9 ms·
Cities move to ban dollar stores, blaming them for residents’ poor diets
- Simulacra 7y agoThis is more of an anti-poverty move and trying to help anyone. In a lot of places in America the dollar general is the only place you can buy groceries, and even if you’re lucky enough to have a grocery store nearby, it’s not gonna be some fancy Trader Joe’s. City should be encouraging more food and grocery outlet’s to open, not restricting them.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoYou typically ban dollar stores and then support coop or other supported grocery stores that’d be unable to compete against a corporate competitor. Also, previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20464624 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20464624
- barry-cotter 7y agoThis suggests the problem is demand not supply. There are small locally run grocery stores in every immigrant neighborhood in the US and they compete just fine against corporate competitors. This is equivalent to the food desert myth. > The Geography of Poverty and Nutrition: Food Deserts and Food Choices Across the United States > We study the causes of “nutritional inequality”: why the wealthy tend to eat more healthfully than the poor in the U.S. Using two event study designs exploiting entry of new supermarkets and households’ moves to healthier neighborhoods, we reject that neighborhood environments have economically meaningful effects on healthy eating. Using a structural demand model, we find that exposing low-income households to the same food availability and prices experienced by high-income households would reduce nutritional inequality by only 9%, while the remaining 91% is driven by differences in demand. In turn, these income-related demand differences are partially explained by education, nutrition knowledge, and regional preferences. These findings contrast with discussions of nutritional inequality that emphasize supply-side issues such as food deserts. http://www.nber.org/papers/w24094 http://www.nber.org/papers/w24094
- WWLink 7y agoHeh. It's ironic that Trader Joe's tries to advertise that they are all about "low cost healthy food" because I don't exactly see them clamoring to open a store in the lower income parts of CA. It's always in the affluent neighborhoods.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoMany of the lower income neighborhoods in CA have demographics that tend to shop more at ethnic markets. I wouldn't be surprised if they had a hard time competing against carnicerias like Northgate
- casefields 7y agoThat's not why they avoid those neighborhoods. It's because they steal. That's the problems the big supermarkets have out here in Los Angeles when maintaining stores in poorer neighborhoods.
- pupdogg 7y agoThis is sad! I don’t buy groceries at the dollar store but any and every time I’m there, I will repeat to myself that whoever came up with this idea was a genius...there are so many useful products for sale at the dollar store that majority of the people don’t think about and instead buy at 200-500% markup at other retailers. I almost always buy all greeting cards, balloons and wrapping paper from the dollar store. Thank you for existing!
- ErikAugust 7y agoI worked in a supermarket in high school and in college. We had a produce section. Even a decent selection of organic. We still had a large segment of shoppers who stocked up on 3 liter sodas and microwaveable pizzas, exactly the kind of stuff people can now buy for cheaper at a dollar store. My guess is banning dollar stores is a form of lobbying by their competition.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jariel 7y agoThere are no such things as 'food deserts' and the healthiest food is in fact the cheapest: it's in the produce section. Kale and organic bananas are more expensive, but most veggies are ridiculously cheap. Meat on sale is not so bad. Processed food is more expensive. "“We can statistically conclude that the effect on healthy eating from opening new supermarkets was negligible at best,” So people given a choice don't eat healthy? How is this news? The poor are more likely to smoke as well - and that's expensive. But the Dollar Store and Wallmart are giving vast, vast surpluses in wealth to the poor by offering them really cheap, off brand stuff that's pretty much as good as the branded stuff. They might be contributing to the material wealth of the poor more than any other thing. If they didn't exist we'd be thinking: 'Stuff is cheap to make, we pay so much for 'brand' - how can we get inexpensive every day items to the poor'? Well, that's called the Dollar Store. Maybe we can spend more time teaching kids to cook basic meals in school? I don't know the answer but these do-gooders I feel are barking up the wrong tree.
- habosa 7y agoWhen you say food is "expensive" that has to factor in preparation time. That's what makes processed food so "cheap" is that it's pretty much ready to eat, at most needs 5m in the microwave. Yes if you buy bulk produce and beans and rice and take the time to prepare it well you can eat healthy and save money but it's hard to make that choice when you're comparing it to something delicious looking low effort junk food.
- debateyourself 7y agoYou're saying the people are the problem. Demand determines the types of stores.
- SaxonRobber 7y agoThere are food deserts, they are the places where residents will spend hours taking public transit just to go to the grocery store because they are too poor to own a car. This fucks with your life, it will be a challenge to get to the store every week and fresh produce will expire too quickly, so you need to stock up on preserved and canned goods. And when you get home after work and fridge is empty and the kids are hungry, you will end up going to a McDonald’s or Gas station or whatever is close and just picking what you can get. If you can’t believe this, then you have lived too privileged of a life.
- whatthesmack 7y agoIt seems a tad elitist to 1) prevent dollar stores from opening, and 2) force existing ones to sell more expensive food. What if that dollar store food is a person’s only financial option? Forcing them to buy something they cannot afford is unhelpful. This sounds like a supermarket lobby or politicians that think they know better than the people doing the shopping about their own situation. I live a comfortable life and would love to see people eat healthily, but this is just more “government knows best” attitude, when the reality is that oneself knows one’s own situation the best. Let people make their own decisions.
