4 ms·
> A judge sentenced Husband to the restitution center in 2015 to pay off almost $13,000 she owed from an embezzlement conviction in 2009. > The State of Missis
by rayiner 7y ago
> A judge sentenced Husband to the restitution center in 2015 to pay off almost $13,000 she owed from an embezzlement conviction in 2009.
> The State of Mississippi had locked Husband into a modern-day debtors prison.
Let’s agree that this sort of punishment is potentially not conducive to restorative justice.
But what justification is there for the article to deceive the reader with a comparison to debtors prisons?
The EU Convention on Human Rights bans debtors prisons. It states: "No one shall be deprived of his liberty merely on the ground of inability to fulfil a contractual obligation." Restitution as punishment for a crime does not arise out of a “contractual obligation.” It arises out of a criminal conviction.
- romwell 7y agoPotato potato, that person would not have been in prison had they paid off the debt. Where the debt comes from matters why exactly? The prison should be for one purpose only: to make society safer. If someone is dangerous enough to be in prison, they should not be out regardless of whether they owe money or not. In other words, if you can't buy your way out of prison, a debt should not bring you into one.
- wavefunction 7y agoI will expand upon your point. Debt in this case is a civil matter between two private individuals. The State has an interest only, if that, in enforcing court decisions such as garnishment of wages or liens. To sentence someone to jail or prison for the crime of a civil disagreement is sick and wrong and I invite you (abstract yous) to prove me wrong via rhetoric.
- underdown 7y ago"People sent to the centers had been sentenced for felonies but didn’t commit violent crimes, according to the program rules. "
- toasterlovin 7y agoAccording to the information in this thread, the amount owed was for a criminal conviction for embezzlement. This is not about a contract between private parties.
- TomMckenny 7y agoThese people had no wage garnishment, instead they were sentenced to forced labor. Why the difference? Because they are poor. And the line between civil and criminal is often drawn in a peculiar way: Repeat copyright violation enough and somehow it's criminal not civil, but systematically fail to pay artists their royalties it remains civil forever. Embezzling $1000 is criminal, keeping $1000 out of an employee paycheck is a civil.
- rayiner 7y ago> Potato potato, that person would not have been in prison had they paid off the debt. No. The meaning of words matters. Words, used precisely, are how people with different values and beliefs can communicate and reach agreements in a functioning society. When journalists, who are supposed to inform and educate the public, twist the meaning of words in order to make a point, that’s wrong. > Where the debt comes from matters why exactly? Because a debt arising from a criminal conviction requires the convicted person to have engaged in a wrongful act in the first place. Mere failure to pay a civil debt does not. > The prison should be for one purpose only: to make society safer Views about the proper role of prisons vary widely. Most people believe that prisons are for punishing people for doing bad things. Note that by your reasoning, many people who do very bad things should not be imprisoned because there is no risk of recidivism. Women who murder their abusive husbands, for example, are almost never going to go and murder someone else. By your reasoning, they shouldn’t go to prison to punish them for their murder.
- quickthrower2 7y agoI see your point, but taking that on a tangent id say someone who has committed murder is more dangerous than the average person.
- a_t48 7y ago> Women who murder their abusive husbands, for example, are almost never going to go and murder someone else. By your reasoning, they shouldn’t go to prison to punish them for their murder. That's a reasonable position to take, actually. Depends on the level of abuse, I'd say. https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/07/europe/uk-sally-challen-intl-scli-gbr/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/07/europe/uk-sally-challen-intl-...
- klipt 7y agoThe thing is, jail also acts as a deterrent to the first murder. If it's common knowledge that everyone gets one "murder your abusive spouse" consequence free, a lot more people might commit murders in cases where a divorce might have worked out better and less deadly.
- rtpg 7y agoIf you are fined $20,000 for a thing and are unable to pay, you end up in a prison and are forced to work off your debt. This is functionally what debtors prisons were used for From the wiki summary: > Destitute persons who were unable to pay a court-ordered judgment would be incarcerated in these prisons until they had worked off their debt via labour or secured outside funds to pay the balance
- wutbrodo 7y agoHuh, TIL, for some reason I always thought they were for general debt.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoYYDL, actually. They were for general debt.
- rtpg 7y agoThis would actually happen. Usually the person you owe money to would drag you to court and then get you thrown in a debtors prison. I guess my point was that you could end up there for civil or criminal things.
- JamesBarney 7y agoSay I did a bunch of work for your company. And you stiff me for $10,000. I can't just go immediately seize your back account. I first have to establish in the court of law that you owe me money. So I'd sue you and the judge would award me $10,000. But he would award me the $10,000 as court ordered judgement which is the legal instrument that proves you owe me money. So that line doesn't mean quite what you think it means.
