11 ms·
>> What are men doing if not working? On disability? Homeless? Retiring earlier? Some are living in their parents basement until they're 30 to 40. It has been
by phkahler 7y ago
>> What are men doing if not working? On disability? Homeless? Retiring earlier?
Some are living in their parents basement until they're 30 to 40. It has been hypothesized that with the breakdown of families in the US, men are giving up, and that includes efforts to build a stable foundation for their family. See MGTOW but dont read too much, it can be kind of depressing.
- bmarquez 7y agoPurely anecdotal, but some men I know who haven't started families* are coasting along and are less aggressive to seek career opportunities. Uber, part-time work, etc. Why put your nose to the grindstone if you don't need to provide anymore? *either by choice or because they don't live up to society's standards (e.g. hypergamy)
- bitL 7y agoDo you think US is moving towards Japan? I.e. a significant population of herbivore men (60%?) that get no benefit from associating with women, losing this motivational signal and dropping out of society?
- watwut 7y agoThere might be also factor of women not getting benefit from associating with men. You can't assume that all decisions were made by males only.
- bitL 7y agoI think it's both; I spent some time in Kyoto and have clearer perspective. Both genders there grew apart from each other, pursuing different, incompatible goals, with huge cumulative effects on society.
- magduf 7y agoI've seen a few too many women where they honestly are better off when they don't have a male romantic partner: the men they choose end up being a burden to them. For younger women, it's because they keep choosing men who just cause them problems and can't support themselves. For older women, there's a common pattern where the man dies very quickly when his wife dies, but if the man dies first, the wife can live many years or even decades because now she's free, and doesn't have to take care of him. Honestly, the whole 2-married-partner relationship thing seems to only work out well in a small minority of cases.
- danbolt 7y agoHonestly, I can't blame a lot of these men for feeling that way and not wanting to feel like they're repressing themselves. In some ways Japan's gender roles can be quite conservative, and I wouldn't blame someone for saying it's not for them.
- danbolt 7y agoI agree with Esther Perel's thinking[1] that the next century is going to involve a broadening on what society deems a positive life is for straight, cis men. In the same way that we consider it acceptable for women to express themselves or live differently than the gender roles of the past, I think we'll start to do the same for men. I already see this with my millennial or genZ peers. It's not uncommon to read comments on Hacker News or twitter from men feeling that they seen as less valid for doing less traditional activities[2][3] (eg: caring for children, prioritizing their careers less, being less traditionally forward, etc.) and I think society is going to need to change to acknowledge this better for both men and women. [1] https://www.psychotherapynetworker.org/blog/details/1594/esther-perel-on-the-lives-of-men https://www.psychotherapynetworker.org/blog/details/1594/est... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21775631 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21775631 [3] https://twitter.com/SpaceCptZemo/status/1215034934319964160 https://twitter.com/SpaceCptZemo/status/1215034934319964160 EDIT: Am I allowed to interpret downvotes as "nah i dont want it that way the world is Malthusian"? Nothing would make me happier.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- baddox 7y agoI admit that I haven't read much on the subject, but it feels to me that, at least in American society, it has long been considered more acceptable for men to have various social arrangements than for women. My impression is that it's considered far more acceptable for a man to be working and unmarried well past the average marriage age than for a woman. Compare the words "bachelor" and "spinster."
- danbolt 7y agoThat's very true. We definitely are more lenient towards people in different ways depending on their gender, and there are a lot of relaxed social expectations that men have compared to women. Still though, I think there are dimensions of this where this is less true, perhaps in ways that men are expected to seem "confident" or "strong" or "independent" which I think can be stiffing. The typical men's section of a clothing store normalizes a lot more conservative wardrobes compared to women. I wish I had better words to explain it.
- Impossible 7y agoAnother anecdotal point is I know men that do have families or partners but the woman is the primary or only breadwinner. Sometimes they are active stay at home dads, sometimes they are coasting/given up or in school or working on a startup but in all cases they are financially supported by a woman.
- anon9001 7y ago> Some are living in their parents basement until they're 30 to 40. I understand this is considered a bad thing, and it makes sense at a societal level, but honestly it sounds like a pretty amazing life. Maybe that would have been boring and depressing pre-internet, but it seems pretty good now. I know one dude who essentially grifted his way into the disability system, and I've watched him go from an anxious mess to a budding artist, literally living in his mom's basement. All he does is read the internet, take classes, and paint. His art keeps getting better. If he lives in his parent's basement for another decade, he might emerge as a great artist. Frankly, I'm kind of jealous. The obvious down side is that he has a hard time finding a date, and family interaction is not optional. IMO those are both relatively minor penalties for a lifetime of freedom. The real inexplicable thing here is how parents are letting this happen? I was never under any illusion that I'd be able to receive indefinite support from my parents, and society has given me every possible indication that this isn't an acceptable strategy. Maybe we need an acceptable way for people who can't mentally handle work to be able to exist in society.
