4 ms·
It's easy to solve the problem of science ignoring the ghosts and visions. All you need is a good experiment. Preferably something reproducible like saying "Bee
by gus_massa 7y ago
It's easy to solve the problem of science ignoring the ghosts and visions. All you need is a good experiment. Preferably something reproducible like saying "Beetlejuice Beetlejuice Beetlejuice". An alternative is something that can convince Randi, but a lot of people will claim he sell out.
My favorite example is high temperature superconductivity. In 1970 if you claim that you have a high temperature superconductor people will dismiss you. It was not theoretically impossible, but all tries had failed and there was no theoretical support to expect one. But one day, someone made a high temperature superconductor and published a difficult to follow recipe, and then someone else published an easy to follow recipe, and now everyone with a good lab can make a high temperature superconductor.
- krapp 7y agoThe problem's been solved. Every supernatural claim that can be tested has been tested, and every conceivable experiment done, the data collected, and the results are in... ghosts and other paranormal phenomena aren't real.
- DougN7 7y agoDark matter is the ghostly realm. And boom, suddenly it hasn’t all been disproven :)
- krapp 7y ago>And boom, suddenly it hasn’t all been disproven :) It still has been, because none of the claims made about ghosts can be explained by the known properties of dark matter (whatever it is.) For example, people claim to see ghosts, but dark matter doesn't interact with the electromagnetic spectrum. You can't see something that doesn't reflect light.
- kd5bjo 7y agoCameras can't see anything that doesn't interact with the electromagnetic spectrum, but most people see things that don't physically exist from time to time; they're called dreams or hallucinations, depending on context.
- krapp 7y ago>but most people see things that don't physically exist from time to time; they're called dreams or hallucinations, depending on context. Yes, and that's what ghosts are, figments of the imagination and thus not real.
- DougN7 7y agoThat’s my point though - so far dark matter only exists in equations (and our imagination) and isn’t real (that we’ve been able to prove). It’s got as much proof as ghosts. That will surely change but we’re not there now.
- krapp 7y ago> so far dark matter only exists in equations (and our imagination) and isn’t real (that we’ve been able to prove). It’s got as much proof as ghosts. Incorrect... there is plenty of evidence for dark matter beyond "equations and our imaginations[0,1]," and certainly more evidence for dark matter than for ghosts. [0]https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/five-reasons-we-think-dark-matter-exists-a122bd606ba8 https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/five-reasons-we-think-... [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter#Observational_evidence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter#Observational_evid...
- kd5bjo 7y ago> figments of the imagination and thus not real Physics doesn’t have exclusive domain over the term “real.” Dreams and hallucinations belong primarily to Psychology, but they are real phenomena that we can and do study.
- lostmsu 7y agoThere is a recent take on dark energy though.
- gus_massa 7y agoYou can't prove that ghost don't exist. For a technical discussion, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability What if ghost only realiablily appear when someone dies and there is a big neutrino flux? Have someone build a room for dying people in the path of a big neutrino beam? What if neutrinos push ghost, so they are pushed to deep space by the neutrinos of the Sun? I guess the best place to put a ghost detector is at the top of a hospital and try to measure a passing ghost at midnight. I obviously don't expect neither of these scenarios to be real, but I guess nobody had measured them. Going back to my superconductor example, let's imagine that you go back in time to 1950 and say that the best superconductor is a ceramic, but you don't remember the exact formula. Hey, you don't even remember the formula of any ceramic material. They will think you are nut. Someone will even try with the wrong ceramic. Or with the wrong composition. Or let it catch some humidity and ruin the sample. Everyone will get convinced that all the conceivable ceramic are tested and it is impossible. They are not even conductors!
- foogazi 7y ago> You can't prove that ghost don't exist. Can you prove that ghosts exist?
- LyndsySimon 7y agoThat's not the point. It is possible to prove ghosts exist (if they exist). It is not possible to prove ghosts do not exist (whether or not they exist).
- yokaze 7y agoSo, ghosts are "not even wrong" (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong). Your story about the superconductor shows how pseudo-science is different from science in practicality every step, despite trying to pose as it. - Ghost potentially exist, we have uncountable "theories" that could explain how, we just have to find the evidence to prove that what we want to be true actually is. Versus: - As we understand current theories based on the existing evidence, high temperature super-conductors are unlikely to exist. Let's spend a huge amount of effort and resources to prove that our understanding is incomplete. Ups, someone accidentally stumbled upon something that doesn't fit, and now we have to go to great lengths to actually formulate a hypothesis that fits the unexpected new evidence, and then we have to go to even more effort to test those hypothesises so maybe one stands the test of time to become a theory. Until we hopefully find something else that doesn't fit.
- yokaze 7y agoThat's a false dichotomy: It isn't "Science has been wrong before, so anything is possible" (https://theconversation.com/the-thinking-error-at-the-root-of-science-denial-96099 https://theconversation.com/the-thinking-error-at-the-root-o...) There are degrees of "wrongness" or likelihood. Pseudo-sciences exists practically as long as there have been sciences. With no evidence, and not for lack of trying. People really like to believe in that stuff. But with that track-record, it is on the rather wrong end of wrongness. Might be true, but on the likelihood of the Flying Spaghetti Monster. But, yes, a reproducible experiment by an independent party would be the way to go, On the other hand, the discovery of existence of high temperature superconductors while certainly baffling and had people scrambling to explain it, is exactly how science works. It was not completely out of the blue, we had a reasonable understanding of electromagnetism. But that "detail" didn't fit. It was just one more puzzle to solve, and it didn't invalidate everything we knew before. Also, there were gradual steps of increases of temperature of achieving high temperature supra conductivity. So, not "theoretically impossible", but rather "practically rather unlikely". A different ball-park then ghosts and visions. The healthy skepticism to high temperature supra-conductivity (and low temperature fusion) comes from the mantra "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" (Sagan), and a lot of pseudo-science people came with the claims for supra-conductivity but without the evidence.