3 ms·
> That said, I've seen two family members die from terminal cancer and in both cases, they would have been better served by hospice rather than spending the las
by masklinn 7y ago
> That said, I've seen two family members die from terminal cancer and in both cases, they would have been better served by hospice rather than spending the last year of their life in chemo. I felt like it was a money grab by doctors. Their end of life oncology treatment cost the insurance company a couple hundred thousand dollars each
On that subject I very strongly recommend Atul Gawande's "Being Mortal".
> I felt like it was a money grab by doctors.
I don't think that's what it is, and Gawande's book (where he speaks as both a surgeon and having had relatives — including parents — go through this) comforted me in that opinion. Rather:
* doctors generally are not trained in this sort of end-of-life care recommendations
* it's easy for a disconnect and misunderstanding to occur between, or for doctors to present alternatives but fail to notice the patient or family doesn't really understand (especially the implications of the various alternative)
* it is common for families to try for survival at essentially all costs (including intrusive and uncomfortable), and hard for doctors to disagree, sometimes at the result of (2) above but not always
* doctors are human and tend to get blinkered by what they do know, and what they do know is usually treatment
One interesting item (of many, the book is barely 200 pages but full of stuff) is Gawande's mention of Ezekiel J. Emanuel and Linda L. Emanuel's "Four Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship." which basically identifies a range from "paternalistic" (doctor knows best and takes all decisions) to "informative" (where the doctor is provides facts & figures and possibly options but no insight).
- DataWorker 7y agoThis might be the best post in this thread. I think you can see a lot of the paternalistic orientation on display even in this thread. I think it’s that sort of hubris which causes people to react in the opposite direction and reject the whole thing. So who to blame for me is clear, it’s the doctors.