8 ms·
Unremovable malware found preinstalled on low-end smartphone sold in the US
- rahuldottech 7y agoThis is very common for low-end Android phones. I have seen and used many models from different companies (eg, Micromax, Gionee) (mostly Chinese) that remotely install apps or inject ads into the OS (notifications, home screen or lock screen). They also almost certainly are used to collect personal user data and sell it. Another bad thing is that these apps often come installed as "system apps", so you can't uninstall or disable them, or change permissions :(
- tandr 7y agohttps://www.xda-developers.com/uninstall-carrier-oem-bloatware-without-root-access/ https://www.xda-developers.com/uninstall-carrier-oem-bloatwa... I have used these instructions in the past to remove things I don't need from Samsung phone. (There is also xda threads that talking about it as well, pointing what apps could be removed) I am not 100% sure if "cheap" phones would allow to do this though.
- pmlnr 7y agoI hope people remember when Kindles were possible to be bought with burned-in ads for cheaper.
- Jeff_Brown 7y agoIn which case the buyer knew what they were getting into, yes?
- jzwinck 7y agoI too hope people remember that, because it was the case one minute ago. You save $20 or so by having ads on your Kindle when it is sleeping. The ads are not burned in, they are delivered via WiFi the same as other Kindle content. I don't see the problem with it.
- wmeredith 7y agoYou can also go into the settings, pay the extra $20, and turn them off.
- jabbany 7y agoThis. In fact this is quite common in Chinese domestic market phones too. E.g. The Vivo branded (subsidiary of BBK who is also the parent of Oppo and Oneplus) phones are generally domestic market targeted and use FuntouchOS which has arguably adware/spyware built in to the OS level. It's also impossible to flash a custom ROM as it has a locked bootloader.
- xfitm3 7y agoPersonally I consider this to be all phones: the baseband firmware is a blob that does who knows what, and is likely the weakest component of nearly every phone on the market. Most baseband processors are connected via DMA. Prior discussion from 2016: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10905643 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10905643
- mirimir 7y agoI'm reminded of the 90s joke about Windows PCs being pwned within minutes after going online. That is, going online directly via dial-up modem, rather than through a router. So yeah, the baseband firmware is a huge vulnerability. But if you use a separate modem/router, and disable the onboard baseband, that's far less of an issue. And with the PinePhone, it's easy: https://wiki.pine64.org/index.php/PinePhone#Killswitch_configuration https://wiki.pine64.org/index.php/PinePhone#Killswitch_confi...
- teruakohatu 7y agoIt was not a joke. I once saw a new WinXP install get hacked soon after being plugin into a modem. The Register reported the avaerge time to infection was 20 minutes. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/19/infected_in20_minutes/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/19/infected_in20_minut...
- mirimir 7y agoOK, I guess that "joke" was a poor choice. More like "wry observation".
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoNo worries - Until SP2, Windows XP’s security was very much a joke :)
- Gibbon1 7y agoBack around 2000 I tried restoring Windows from the original CD and the thing would get hacked before it could install it's updates. Eventually punted and bought a hard drive with Windows pre-installed.
- cs702 7y ago...and on high-end smartphones too, arguably. Consider how difficult it would be to remove from any smartphone any piece of software that you as a consumer don't want (e.g., baseband firmware, call-home components, data-collection services, etc.).
- butz 7y agoIs it really unremovable? What about flashing custom AOSP build?
- droithomme 7y agoSure, why don't you buy these figure out how to do it then publish easy to understand instructions for the average purchaser to follow. Thanks!
- kick 7y ago"Requires domain knowledge" is not the same as "unremovable," so it's a valid question.
- rimunroe 7y agoThat’s a needless distinction for the vast majority of users. I imagine anything is removable with enough domain knowledge and the right equipment.
- Jeff_Brown 7y ago"with enough domain knowledge and the right equipment" you could just build your phone from scratch. Without specialization and trust, there would be no economy, and humanity would be immeasurably worse off.
- alasdair_ 7y agoOnce one person knows how to do it, they can document and even automate the process, then other people don’t need to have any domain knowledge.
- okcando 7y agoThis may be the dream but is not and has not been the reality of rooting phones and flashing them with custom software. It's ugly, it's error-prone, and the software that attempts to simplify it doesn't and is of unknown trustworthiness. A very unhappy path. Absolutely not a reasonable option for the typical user, and an even less reasonable expectation that they should do it or should have known to.
- droithomme 7y agoIs this too much different than the unremovable malware found preinstalled in high-end smartphones sold in the US? Even big brands like Samsung are riddled with insidious malware these days, all which you consent to when clicking through the registration screens. We need regulation banning all this. Will never happen since malware benefits those who crave endemic surveillance.
- ggggtez 7y agoThat's not "malware". Adware maybe, but malware does assume something more ... malicious. Asking for consent is annoying, but we are talking about stuff that doesn't ask for your consent.