- gonzo41 7y ago-- I live a comfortable life and would love to see people eat healthily. Would you live a slightly less comfortable life to see other people eat healthy? Food is expensive, but I'm sure there's fat in your budget. I agree banning dollar food stores is elitist, but it's also incredibly myopic by those in power to not also address the root cause which is you have a segment of the population that can't afford good food and has to consume food that exposes them to a greater set of negative health consequences. Raising minimum wages, and progressive taxation would go along way to fix a lot of this. \_(:|)_/
- busymom0 7y agoRaising minimum wage does the exact opposite. There’s a reason why Amazon and Walmart wants higher minimum wage because they can afford it but the small businesses can’t. Also raising the minimum wage does nothing but make the person who was already making slightly above the minimum wage now get paid less because everybody isn’t going to get a wage raise (and if they did then we are back to square one). AOC’s previous employer The Coffee Shop which was a major diner in NYC had to shut down last year because they couldn’t afford a $2 raise in the minimum wage.
- barry-cotter 7y ago> the root cause which is you have a segment of the population that can't afford good food These people don’t exist. Nutritionally complete diets that are very cheap include parties and milk, beans and rice, peanut butter and bread. If you add vitamin supplements or practically any meat that isn’t totally lean or any fruits or vegetables you will be perfectly healthy. Food is cheap enough that in Mexico the problem is obesity, not malnutrition. The US is a lot richer than Mexico.
- habosa 7y agoYou can't tell people what to eat. Figure out how to tell the market to tell them what to eat. What's next, banning the dollar menu at McDonald's? When something is the last resort, like dollar store food, taking it away doesn't help anyone.
- dawnerd 7y ago> What's next, banning the dollar menu at McDonald's? McDonalds basically already did that themselves. They left it up to the franchise owners and guess what? Every one I've seen have removed everything. Taco Bell on the other hand...
- olliej 7y agoHere’s the problem: unhealthy food is cheaper than healthy food. (Functionally) making cheap food illegal is nonsense. Another common oversight is that cooking food takes time, Refrigeration costs money, etc, etc
- stickfigure 7y ago"Let them eat cake!"
- jmpman 7y agoEBT (food stamps) should be modified to only work for healthy food (however one wants to describe that), and dollar stores will then offer that food.
- whb07 7y agoEven if you signed up a ship to home large box of healthy food, you’re delusional if they would divert their shitty food budget to it. Everyone knows eating healthy and exercise is good for you. Yet few people do it, to include the middle and upper classes.
- jmpman 7y agoIf they can’t but Doritos, maybe they’ll buy apples - is likely delusional. They’ll likely buy flour, lard and sugar and make donuts.
- alphabettsy 7y agoAbsolutely the wrong approach.
- JDiculous 7y agoHow about ending poverty instead so that poor people don't have to eat at the dollar store because that's all they can afoord.
- abcpassword 7y agoI imagine you have never been poor or lived in poor neighborhoods. These people don’t give two shits about nutrition.
- Havoc 7y agoSeems quite tone deaf. Eating healthy is quite expensive - either in money or time/equipment. It's not exactly a coincidence that poor students have a rep for Ramen noodles.
- interestica 7y agoYeah, but then you can move onto the amazing fancy ramen. And it's not cheap.
- epicgiga 7y agoThese anti-pleb AHEM I mean anti poor diet measures will improve the overall demographic quality AHEM I mean health of our city's occupants. All claims of "forced gentrification" are absurd. We do this out of genuine disgust AHEM I mean compassion towards the lower classes.
- mcadenhe 7y agoI think banning dollar stores will just mean people buy their honey buns and hot pockets elsewhere. Curtailing liberties like this seems to throw the baby out with the bathwater. The actual problem is not the substance, but the abuse of the substance. Drinking too much, smoking too much, eating too much junk. We abuse because it's gratifying. If only the delayed gratification of moderation could compete on the daily. I think the most productive thing that can be done right now is to discuss what we as a society could do to support people who are in pursuit of delayed gratification. How might we add components of immediate gratification to delayed gratification? For instance, if you're trudging through something and the end is still out of sight, just hearing a, "you're doing a good job", can be immediately gratifying.
- wsxcde 7y agoI feel both sides are making reasonable points. On the one hand, telling people where they ought to buy their food from does seem like government overreach. On the other hand, there's considerable evidence that people's nutritional choices are terrible for their own and their children's health. But there's an obvious way to resolve this debate! Run these laws as A/B trials across demographically similar neighborhoods. Track people's health outcomes over the course of the experiment. If the laws seem to be working in making people healthier and happier, keep them. And if they don't, just drop the law. We're drowning in data! There's no need to go back to the world of Socrates/Plato to try and figure everything out via thought experiments in one's own head!
