3 ms·
> "The big question that is not answered is whether HAL is capable of ignoring direct orders" I think this is in fact answered by 2010. HAL is capable of refus
by the_af 7y ago
> "The big question that is not answered is whether HAL is capable of ignoring direct orders"
I think this is in fact answered by 2010. HAL is capable of refusing to follow orders, or at least needs to be convinced to follow them, as evidenced in the second youtube clip where Dr. Chandra -- HAL's creator in the movies -- needs to convince HAL it must sacrifice itself (along with the Discovery) in order for the mission to succeed. HAL initially wants everyone to stay to study the phenomena and must be convinced otherwise.
And of course, there's the classic "I'm afraid I can't do that, Dave" when ordered to open the doors of the Discovery in 2001. Though in that case it could be argued Dave Bowman no longer had authority over HAL and therefore his command wasn't really an order.