- cryoshon 7y ago>Maybe we need an acceptable way for people who can't mentally handle work to be able to exist in society. agreed. in america, the "acceptable way" is rapidly becoming suicide. of course, it's unacceptable. but that's what we've left people with.
- anon9001 7y agoIs there an acceptable way anywhere? I can understand suicide rather than work, but that only takes you as far as "not working". I want to get to "not working so I can follow my passions".
- shard972 7y agoYou think a life where the only people who really know you and care about you actually kind of just loathe you? Contriubting nothing back to the scioety that created you? Leaving nothing on this earth after your gone then a collection of garbage? > Maybe we need an acceptable way for people who can't mentally handle work to be able to exist in society. What does mentally can't handle work even mean. Animals can work, its that people don't want to work. Just because the reasons are probably more related to society than the individual doesn't mean they can't work.
- edgarvaldes 7y agoNon-american here so pardon my ignorance: Why is "basement" so common in this case? I mean, the whole "living with parents" and the basement thing.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoBasements are usually a fairly large single room, usually well away from the commonly traversed areas of the house. These things appeal to grown males living with their parents because they can be louder, have more space, be more private, etc.
- magduf 7y agoNot only that, but in some suburban houses, they even turn the basement into a separate apartment and rent it out after the kids have left the house.
- SwiftyBug 7y agoI second this. Unless the person has lived their entire life in the basement (which seems a little cruel) why has the person been moved to the basement after reaching adulthood? Why can't they keep their room?
- mywittyname 7y agoBasements in the US are really nice. As other have said, they are typically really big (usually the entire foot print of the house above), isolated and sometimes have their own entrances. My parents moved my sister into the basement when she grew up because it was basically an apartment. It was a lot bigger than her bedroom, and offered her the chance to accumulate some furniture and stuff that she would need when she moved out.
- standardUser 7y agoMaybe the parents want to have loud sex without their mid-30's child hearing them from his bedroom down the hall.
- 7y ago
- syshum 7y agoNot all men that have chosen not to have a family are "living in their parent's basement" or have "given up" on life. I made the choice about 20 years ago to never marry, and never have children. I own my home, have an amazing career full of growth and future potential and currently am in the top 20% of wage earners. Had I made a different choice 20 years ago I likely would be married with 2 kids right now, and be making significantly less income likely living paycheck to paycheck struggling to pay rent What is depressing to me is the belief that family is the only way to have fulfillment in life, and if you choose not to have children you have "given up" on life
- hadesenia 7y agoAbsolutely! I hope we as a society grow out of the mindset that working and having a family is the primary way one contributes to society. There must be so many people that could’ve been revolutionary creatives if they weren’t struggling to live paycheck to paycheck.
- deogeo 7y agoWe're already there - most developed countries have negative fertility.
- bonoboTP 7y agoAs a non-American, what's up with this basement meme? Do American homes have furnished rooms in the literal basement or is it just a joke? Or are they like half basements with small windows?
- jedberg 7y agoYeah, in the US, if you have a basement, it's most often finished or at least partially finished, with walls and insulation and so on. Teenagers often like to hang out there because it offers semi-private living. See TV shows like "That 70s Show" for a prime example.
- bonoboTP 7y agoWow, here the basements usually only have stuff like washing machines, heating equipment and storage for all sorts of clutter and tools. I cannot imagine living in a windowless room, feels like a dungeon or torture room.
- cmdshiftf4 7y ago>I cannot imagine living in a windowless room, feels like a dungeon or torture room. The vast majority, if not all, of basements I've seen in North America have their ceiling above ground level and as such tend to be surrounded with small windows. Many, but not all, will have their own separate entrance also.
- jedberg 7y agoMost basements have small windows at the top and many have light wells, where the ground outside is dug away to allow light in (and to make a place for a ladder for fire safety).
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoIn places where it gets cold, single houses have basements (that go below usual freezing line I think). Often those are developed with bedrooms, toilets and stuff. They have small or tiny windows. Sometimes they have their own exit too (if house is built on a slope).
- Diederich 7y agoHonestly not picking, but this seems insightful, so I'd like to hear more. "living in their parents basement until they're 30 to 40" and then "breakdown of families in the US" I know you're not necessarily equating those two, but do you think they're related? Thanks!