.gov/news/news_videos.jsp?cntn_id=125575&media_id=73196&org https://www.nsf.gov/news/news_videos.jsp?cntn_id=125575&medi...
- tsimionescu 7y agoThe GP's post was not about early development, but about all human learning, including higher learning and advanced physics. Sure, there are modes of learning that are pure experimentation, but there are many other modes of human learning. Even children, after some point, start developing a model and then designing experiments to test hypotheses to refine that model, which is not at all how machine learning works.
- jacquesm 7y agoHumans were learning long before manuals.
- tsimionescu 7y agoSure, manuals were just a very obvious example. Teacher-pupil and master-apprentice relationships are similar to manuals though, and these were likely present even in primitive human societies. Even in primates, copying another individual's actions is a major mode of learning, instead of random exploration.