- cam_l 7y agoMaybe the reason they would argue this is a debtors prison and not merely a matter arising from a criminal conviction is that she was ordered to pay back money which she had not, and therefore was remanded to the debtors prison. If she had the money, and paid it back, I would argue this would not have happened. The restitution centre is literally there to pay back debts, and not of the 'to society' kind. But also to the very premise of theft, if I take $13,000 which I had access to from my boss but was not supposed to take, that is criminal (fair). But if my boss takes $13,000 from me, because he is a lousy cheapskate who decides to not pay me fairly for the time which I worked. That is a civil matter? Hell, in this case it is not even a civil matter, they are allowed to only pay her $4 an hour. 92 weeks of cheap forced labour. Seems to me these words are all just used to reinforce the status quo.
- ChoGGi 7y agoMaybe the reason they would argue this is a debtors prison and not merely a matter arising from a criminal conviction is that she was ordered to pay back money which she had not, and therefore was remanded to the debtors prison. She went to jail because she stopped going to her probation appointments. She said her probation officers threatened her: "Next time you come in and you don’t have any money, you’re going to jail." Fearing she would be thrown in prison for nonpayment, she stopped reporting.
- fzeroracer 7y agoWords do matter and you are writing a deliberately deceitful post here trying to shy away from the fact that this is a debtors prison, full stop. Once someone has been released from prison they have fulfilled their obligation to society. Sentencing them to prison again solely because they owe money from a previous sentence is a perversion of justice and an absolute farce. They are sent to prison because they owe a monetary debt.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoWhen they've been released from prison and paid their fines and restitution money, they've fulfilled their obligation to society.
- geofft 7y ago> The EU Convention on Human Rights bans debtors prisons. It states: "No one shall be deprived of his liberty merely on the ground of inability to fulfil a contractual obligation." Restitution as punishment for a crime does not arise out of a “contractual obligation.” It arises out of a criminal conviction. Sure, but the Convention does not define the term "debtors' prison," however much you may want to imply that it does. It merely says what you quoted; it says that this particular thing is a human right. It does not close the door to debtors' prisons that do not violate human rights but are still odious in civilized society; it certainly does not close the door to violations of human rights that are not enumerated in the Convention, perhaps because some party to the Convention wishes to continue violating human rights. The argument "Because the Convention doesn't ban it, it must not be a debtors' prison" is just as sound as saying "Because the 13th amendment doesn't ban it, it isn't slavery." Forced labor as punishment for a crime is permissible in the United States, and it's still slavery, of course. The meaning of words matters, and a lawyer, of all people, ought to use words precisely when speaking about justice and imprisonment.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> But what justification is there for the article to deceive the reader with a comparison to debtors prisons? Yeah, this isn't debtors prison; it is penal slavery. Not that it makes it any better. > The EU Convention on Human Rights bans debtors prisons It unconditionally (unlike the US Constitution) bans slavery, too. I'm not sure what bearing “The EU Convention on Human Rights bans...” has on the facts here; not only does the Convention not apply here, but even if it did what the law prohibits has no bearing on what the facts actually are.
- dfawcus 7y ago> The EU Convention on Human Rights bans debtors prisons. FWIW it is the "European Convention on Human Rights", drafted in 1950, usually abbreviated as ECHR (with its court being ECtHR). It is distinct from the EU, being a product of the Council of Europe. Whereas the founding document for the EU (Treaty of Rome) was signed in 1957. As for the EU, it has its own "Charter of Fundamental Rights", somewhat based upon the ECHR, but I can't spot a reference to debts or contractual obligations. The ECHR would not forbid this Mississippi practice, as Articles 4 and 5 allow it. Similarly Articles 5 & 6 of EU CFR would also seem to allow this practice (read the explanatory notes). Please clarify just what Convention, or Charter it is you are referring to, and which body created it. ECHR - https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Collection_Convention_1950_ENG.pdf https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Collection_Convention_195... Article 4 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_4_of_the_European_Convention_on_Human_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_4_of_the_European_Conv... Article 5 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_5_of_the_European_Convention_on_Human_Rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_5_of_the_European_Conv... EU CFR - https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:C:2007:303:FULL&from=EN https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=OJ:...
- FireBeyond 7y agoLet's not also ignore the fact that most of the (Western European) states have explicitly _not_ ratified Article 4 of the EuCHR, despite having been signatories to the Convention.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]