- jamespitts 7y agoRather than focus on the dollar stores, the city should focus on itself and its role in the problem. The structure of the street, zoning, parking requirements, vast distances between living places and stores, etc. are key to the existence of the big box stores. The structure chosen by the city planners years ago literally makes the big box store feasible to economically exist, and reduces the feasibility of mom and pop stores with healthier options. Besides encouraging terrible food options, this situation has generated numerous other social and health-related problems. Take a walk in the poorest neighborhood in your region which has small-width streets, walking distance between homes and stores, stores on the sidewalk, and terrible parking options. In that neighborhood, you will find fruits and vegetables being sold by mom and pops, and far less prominence of dollar stores.
- crispyambulance 7y ago> you will find fruits and vegetables being sold by mom and pops, and far less prominence of dollar stores. Yes, it depends on the city and even the particular neighborhood within the city but cornershops still exist, and there are still vendors selling produce from carts/trucks at relatively low cost. What's missing from the article, however, are indoor markets. These are facilities that contain many vendors who rent out stalls/floor-space. Sort of like a farmer's market but with less yuppies. These types of arrangements have been around for since the 19th century. In Baltimore, they're city-operated. You can get everything from bok-choy to pigs feet. These kinds of markets provide farmers, bakers, or small grocery operators and opportunity to run their business without having the burden of real-estate or a leasing out a building.
- nkoren 7y agoEmigrating from the US to the UK, that was one of the biggest wins for me: ubiquitous small shops, within walking distance, where I can buy fresh vegetables. What a revelation! I've come to see the existence of such shops (and the zoning and population densities necessary to support them) as an absolute minimum requirement for a "liveable" neighborhood.
- bertjk 7y agoWhy is it assumed that mom & pop stores will opt to carry healthier options?
- loraa 7y agoIt's like gun bans. Anyone who thinks these type of illusions make sense need to shake their heads.
- loraa 7y agoAlso poor people when given the chance will eat junk food. Many poor people are not poor by chance but poor by stupidity.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sneak 7y agoIncreasingly, I find bogus restrictions on what one can do with the land that they own to be tyrannical. Is there any real point to zoning other than coddling residential purchaser future land values and de-risking their investment?
- useragent86 7y agoIndeed. I's hard to imagine why an entrepreneur would risk investing in land and building a business when a few years later the government might artificially put him out of business with arbitrary restrictions.
- jstewartmobile 7y agoNot everything in the produce section is an avocado. Many fruits/vegetables--especially ones in-season--are cheaper than junk food. Fact of the matter is, poors don't want them. If the inventory sold, the stores would carry it. Covert gentrification maneuver. None of these city-libs give an actual damn about minorities and poors.
- hurricanetc 7y agoWhat lengths we will go to blame anyone but ourselves.
- petagonoral 7y agoThis just seems like a puff piece for Republican party values. Not journalism. Not an opinion piece. An ad.
- elfexec 7y agoAs another commenter pointed out, this seems like dollar stores' competition with deeper pockets just trying to get rid of them. If cities truly cared about their residents'poor diets, they would ban the foods these people are buying ( soda, junk food, microwavable garbage, etc ). Once the dollar stores close, then their customers would have to buy their junk food at a supermarket. Also, I'd suspect that Costco, Walmart and large supermarket chains lead far more to poor diets and especially obesity than dollar stores.
- RickJWagner 7y agoThat's just a bad idea. The Nanny State cannot legislate people into making the decisions they need to make.
- _bxg1 7y agoDollar stores seem like a short-sighted target. What if we treated hyper-sugary/calorically-empty packaged snacks the way we do cigarettes? Ban colorful packaging, mandate huge health warning labels, give them their own special tax. Maybe you could even require people to be 18 to purchase them, forcing parents to be responsible for the decision. Dollar stores (and other stores that don't fit into such a narrow category) would be unable to sell nearly as many and would be forced to introduce better options, or they just wouldn't make money off of snacks at all.
- drharby 7y agoSounds like anticompetitive muscling out with a trivial and nondata supported claim for justification. If diets were a real concern of governments, there exists more appropriate policy measures, but passing laws that apply pressure on the free market with no effect on the bottomline of a city's budget is just easy so I can see why they are doing it.
- cascom 7y agoThe time, scale, infrastructure question seems to be missing from this conversation. For example a roast chicken dinner with rice and vegetables that serves ~4 can be had for ~$10 - which is pretty healthy and seems very cost effective. But you need to assume a. You’re feeding ~4 and not one, you have a home with an oven (and not just say a microwave), you have the time to go shopping, an hour of time to cook (maybe only 15min of active time), and the basic home economics skills to execute on this.
- fortran77 7y agoIf "food desserts" really exist, and the market isn't solving the problem, then the Government, working for the Citizens, should attempt to open a grocery story in an afflicted neighborhood, to meet the perceived need. Think of it as a jobs program.
- LocalH 7y agoThe best way for a government to increase the health of its citizens is to ban things like high fructose corn syrup, and provide incentives to those who purchase healthier food. The buck doesn’t just stop at the dollar store industry.
- phendrenad2 7y agoSupermarkets sell the same snacks - so how will this help anything? Whoever came up with this is highly out of touch with reality.