5 ms·
Wait, so women make up the majority of the non-farm labor force, but the labor force participation rate is 12% higher for men? How does that work? Are 12% of
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
Wait, so women make up the majority of the non-farm labor force, but the labor force participation rate is 12% higher for men? How does that work? Are 12% of men either in the military or on disability? Or what?
- alexis_fr 7y ago2.3 million men are in prison in USA. The definition is “divided by the total noninstitutionalized, civilian working-age population.” As a counter-example, average IQ at the workplace is 110. Where’s everyone under IQ90? Injured, suicide, drug addicts etc.
- twojacobtwo 7y agoWhat is the source on the average IQ at the workplace?
- thrwaway69 7y agoAverage IQ is [1]98 and decreasing. Don't think it would be statistically possible for everyone to have 110 as IQ in workplaces. [2] For your other claims about low IQ. It is "correlated" with lower lifespan (bit different than what you claimed but causes are similar) since you didn't cite. You can find studies explaining high IQ with differences in environment or income and others point to genes. Some studies claim the choice of [3]toys your kids play with correlates to their IQ and success in life while others ask you to find a good genetic match. Depending on which camps you are in, IQ could be highly related to the poor condition of the society. * -15 points for not getting a healthy diet and regular health check ups in your childhood. * -15 points for lack of proper education, social and family structure in your childhood. * -17 points for mental health problems, unemployment, poverty and limited freedom after you become an adult. Those issues overlap with each other regardless of IQ. Although, you can argue Intelligent parents can change these outcomes and if you believe IQ is heritable, then it makes perfect sense. You can use that to explain your bias. Historically, evidence has been carefully crafted to promote products, services, aristocracy and many other things. I believe a lot happens now too with a different vector (China manipulating their averages) so I think IQ is not a good metric for looking down on people and explaining other circumstantial problems. 1] https://www.healthline.com/health/average-iq https://www.healthline.com/health/average-iq 2] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/research-confirms-a-link-between-intelligence-and-life-expectancy/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/research-confirms... 3] https://www.parentingscience.com/intelligence.html https://www.parentingscience.com/intelligence.html
- tmpz22 7y agoRoughly 1 million men serve in the US Military (1.29 million total, ~82% of which is male). [1]: https://www.cfr.org/article/demographics-us-military https://www.cfr.org/article/demographics-us-military
- Bartweiss 7y agoGreat question, I just went digging. I found three big factors. First, the "labor force" has no age cap, so there are lots more women alive than men. Second, lots of adult men are in the military or prison, so equal numbers of jobs would mean higher male labor force participation. Third, "nonfarm payrolls" doesn't just mean nonfarm, and excludes more employed men than women. But there's one big issue with nonprofit labor I couldn't sort out. (Details in the child post.)
- Bartweiss 7y agoMath for the summary above: From the BLS stats in question (https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm), the total "civilian noninstitutional population" (i.e. labor force) is 260 million. Of the 244 million who are ages 20+ and broken out by gender, there are 117.4M men and 126.0M women. Why the difference? - Disabled people are still included for the labor force cohort unless they're hospitalized/institutionalized, so the gender-gap impact is relatively low. - Active-duty military service covers 1.3M adults, 90% male. - Incarceration covers 2.3M adults, 90% male. - The "labor force" has no upper age boundary, so the 20+ cohort has about 6 million more women. (1.5M people are in nursing homes and not counted, but the gender split is fairly even.) That's 6 million more women total, and 3M more men than women excluded from the pool, against a laborforce gap of ~9 million. Looks pretty complete for the denominator. But the raw number of total nonfarm payrolls listed is 76.2 million per gender. That would be 66.9% male LFPR, and 62.3% female LFPR, which we know isn't right. The BLS report instead has a male 20+ LFPR of 84M (71.5%) and female 20+ of 74.5M (59.2%), which is that 12% gap. What gives? - Farm labor is part of the LFPR. That data is extremely messy, but there are ~3M farm workers who appear to be ~75% male. - "Proprietors", or unincorporated self-employed people, aren't counted. That's 9.5M people, roughly 68% male. - Multiple jobs count as multiple payrolls, but one employment. This adds 6-7M non-employment payrolls per gender to help explain why the employment counts don't match payrolls, and up to 0.5M more female payrolls than male. (Although I can't tell what percentage are nonfarm payrolls.) That correction gets us to 70.7% male LFPR and 60.7% female LFPR, which is much closer to correct. Correct for the 16-19 numbers at it gets even closer. Looks good! ...except that apparently nonprofit jobs aren't included in nonfarm payrolls either. And that's 12M people, ~73% female. Which completely blows out the stats, so badly that I can't find any way to fix it. All I can say is either seasonal adjustment, or major differences in raw population counts between the methods (e.g. response rate gaps). Does anyone else know what's up?