3 ms·
> Still, a group of online cancer truthers have zeroed in on chemotherapy as the ultimate example of the hubris and greed of Western medicine and Big Pharma. A
by rayiner 7y ago
> Still, a group of online cancer truthers have zeroed in on chemotherapy as the ultimate example of the hubris and greed of Western medicine and Big Pharma.
Anti-vaxxers and chemotherapy truthers are employ only somewhat more extreme forms of the fallacious mode of reasoning that dominates today’s media. Open up pretty much any article about a complex issue, and you’ll see the pattern. Relevant facts will be combined with irrelevant ones and set in a narrative arc, a story with clearly identified villains and victims. The reader knows what conclusions she is supposed to draw based on how she feels about the villains and victims, as opposed to objective big picture analysis.
Take a simple example: Trump’s recent proposed revisions to NEPA, the federal law that requires government entities to perform environmental review of infrastructure projects: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/09/climate/trump-nepa-environment.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/09/climate/trump-nepa-enviro.... The whole thing is set within a narrative arc about Trump’s deregulatory agenda, with Trump as the villain. Isolated quotes from individuals are provided, making various assertions. Nowhere is there any analysis of objective facts by which someone could evaluate the proposal. For example, there is no mention of the fact that European countries have environmental review rules even more streamlined than what Trump is proposing. There is no mention of the median environmental review period of transit projects under NEPA (6.7 years), studies that have been done estimating the costs of delaying infrastructure projects (trillions), etc. Nothing to permit objective evaluation, just narrative, victims, and the villain. This is how journalists are taught to write and this is how they do write.
Anti-vaxxers and chemo truthers simply engage in a somewhat more extreme version of this reasoning. They likewise ignore the big picture analysis. Chemotherapy, for example, clearly causes harms, but has even greater benefits. There are many studies quantifying those harms relative to the benefits. Instead of looking at that analysis, they elevate the narrative above all else. “Big drug companies,” “western medicine,” etc., are the villains. The narrative is that those greedy players are suppressing natural remedies out of a desire for profit. Within that narrative, a few anecdotes about people getting better without cancer are all it takes to make the narrative plausible.
If you read Matt Taibbi’s work, for example, is he so different? He uses “Wall Street” and “big banks” in the same way as these folks use “western medicine.” He constructs a narrative where the entire global banking system, and practices employed by nearly every advanced democracy, are causing harm in the pursuit of profit. The experts are hoodwinking you, but he and a few others have seen through it! Throwing in a few anecdotes of misconduct or bad behavior seals the deal and makes the narrative believable.