- jenkstom 7y agoI bought three of these for my 8 year old triplets from twigby.com. I was really upset with twigby, but I guess they weren't the ones that did it. These phones would continuously install weird apps no matter what I did. I even had them locked down with the google family app and they still did their thing. I upgraded to to Moto G7 Plays and they are not only faster, they don't continuously install malware.
- swiley 7y agoI had a similar experience with a track phone I bought as a cheap balloon tracker: As soon as I put it on WiFi it pulled down maybe a gigabyte of random crap (it looked like mostly games but also “facebook” and some other things like that.) It refused to install termux until it had installed a dozen or so worthless things.
- TrueDuality 7y agoA lot of the comments here are complaining about trash software that exists on other phones that isn't removable. The difference here is that it isn't just garbage ware that might have vulnerabilities like the stuff Samsung puts on its phone, this is actively malicious. This especially sucks because the people who can't afford a good phone will pay not only in having a poorer user experience but they'll have their financial and social media information stolen as soon as its used on these devices. That means the people who can least afford (via both time and money) to deal with identity theft will be the ones hit the hardest.
- kop316 7y agoHeh, it's funny you say that. I just broke my phone and had to go get a new one. I was holding out for the PinePhone/Librem 5 to be useful enough that I wouldn't need another Android device. The cheapest device that I trusted was the Pixel 3a, and that's because I can cleanly install GrapheneOS and not have google play install. That was $400. It was very tempting to get a $100 phone, but this was my exact worry.
- dathinab 7y agoThe problem is that it's increasingly harder to run a non Google certified Android phone. For example many German (EU?) Banks now have some form of 2FA system for credit card payments which requires a Android/iPhone app which does only run on non rooted certified phones. (Through it should be noted that in Germany credit card is not the major payment method and many people don't even have one, instead dbit cards with V-Pay, giropay, etc. are dominant. ) As a site note this is also the case for their online banking Apps, but you can just use their website instead.
- jimmaswell 7y agoThere's no malware here that I can see, simply an auto-update mechanism that could theoretically be abused, like every auto-update mechanism (Chrome, Windows 10..)
- JohnFen 7y agoI pretty much consider all auto-update (and telemetry, for that matter) mechanisms that I can't disable to be malware.
- awinter-py 7y agothe department of the interior made disabling all phone-home (including auto updates) a condition of their DJI drone buy and cautioned that the level of testing they need to do for future updates is a large expense of the project
- JohnFen 7y agoIn my opinion, the prevalence of software that I consider to be malware has become so extreme that I don't consider any smartphone to be safe enough to use anymore. Although I'm marginally OK with my current one (an antique that I have a google-free ROM and a lot of security installed on), it will probably die within the next couple of years. At or (hopefully) before that time, I'll have completed my move out of smartphones entirely.
- makerofspoons 7y agoThe PinePhone will be launching soon, and you could install any flavor of mobile Linux you want if you are still interested in owning a smart phone: https://www.pine64.org/pinephone/ https://www.pine64.org/pinephone/
- JohnFen 7y agoYes, I've already investigated the PinePhone. I have nothing against it -- there are a great many things about it that are wonderful -- but I don't find it particularly appealing on the whole. My escape plan is to use the dumbest feature phone I can find and also carry a pocket computer (running standard Linux) that lacks cell capability.
- spurgu 7y agoWhy not combine those two into a Cosmo Communicator or its predecessor Gemini PDA? I'd love to get a Cosmo but I'd hate to carry it around everywhere due to its bulkiness. I guess that might be your concern as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 7y agoYes, it's much too bulky. I've also become very fond of the idea of keeping my compute and my cell physically separate. That's not really necessary from a security perspective as long as I can install my own copy of Linux on it, but the idea gives me warm fuzzies.
- ggggtez 7y agoI thought malware was the business model of low-end smart phones. Random game company pays them to install their game on x000 devices. It's really a question of when, not if, those companies would ship malware. You can't imagine they are actually vetting any of that stuff they install.
- w3bshark 7y agoI know one of the companies who ships the software embedded with privileges which then installs the garbageware apps (designated by the carrier). The garbageware apps are definitely not vetted to my knowledge.
- userbinator 7y agoActually unremovable, i.e. unrootable and with a locked bootloader? That's pretty bad. On the other hand, when I looked into the Android community a few years ago, it was almost "common knowledge" that a lot of the cheap and unbranded ones come with preinstalled crap, but they're unlocked by default and easily rootable so you can remove it, and there's various guides on how to do that and make a custom ROM.
- hpoe 7y agoPeople keep focusing on how these Chinese phones have malware and are being used in the West but I tend to believe that is more of a nice side effect, the real purpose is for China to keep a tight leash on those inside it's borders. I mean if we think about it they have to monitor, survail and keep in check more people than the entire US and EU combined.
- apta 7y agoYep, people keep buying Chinese phones without thinking. How does the government allow them to be imported?